SEEKING NOTORIETY AGAIN

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 1, 1880

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 2.

Read the full edition

SEEKING NOTORIETY AGAIN.

ONE A. N. Seymour, of Michigan, whose name some of our older readers will remember, is again seeking to make himself obnoxiously prominent in connection with the Sabbath question. So many years have elapsed since his former insane and inane crusade against the sacred institution of the Lord Jehovah, that he perhaps imagines that but few acquainted with the circumstances as they transpired will remember them, and that most of his readers will be those who had no knowledge of them. In no other way can we account for the audacious statements which he makes.
In the World’s Crisis of June 16, 1880, he states that some twenty years since he wrote out eleven questions for Sabbatarians to answer. Considering the man, this is a marvel of modesty. He wrote not only eleven, but by transposing, restating, and ringing the changes on certain expressions, he rolled up the number to the pompous figure of “fifty,” and called them “unanswerable arguments.”
After a certain conference in Jackson, he further states that J. M. Stephenson returned “to Wisconsin and commenced publishing a paper advocating the principles of seventh-day Sabbath-keeping,” and sent him a copy. With his fatal eleven questions our hero stood ready and launched them at that office. Stephenson waited six weeks, he says, and then wrote him that he could not answer the questions; and after another silence of six weeks, he came out in two lengthy articles, renouncing that theory. A paper throttled to death twenty years ago, after twelve weeks of existence, by the famous eleven questions, and this is the first the world ever knew of it! Never before did we hear of any such paper. We would like to learn its name, precise date, and location.
D. P. Hall was next swooped upon, according to the narrative. “He was silent for six months,” says S., “and then wrote me that he was skeptical in reference to the Sabbath.” “After another silence of six months, he renounced it.”
How remarkably regular these transactions were. One waits six weeks and writes, and then in six weeks more gives it up. The other waits six months and writes, and then in just six months more gives it up. J. M. Stephenson routed from the Sabbath in twelve weeks, and D. P. Hall in one year, by the same wonderful eleven questions! The truth of the matter concerning Stephenson’s and Hall’s apostasy is simply this. They came East in the interest of a conspiracy to gain control of the REVIEW, and change it into an Age-to-come paper. But being circumvented in this, they soon broke their connection with this people; and A. N. S. will never be chargeable with the guilt which he so much covets, of turning those men away from the truth.
He next avers that he sent the same questions to the editor of the REVIEW, and gives a list of the questions. After the questions he makes the following statement, which we quote verbatim, the italics being his: “The above was sent to the Review and Herald years ago, but the editor took no notice of it. What think ye of such conduct? Judge ye all.”
We can tell in few words not only what we think, but what we know; and that is that in this he is following in the steps of Ananias and Sapphira. Not only his eleven questions, but all the fifty above mentioned, which in reality are only the substance of the eleven, re-stated in every silly shape in which it is easy to put them, were published in the REVIEW, beginning with No. 1, Vol. 20, and fully answered by J. M. Aldrich, running through six numbers of the paper. The same matter was immediately put in tract form, and advertised for years in our book list, under the heading, “Review of Seymour; his Fifty Questions Answered,” and sold all over the land with our other books until the edition was exhausted. Yet he would now have the readers of the Crisis understand that no notice has ever been taken of his questions by the REVIEW. We do not need to ask any man in whose heart there still lives a spark of moral honesty, what he thinks of such conduct.
As to the questions, in themselves considered, they are entitled to no consideration. They are unfathomably shallow; and what obligation the editor of the REVIEW or any one else was under to notice them, does not appear, though it may look in his eyes like a great crime. The notice that has been taken of them is only for the sake of those who for the time being might be confused by them. Here for example is the first question: “1. Where is there one command of God to keep holy the seventh-day Sabbath prior to the time of Moses?” The question is designed to imply that there was no command, and hence no Sabbath, nor obligation to keep any. But any reader of average intelligence will at once try the same question on the other commandments. For instance, Where is there one command not to kill prior to the time of Noah? Yet was not the law against killing as binding from Adam to Noah as it is to-day? and was not Cain condemned and branded as a murderer for killing his brother? Gen. 2:3 contains in plain language the record that a command to keep the seventh-day Sabbath was given to Adam, and consequently that such command was in existence from Adam to Moses. And when we reach the time of Moses, and the record and the writer were contemporaneous, then the Sabbath command is set down in express terms. There was no occasion for it in the preceding record.
His second question is a similar clap-trap utterance: “Where is there one command of God to any Gentile nation, either in this or in any preceding dispensation, to observe the seventh-day Sabbath?” Mr. S. claims to be a Gentile, and in this we think his claim may be well-founded. Then he may read a description of his condition in Eph. 2:11, 12. The first thing for him to do is to get out of this state, cease to be a Gentile, join the commonwealth of Israel, become a “fellow-citizen with the saints, and of the household of God,” verse 19, and he will no longer spend his time blindly inquiring what laws God has for the Gentiles.
He also rings the changes on “one command” for the Sabbath subsequent to the crucifixion, not thinking in his windy defense of the Lord’s day, that some one may think far enough to ask him for “one command” in the New Testament for Sunday-keeping.
He seems to think that an intense desire has existed on the part of seventh-day people that he should commence to keep the Sabbath. In this, again, his conceit gets the better of his veracity. The Lord wants none but converted men in his cause, and ever since we have come to know this man, it has been evident that a radical change must be wrought in him before his services could be of use in any good cause.