SPECIAL PROVIDENCE AND NATURAL LAW.
Our friend Mr. Manly is nothing if not skeptical. His last feat in argumentation was a presentation of the hackneyed but still favorite theory with his class of thinkers, that, the world being governed by fixed laws, there is no room for Providence and no use in prayer. To this, Deacon Thresher replied, “Neighbor Manly, you assume too much and prove too little; besides, you are advancing a doctrine of fatalism which neither you nor anybody else ever acts upon. Neither a Mohammedan nor an old-school Baptist can be found to tie himself down to it. Talk as you may about the inflexibility of natural law, there is not a day of your life that you are not acting on the supposition that what you call inflexible law, is sufficiently flexible to allow ample play for human energies. How much more, then, is there room for the exercise of divine energy additional or alternative of that which you already see.” “Take, for instance, the four seasons. If anything on earth is ‘fixed’ in their conditions, they are. They are the result of the earth’s course in its orbit, and the inclination of its axis toward the sun. They cannot be stopped or transposed in their relationship without the destruction of the world in its present form. Then a shower of rain; that too is the product of determinate causes and the result of laws as fixed as are the everlasting hills. There is the action of the sun and the wind in lifting the vapor; then the counter-current of cold air must come in just a certain way, and act in a fixed manner, or there will be no rain. And the crops, too, are all the product of settled laws. So much rain and so much sunshine in duly settled proportions are requisite. The mode of growth is all decided beforehand; and in the same way you may go on through the whole realm of nature, and everywhere you will find law,—absolute law, fixed and determinate law. “And yet see how much free scope there is for conjecture. How little you know, after all your prating, about fixed law. Consider how much there is unfixed. All the men on the globe have their faces formed alike, and there are no two of them just the same. So, you have summers and winters by the score, and yet when did you find any two of them just the same? They vary in the number of hot days, in the number of cloudy days, in the number of frosty mornings. You cannot tell when it is going to rain, not even with the weather conjecture before you. Your old man of eighty, who has studied weather signs for all these years, cannot do anything more than make a guess whether in the coming season there will be much rain or little rain, whether the winter will be a closed winter or an open winter, whether the spring will be a forward spring or a backward spring. You see plainly that what is settled is more than matched by what is unsettled, and what you do know is exceeded by what you don’t know. Neither does Huxley know, nor Tyndall know, nor John W. Draper know, nor a whole academy of scientific men with several dozens of such men as John Weiss and Oliver W. Holmes thrown in. When these men pack their carpet bags to attend a convention where they will talk for a week about the absolute fixedness of all things, there is not one of them that knows whether it is safe to start without an umbrella. A scientific man carrying an umbrella in a clear day is a proof that he does not trust his own theories.” “Now, right here in this wide domain between the fixed and the unfixed, the determinate and the indeterminate, law and laxity, is the field where special providence comes in. Your prosperity, your welfare, your comfort, your health, your life, the success of every single one of your plans, is as dependent upon the unfixed as upon the fixed. An inopportune shower may cause you the loss of a crop; an unexpected frost may cut off all your fruit; a slightly altered spring may favor the development of caterpillars’ eggs; a wet spring may make a ‘fat graveyard’; an unforeseen puff of cold air may lay you on the bed of a consumptive; a trivial incident may alter the whole course of your life. Nay, more; it is the truth that the whole of human history, of tribes and kindreds and kings and kingdoms, of revolutions, of battles, are all of them dependent upon little contingencies,—dependent upon no ‘fixed law’ that anybody knows anything about. These little contingencies are the special administrative corps of special providence. “There is room for prayer, then. You know the sun will rise to-morrow morning. That is fixed, and you need not pray that it be otherwise. But you do not know whether it will be a clear day, and you may pray for that if need be. In a few moments, without interfering with any of his fixed purposes as regards the rising of the sun, God can cover the whole sky with clouds, or he can drive them away in half an hour. You may pray that God would avert frost from your orchards; he can do it by slightly changing the direction of the wind, which is blowing according to a ‘fixed law.’ You can pray for rain upon your withered corn; and God can send it by gently affecting the action of certain laws which regulate the condensation of moisture. All the conditions of your daily and hourly existence are affected as much by the contingent as by the fore-ordained. There is such a thing in the economy of Divine Providence as fore-ordained contingency. Consequently, there is not a single condition of your hourly existence that may not be affected by prayer.” And so the company went on discussing the subject. Many other things were said. The history of Joseph was adduced to illustrate the way in which God makes use of contingencies to accomplish fixed plans. The case of Hushai the Archite was used to show how Providence can effect its object by making use of fixed laws. One man said he wished the minister would preach on the subject occasionally. He added that he would gladly forego, for a Sunday at least, an account of “What I saw in Europe,” for the sake of a good sermon on Providence. Another said, “The Sabbath-school lesson ought to contain a well-digested course on the subject, taking the Old Testament as a text-book of precedents.”—Selected.