[The following is a letter written by a Congregationalist minister of Maine to a young brother in the city of Springfield, Ill., who was formerly a member of his church, but who has since embraced the views of Seventh-day Adventists. The reply was made by request of the latter, but failed to reach the minister, as his wife received it during his absence, and destroyed it immediately after reading. It seems a very poor way to gain the confidence of young converts, to refuse to hear both sides of a question in which they are interested; and the young brother to whom the letter was addressed thinks that professions of humility and brotherly love are a little doubtful when coupled with such a way of treating his letters.
[A. H. C.]
W———s, June 29, 1881.
DEAR FRIEND AND BROTHER IN CHRIST: I have received and read the tracts you sent me, and these are not the first of the kind I have read. I have also read books of the most talented authors, advocating the peculiar tenets which they set forth; and while I think I sit at the feet of Jesus, and am ready to receive any increase of true light, come it from what quarter or through what channel it may, I am not yet convinced that I am in error with regard to the Sabbath or the immortality of the human soul.
Those who argue for the seventh day as the Sabbath and the only day for the Christian Sabbath, and so make infidels of the church of God because they do not keep that day holy instead of the first, I look upon as in this thing “straining at a gnat and swallowing a camel.” They seem to make everything important relative to a proper observance of the Sabbath depend on a certain segment of time called the seventh day.
So far as time, in itself, is concerned, I do not suppose that any one hour or day is more holy than another. And certainly there is nothing holy in the name seventh. Were this the day well-nigh universally kept by Christians, instead of the first, I should not keep it any better as to religious exercises and a day of rest than I now do the first, and I think you would not, my brother. And then if you keep the seventh, or Saturday, you are not sure that you keep the exact time that the Jews did anciently in Palestine, or that they do now there. I am sure you do not. Then again, the change that has taken place from the seventh to the first, God never would have suffered in connection with his church and the gospel, had it been such a monstrous wrong and injury to the world.
Oh! how prone men are to get hold of some unimportant idea, and make a hobby of it, instead of devoting themselves to practical godliness. I don't know but some pretty good men would die if they could not fight the church of God on some line or other.
For my views on life eternal, and its opposite, eternal death, I refer you to Christ's words in John 17:3. I would give more for what he says on the matter than for all simply human reasonings. Please read, and ponder and pray. My interest in you is warm and tender. Do not readily give up old and tried truths for new and contradictory ones. Cling fast to the example of Christ. Our prayers and best wishes are for your temporal and spiritual good.
Fraternally, A. M——N.
REPLY.
SPRINGFIELD, JULY 9, 1881.
DEAR SIR: I have been requested by my cousin, W. H. Barker, to reply to your letter of June 29, in which you write to him pretty plainly on the Sabbath question. I will endeavor not to weary you with a very lengthy epistle, and yet notice the leading points in your letter.
In the first place, you speak of having read books by the most talented authors bearing on the subject, but mention none of their names, which would have been very gratifying, as your letter indicates that you have made a mistake in regard to their talent, or else have forgotten or withheld the most important features of their books. For I am quite certain that our leading writers are far from presenting the subject in the light which you represent. I refer to your statement that Sabbath-keepers “make everything important relative to a proper observance of the Sabbath to depend on a certain segment of time called the seventh-day.” This is not true.
First-day keepers, in order to evade the requirements of the fourth commandment, teach that the precept requires simply a seventh part of time, in the order of six days of labor and a seventh of rest for its observance; and this is the only “segment-of-time” theory in regard to the seventh day ever heard of. On the other hand, seventh-day advocates attach importance to the day numerically, as the seventh day of the week from the beginning of creation, and the only day of the week which can possibly commemorate the first seventh day of time in which God rested. But the feature of supreme importance in connection with the subject is the authority of God, and the fact that God has commanded the observance of this particular day. The institution, then, with us, consists in its being a memorial of the Creator's rest, and indirectly a recognition of his sovereignty as the Creator of the world. The feature of rest is a secondary and subordinate, though important, blessing connected with the day, and the weekly repetition of divine worship is as essential now as when first ordained, six thousand years ago.
