THE SEVENTH-DAY SABBATH, OR THE FIRST?
By O. Dickinson
An article under the above heading, published in the REVIEW AND HERALD, Vol. 55, No. 21, is a subject of earnest criticism by a writer in the World’s Crisis, July 14. He thinks there is a “fallacy” and an “assumption” in our reasoning, which ought to be exposed. He says, “The assumption is, that the ten commandments, in their entirety, are all moral laws; that the Sabbath commandment is a moral law as really as the commandment against killing; that as to their nature, all the commandments are precisely alike.” The writer then makes a distinction between moral duties and positive duties, and says that truthfulness, chastity, and refraining from murder, are moral duties, while the observance of the Sabbath is not moral, but belongs to the list of positive duties. “Moral laws,” he says, “are those requirements which the very nature and constitution of things render necessary, the reason for which we see, independent of any revealed law or command concerning them, and which must, in the nature of the case, demand obedience from all moral creatures, while such constitution of things endures.” The writer then goes on to show, from his definition of moral law, that any argument for the Sabbath is fallacious, because the law to remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy, is not a moral law, but a positive law, and for that reason may exist or not, may be changed or done away, and no moral principle be touched by the change. In regard to the above, it seems to me that my brother mistakes. It seems to me he has not duly weighed the words which he has penned. Take the definition which he gives: “Moral laws are those requirements which the very nature and constitution of things render necessary, the reason for which we see, independent of any revealed law or command concerning them.” Is the above definition of moral law a good one? A definition, as I understand it, should shut out, on the one hand, all that does not belong to the thing defined, and should admit all that does belong to it. Does this definition do this? May there not be moral laws and moral duties, the reason for which we do not “see”? Many a wayward boy, blinded by his passions and perverse will, has not seen the reason for the command “Honor thy father and thy mother.” He has thought himself abused by the requirement of obedience on the part of his parents. But because he has not seen the reason of that command, and the moral duty it enjoins, is it therefore not a moral duty, and the law a moral law? And may it not possibly be a moral duty to honor God, our great Parent, in keeping the Sabbath? And may it not be a moral law which commands the keeping of a specific day for the Sabbath, even though we in our blindness do not see it? The seeing of a duty, or the not seeing of it, does not change the fact. It is equally a duty for a child to honor his parents, whether he sees it or not. The child who does this will grow up to manhood with a nobler character; he will be a better citizen, will take his place in the world on a higher plane, and will be far more likely to be submissive to the laws and government of God in all other respects, than if he refused obedience to it. The law to honor his parents is a moral law, though he did not see it,—moral in its effects upon him, moral and ennobling in its effects upon society, upon the State, and upon the world. The definition of moral law which the writer gives, it seems to me is not a correct one. When we use the word “moral” in its first sense, it has “reference to duty or obligation. It pertains to those intentions and actions, of which right and wrong may be predicated, or to the rules by which such intentions and actions ought to be directed.” “It relates to the practice, manners, or conduct of men as social beings,” and it takes in, not only their relations to one another, and the right and wrong of these relations, but it takes in their relations to God also; and I believe the word is so used by our best writers and thinkers. I believe I am right when I say that the word moral, as used by the English-speaking nations, takes into consideration the divine law, the ten commandments; and that we cannot be considered, even before our courts of justice, worthy moral men, unless we have some regard to God, and to what he says in reference to the actions of men. And right here, it seems to me, the religion of the present day, in all our churches, is too much at fault. We have dropped out too much the idea of God from our actions. I believe that God is a moral being; that he is one among moral beings; that he has rights which we ought to respect; and that he has created us with rights which he respects. I believe he is such a moral being that he will not do injustice even to the weakest of his creatures, nor does he wish injustice done to himself by them. He is such a being that he can call upon Heaven and earth to witness between himself and his people. And it is injustice toward himself, on the part of men, that he most complains of. “Hear, O heavens, and give ear, O earth; for the Lord hath spoken. I have nourished and brought up children, and they have rebelled against me. The ox knoweth his owner, and the ass his master’s crib; but Israel doth not know, my people doth not