AdventAI

A WELCOME ALLY.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 11., September 2, 1880

The Roman Catholic Bishop of Buffalo, N. Y., has issued a circular denouncing the profanation of the first day of the week, or Lord’s day. He says, “ ‘Remember thou keep holy the Sabbath day,’ is God’s own command, and the Christian Church, in transferring its observance to the Sunday, the Lord’s day, enforces the obligation of keeping the Sunday holy, and determines for us in what the Christian observance of the day consists.”

This is an acknowledgment that the church, by which of course he means the Catholic church, has changed the day; and it is consistent that the power which can change the day can also regulate its observance. He then goes on to declare how the day should be observed, and prominent among the duties belonging to it is the “hearing of Mass.”

He then declares that none will be recognized as Catholics who will not strictly observe the Lord’s day. The profanation of Sunday, he adds, is falsely charged upon the teachings of the Catholic church, to which he answers, “Not because of, but in spite of, the Catholic Church, is the holiness of the Lord’s day profaned. . . . We know how the Church in France, for instance, has grieved over and cried out against this great abuse; how this open insult to the Almighty, in neglecting to keep holy the Sunday, has brought a curse upon that once Catholic land, as our Blessed Mother, on various occasions, declared it would. And can Catholic societies expect to prosper by treading in such unhallowed paths?”

The editor of the Christian World comments with great satisfaction upon this remarkable document. In a prefatory paragraph, he says, “The following document seems to us to deserve attention and preservation. It is from a recent circular of the Roman Catholic Bishop of Buffalo, the Rev. S. V. Ryan, and deals with a most important and vital topic,—that of the proper observance of the Lord’s day. It is a matter of no small moment that the Roman Catholic Church in this country should take a proper ground, or anything like a proper ground, on this subject. The future of these United States depends, more than any of us realize, upon the manner in which we shall, as a nation, treat the divine ordinance, and set apart the first day of the week as a day of physical rest and of spiritual worship. . . . It would certainly furnish great ground of gratitude to every truly pious heart, if we might count upon the Roman Catholic ministers of religion as faithful allies in the struggle.”

Again we quote: “There are, it is true, many things in the circular before us which we do not approve or indorse. . . . The historical statement with regard to the position of the Roman Catholic Church on the question of the Lord’s day is, unfortunately, far from correct. . . . And yet we prefer to waive an inquiry into the truth or falsity of Bishop Ryan’s claims, and to congratulate our Roman Catholic citizens and ourselves on the position which some, at least, of the prelates of this church in this country are disposed to assume.”

The Bishop claims as the authority for the Lord’s day the action of the Christian church, by which he means of course the Catholic church. This Protestant writer is willing to waive that claim if he can have the help of the Catholics in trying to enforce the day. If the day rests on the authority of the church, it is simply a human institution, and cannot bind the consciences of men; but this Protestant virtually says, We do not care what its origin is, nor on what authority it rests, if we can only carry our point, and succeed in enforcing it.

He further says, “It is a favorable omen for the future of the United States that Romanism here has been and is so affected by contact with Protestantism as to desire to reproduce, even faintly, the reverence of the latter for the Christian Sabbath.”

If it is possible for a person to talk more like a blind man than this editor talks in this paragraph, it has not been our fortune to meet with any such instance. He has stated just exactly the reverse of the truth; for it is Protestantism which has been affected by Romanism, touching the Lord’s day, instead of Romanism being affected by Protestantism. Under the impulse of such feelings as are here expressed by the Christian World, it certainly would not be difficult for Protestants and Romanists to form a coalition on this subject.

It has for some time been a query when Catholics would begin to speak on this question, and what position they would assume; but this circular from the Bishop of Buffalo is the beginning of the answer to that query, and it is an answer of no uncertain kind. Protestants and Romanists combined could speedily secure such legal enactments as would make a Sunday-Sabbath law binding throughout all the land. When a Catholic Bishop issues such a circular as the one herein referred to, and a Protestant editor hails it with undisguised glee, it is strong evidence that such a consummation as regards the Sunday institution is not far distant.