Again, the Sabbath institution of the fourth commandment is of importance at the present time, as evidenced by the agitation of the subject both in this country and in Europe, and by others than seventh-day keepers. First-day people admit the importance of a particular day for general observance in their efforts to secure the support of that day by legislation; and under the name of “The Constitutional Amendment Party” a large number of prominent and influential men of the different leading denominations are trying to insert the name of God in the Constitution, and also to place Sunday upon a legal basis as a Sabbath.
When urged to regard the seventh day, the opponents of that day say that the particular day is of no importance, but admit that a particular day is essential in order to secure unity and harmony in society, and that human authority is sufficient to regulate this day. You admit this when you say that were the seventh day well-nigh universally kept by Christians, you should not keep it any better as to religious exercises, etc., implying that worship and rest are of divine authority, while the day itself is regulated by custom.
Now, we believe that the Author of the fourth commandment knew as well as human legislators that a particular day would be required in keeping the precept, and for this reason appointed the seventh day, as the most appropriate for that purpose. To sum up the matter, then, the Creator knew that a particular day would be required, and for this purpose appointed the seventh day to be kept by everybody; and this makes it the particular day of the commandment.
Again, you think God never would have suffered the change from the seventh day to the first, had it been such a monstrous wrong and injury to the world. This is simply human reasoning,—which you affect in another part of your letter to treat with contempt,—and is opposed to the facts in this particular case and to thep. 68 experience of the world in repeated instances. The Lord suffered the Antediluvians, the cities of the plains, etc., although it is said he knows how to reserve the unjust unto the day of Judgment to be punished.
It is also true that God has permitted a terrible apostasy of the church since the days of the apostles. And it is a historical fact that Constantine placed Sunday upon a legal basis as a Sabbath while he was a heathen worshiper; for he spoke of the first day as the “venerable day of the sun” at that time, A. D. 321. “Sylvester, who was bishop of Rome while Constantine was emperor,” Christianized the day, changing the name of the festival of the sun, by his apostolic authority, into that of Lord's day. “To Constantine and to Sylvester, therefore, the advocates of first-day observance are greatly indebted.”
Finally, as to your remarks on the Sabbath, like most of our opponents, you refute your own arguments; for even in the limited space of four pages you denounce, first, the practice of worshiping on a segment of time called the seventh day, denying that such specific time is required in the commandment, and then assert that a person cannot observe the law, as he cannot keep the exact time that the Jews did anciently in Palestine, or that they do there now. Thus you teach that a person is narrow-minded for making the exact day of any importance in the matter; and then you make a proper observance of the commandment to consist in keeping the exact day. I cannot construe your letter in any other way, since Sabbath-keepers make no such hobby of a local division of time. For upon this principle a person in the western part of Palestine could not keep the same time as that observed by another in the eastern part, and a person traveling around the world would gain or lose a day, according to the direction he traveled.
But we have no such difficulty in our practice, as we measure a day by one revolution of the earth upon its axis, and accommodate ourselves to the day as we find it at any part of the earth's surface. “The spherical shape of the earth, however, is a difficulty only in connection with the seventh day, as the globe flattens out upon the first day of the week.”
In conclusion, I will say of the passage in John 17:3, I consider the language tropical, the cause being put for the effect; or, it is necessary to receive God and Christ and to walk in them in order to obtain eternal life. Your method of interpretation is that employed by Romanists to prove the literal presence in those passages which speak of the body and blood of Christ.
In Prov. 10:15, we read, “The destruction of the poor is their poverty;” yet I hardly think you would consider this a literal definition of poverty or destruction, although the passage is parallel to the one found in John 17:3. It is strange that people will ignore the literal account of the constitution of man found in Gen. 2:7, and appeal to a passage of Scripture which is certainly figurative, in defining the nature of human life; but such is the case.
Yours truly, ALFRED H. CLEAVES.