consider.” His expressions all through his word indicate that he feels the injustice with which he is treated by man, and he cries out: “What could have been done more to my vineyard, that I have not done?” So, too, if we come into the New Testament Scriptures, we find him putting himself in with men, counting himself injured when men are injured, and assisted and blessed when they are blessed. He will judge the world upon this principle: “Inasmuch as ye have done it unto one of the least of these my brethren, ye have done it unto me.” It is an admitted fact by all our churches, that God is a moral being, and that his moral law does not pertain to man only. I believe the Scriptures bear me out in the assertion that we may take from God what belongs to him, as really as we may take from men what belongs to them. When God had given permission to our first parents to freely eat of the trees in the garden, those trees were theirs; they had a right to them, and could use them for food as they wished; but when he reserved one tree to himself, that tree was his; they had no right to it, and when they put forth their hand to take and eat of it, the act was as clearly stealing as if there had been other men living, and they had taken what belonged to them. The fact that the tree belonged to God does not take away the evil, nor make it less a moral wrong. Nor does the fact that God was not physically injured by this act, take away the wrong. There are wrongs, even among men, that are far greater than some physical wrongs. “He that steals my purse, steals trash,” but what of him that blasts my honor or smutches my good name? God has a right to the honor of his creatures. They do a moral wrong if they withhold it from him. It was one of the faults of his ancient people, that they did not give him the honor that was his due. “A son honoreth his father, and a servant his master; if, then, I be a father, where is mine honor? and if I be a master, where is my fear? saith the Lord of hosts.” As I understand the Scriptures, it is as fully and clearly an immoral act to withhold the honor that is due to God, as it is to withhold from man what belongs to him. “Thy commandment is exceeding broad,” says the psalmist. I understand that, “beginning with the lowest and least of his intelligent creatures, it reaches up through all ranks of beings,—men, angels, the Son of God, and even to the great Father himself; and each of them all has a right to the honor, respect, and place which he individually holds.”162 The above being so (and I think all will admit it), how is it that the law of the Sabbath is taken out from among the other nine commandments, all of which are admitted to be moral laws, and cast aside as having no connection with them? What right have men to say that God shall not have the honor which is his due as the maker of the heavens and the earth? He has appointed a day, one in seven, in which he asks men to give him that honor. He has arranged the constitution of things so that they can do it. He did not make the earth so stingy of her food that man must use every hour, and seven days in a week, to draw from her unwilling breast the nourishment he needs; but with bountiful hand she opens her stores. She gives to the reaper a full supply in the six days’ work, and even with that, he may let fall his handfuls for the gleaner and the poor. When man takes the day which God has chosen, and uses it to give him honor, remembering the God that made him, he is better off, even in this world’s goods, than if he used the whole seven in his work. God fulfills his promise to him, “Them that honor me, I will honor.” How, then, is it, I say, that this one of the commandments of God is not a moral law? But my brother says, “Apart from the explicit command, the duty to keep the Sabbath does not exist.” How does he know that? How does he know what real injury to God’s law would come, if there were no command to keep the Sabbath? Wherever men have not known the command, or wherever they have once known and forgotten it, we know that great evil has come to them in body and in mind. How does he know what sorrow pierces God’s heart, when he sees the abuse of physical life, of mental life, and of moral life, which men give themselves up to, when the constantly recurring Sabbath does not remind them of their Creator, and of the high claims which he has upon them? Can a child give himself up to forgetfulness of his earthly father and mother, and they not be injured by it? Can they see him in iniquity and sin, and not sorrow over it, even though he knows not their wishes to the contrary? If father and mother know his life, that is enough, the injury and sorrow to them is complete. And so God says of men, “Thou hast made me to serve with thy sins; thou hast wearied me with thine iniquities;” and the Lord Jesus Christ wept over Jerusalem, because they knew not the day of their visitation. The Jews not knowing and not considering, did not save them from evil, nor did it save the great Father from pain, nor the Son of God from tears. These things being so, how does the writer of the article to which I refer know but that the nature and constitution of things under the law of the Sabbath are necessary, and therefore that it is a moral law? He says, “Moral laws are those requirements