An Interesting Book

17%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 31, 1882

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 5.

Read the full edition

An Interesting Book.

I HAVE just read “The Problem of Human Life,” by A. W. Hall, and find some things in it of great value. The two chief points are his arguments against the immateriality of the soul and Darwin’s doctrine of evolution.
While the author strenuously contends for the immortality of the soul, he as zealously opposes the notion of the immateriality of anything,—soul, spirit, angel, or God. He shows up in a forcible light the absurdity of the popular ideas of the soul and its immateriality. He shows that the old arguments for the immortality of the soul drawn from its immateriality, will not stand a moment in the light of modern science. Then he boldly advocates the idea that the soul is a real, material being, inside the body of flesh, having the same organs precisely, only more finely organized.
The fallacy of this position is readily seen. What is the use of one material man inside of another? If he admits, as he does, that God can organize a living, thinking man out of matter, then he gives up the whole question of mind being independent of matter. Then a properly constructed physical organism can think. This is all we claim, and just what we see man to be. The publication of this book, therefore, so highly and widely indorsed as it seems to be by the religious press, is a remarkable evidence that the old theories of immortality are giving way. It is a surrender of more than half the battle-field.
To me, it seems that his arguments against the modern theory of evolution are wholly unanswerable. They are far ahead of anything I have seen. They are simple, taken from the most common facts, and easily remembered. Our ministers would do well to read the book, though of course they will have to winnow out much chaff.
D. M. CANRIGHT.