which the very nature and constitution of things render necessary.” I cannot see that anything can be more necessary or more moral than that men should have their lives in harmony with the most moral being of the universe. I can readily see that, if men did not know his will, or anything about him, or about his Sabbath, they would not know where the injury came from, which the unceasing work and delve and plod of a world without a Sabbath would bring; the unceasing push of hard hands, the unceasing grasp of selfishness, on and on, with no rest, no law of Jehovah to lift the burden off their shoulders, to lay it aside for one day in seven. They might not know where the injury and the evil came from, or what was out of place in the “constitution of things,” or what was necessary to make it right; but they would suffer evil all the same. Man needs to honor God in the Sabbath, for the sake of his soul life and his physical life. The difficulty with the brother who penned the article I speak of, is, that he has shut his eyes against God. He has dropped the Deity out of the account of moral beings in the universe, as if there were none of him, while men, and what we see about us, are everything. Take his shorter definition, and see if it is not so. “A moral duty,” he says, “is an act demanded of us, by the very relation we sustain to the world about us, whether an express command concerning it has been announced or not.” You will notice that “the world about us” is what he has in mind,—men, simply men, “the world about us.” How was it possible that he should pen that sentence and not think of God? The greater part of the world is God. He is over us all, and among us all. “In him we live, and move, and have our being.” If all the millions of earth should die, at his word other millions would spring forth from “the hiding of his power.” “They that be with us,” said Elisha, “are more than they that be with them.” How, then, could it be that our brother, in speaking of moral duty and moral obligation, should not think of God, or imply in his definitions the idea that God is a part of this universe of moral beings; and that if we do not give to him the respect and reverence which is his due, we are as truly immoral, and do a wrong as fully, as if we withhold the money which we owe to our fellow-man? And now, as I close this article, perhaps I may repeat its substance:— 1. God is a moral being among moral beings. 2. He has rights which other intelligent beings ought to respect, and among these rights are the honor and esteem which belong to him as the wonderful architect of the universe. 3. Since these rights are often forgotten by men, he has wisely made a law to protect them, proclaiming himself the Creator of the heavens and the earth, and commanding men to rest from all work on one particular day in each week, for the reason that he, their Creator, rested on that day. 4. Since he is the Maker of all things, he is the owner of all things. The days of the week are, therefore, his, and man has no right to dispose of them as he pleases. 5. The first six days of the week God has given to man, in which to do all his work, but the seventh day he has specially reserved for himself, guarding it with more specifications, and with more carefully arranged words and clauses, than any other law, so that his intent and purpose cannot possibly be misunderstood. 6. Inasmuch as all days are his, and he has given men only six days to do their work in, if we take the seventh day we are taking what belongs to him, and though we may not think of it, and while in ignorance are not as guilty, yet if we take the seventh day for ourselves, we as really and truly steal from him as we would if we took what belonged to man. 7. If we take from him, he is injured, and feels the injury, in many respects, as men do. 8. The fact that we have substituted another day for the Sabbath, which he has not asked for, nor given his consent to, does not take away the evil or wrong of our conduct. The fact that I have substituted another horse in the place of the one I have taken from my neighbor, does not justify me in the eye of the law, nor make me less guilty before men. 9. Because we do not see God, or think that he is injured by what we do, does not make it less an injury to do a moral wrong. British landlords may not see their tenants in Ireland when they collect exorbitant rents, yet injury and starvation may come all the same by their conduct. 10. All these being moral matters which the fourth commandment was designed to protect, we may as properly and truly regard the Sabbath law a moral law, as any other one of the ten commandments. 11. If the law of the Sabbath is a moral law, as I believe it is, I may reiterate the proposition upon which I grounded my first article; viz., The moral law of God, that was written upon tables of stone by the finger of God, is primary in its nature—primary in the sense that it is of first rank, and that it never can be done away so long as God and intelligent moral beings exist, and have relations to each other. And to this agrees the word of God. Ps. 111:7, 8, “All his commandments are sure. They stand fast forever and ever, and are done in truth and uprightness.” Ps. 119:142, “Thy righteousness is an everlasting righteousness, and thy law is the truth.”