AdventAI

AN EXCELLENT MISTAKE.

By Mary E. Comstock

From Review and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 2., July 1, 1880

The Wrens and the Littlefields were families that had met at the seashore and among the mountains. They both came to town to live about the same time. Each family took a pew in the nearest congenial church. The Wrens went to Dr. Goodman’s and the Littlefields to Dr. Speedwell’s. Once in a great while the families exchanged informal evening visits.

“I told Ray last Sunday,” said Mrs. Littlefield on one of these occasions, “that we might as well give up our pew in church. I feel frozen out. I’m chilled to death, and I’ve concluded not to keep up the experiment any longer.”

“Can’t you get a seat nearer the register?” asked Casper Wren in his matter-of-fact, direct way, looking up with an inquiring expression of surprise and concern.

Ray Littlefield leaned back in the comfortable, deep easy-chair he occupied and seemed intensely amused.

“That’s exactly like you, Casper! My wife means that the frigidity she experiences in the social and spiritual atmosphere of Dr. Speedwell’s church is such that—ah—in short, such that the consequent mental state induced corresponds to the bodily sensation of chills, unvaried by any flashes of fever whatever,” and then dropping bombast in tone and manner the gentleman added, “Seriously, Frank has stood the depressing influence with a great deal of bravery. I do not wonder she has taken a death-cold so far as that church is concerned.”

“Why, you dear soul,” said little Mrs. Jenny Wren, turning to Mrs. Littlefield, “how dreadful it must be. You ought to come to our church. It is the sunniest, happiest, most summer-like church you ever saw. The congregation is very sociable and there is a feeling of at-home-ness that is perfectly delightful.”

Mrs. Littlefield glanced at her husband with a look of significance, and turning to Mrs. Wren again, said,—

“Do you really mean it?”

“Why, certainly, I do.”

“How long have you attended there?”

“About a year.”

“Well, I have heard very different accounts of your church. Mrs. Eaton says that it is very stiff and exclusive, and I’ve heard others say so. But I suppose you had friends of your own there, and their friends ‘took you in,’ and so you do not feel it so much.”

Mrs. Wren smiled a wondering little smile.

“Why that isn’t so a bit,” she said. “Come to think of it, we didn’t know a soul when we went there, did we, Casper?”

“I think the Churchman is right,” rejoined Mrs. Littlefield, “in what it says about the lack of Christian courtesy in churches. I notice a great many papers, of various denominations, are indorsing the ground the Churchman takes.”

“What is the ground?”

“Here is the gist of it,” said Mrs. Littlefield. “I clipped an extract and put it in my pocket-book. ‘In some cases,’ says the Churchman, ‘even cultivated families may attend for years and not obtain the slightest recognition.’ And then again it says, ‘People naturally want to know by certain external signs whether the communion of saints means anything, and whether, if it mean nothing here, it may mean anything hereafter. The worst thing of all is that not a few people become exasperated and soured against the church, because they find in it nothing answering to Christian fellowship, and next to nothing which answers to Christian civility.’”

“Rather sharp,” said Casper Wren.

“Just hits the case,” said Mr. Littlefield. “I was speaking to Goodfellow down at the office about it, and he agreed with the sentiments exactly. He says he and his family are constant attendants, but are recognized by no one in their church. They really enjoy getting in the country summers and being greeted by the folks. They are a very high-toned, cultivated family. It isn’t the fault of the people who complain.”

“I saw,” said Mrs. Littlefield, “a very good little article in a Syracuse paper. A lady, the writer, told Halicarnassus she was going to church. He wouldn’t go with her, told her she would be sorry if she went, that she was a stranger, and wouldn’t have a good time. She went alone, was seated by herself in a vacant pew. No one spoke to her as she came out. She lingered in the vestibule and finally drew her veil down over her face to hide the starting tears, and came away cut to the heart. Halicarnassus said he told her it would be so. She resolved not to go there again.”

Casper Wren had listened to Mrs. Littlefield’s synopsis with an interested, sympathetic face; but when she reached her concluding period and he perceived that to be the finale, he was rude enough to laugh.

“It was an exceedingly well-written article,” said Mrs. Littlefield, with heightened color.

“I haven’t a doubt of it,” said Casper apologetically; “but how did others know the lady would not have considered recognition intrusive, or, in fact, that she was alone? Why, if she felt inclined to communication, didn’t she speak?”

“How could she?”

“Well,” said Mrs. Jenny Wren, “I don’t know what I should have done in her place,” and the little woman looked very reflective with her head on one side. Then brightening suddenly she added,—

“Why, I suppose I should have done just as I did a week ago in a strange church. I went Sunday morning to see my sick washer-woman. She had had hemorrhage, and I dared not wait. I saw when I left her that I was too late for church at home, so I went into the nearest place of worship. I did not know a person. The usher seated me in a vacant pew. I was very comfortable. A gentleman and lady came in late. I showed them the number of the hymn. After service I turned and shook hands with the lady, and said, ‘I have enjoyed your pleasant seat very much this morning,’ and I asked her if the hymn-book was the one used in Dr. Barton’s church of the same denomination. I have one of those, and I wanted to find that hymn again. We had quite a little chat. I never thought anything about it, only that I enjoyed the service.”

“Did the lady repel you, consider you intrusive?” asked Mrs. Jenny’s husband, with arching eyebrows and a look of mock solemnity.

“Not a bit.”

“But you see,” said Ray Littlefield, “the cases are not parallel. The lady who wrote the article for the Syracuse paper sat entirely alone, so the article states as a grievance.”

“She might have spoken to a neighbor, then, if she desired to offer a remark, and said she had enjoyed the service.”

“But,” said Mr. Littlefield again, “she had not enjoyed it. It would have been an untruth.”

“You’re incorrigible!” said Wren.

“Not at all,” was the response. “I have myself noticed encomiums of the Churchman’s article and similar remarks in six or seven different papers, and a prominent minister alluded to the subject in a recent lecture. You know yourself what it is to receive a welcome anywhere, or on the contrary to feel ‘left out in the cold.’”

“I see I’ve made a great mistake,” said Mrs. Jenny Wren. “I have always thought that we went to church to worship God and to learn our duty. I have always taken it for granted, too, that worshiping congregations were a great family united by a common bond. I know it is so in our church.”

“Miss Rathbun told me herself,” said Mrs. Littlefield, “that she attended your church a long time, and that even at the ladies’ prayer-meeting no one spoke to her. I suppose you happened to be well introduced.”

“At the prayer-meeting? Why, no, of course not; I wasn’t introduced at all,” said Mrs. Jenny Wren, with an exceedingly perplexed expression on her pretty face. “I just went one day. I had heard the appointment read as usual on Sunday. Most of the ladies had gone to the country. Anyway there was only one there besides myself. We waited a long time in silence expecting some one else to come, then I said, ‘There are two of us, enough to claim the promise,’ and I read from my pocket Bible a verse that had come to me with new beauty of late, and we compared scripture with scripture for a few moments, and spoke of the family for whom the prayers of the church had been requested. We spoke, too, of the arduous duties of Doctor Goodman, who was absent, and acting as Moderator of the General Assembly and offered prayers for him and the family spoken of; and just as we closed, another lady came. We three have been real friends ever since.”

“Wife,” said Casper Wren, “I wonder it never occurred to me before what an irrepressible little woman you are. Don’t you think you and I make ourselves too much at home everywhere?”

Mrs. Wren looked up into her husband’s face with a troubled look. “I remember, now, things that have made no impression upon me in the past. I said to Mrs. Atherton the other day, ‘I should have sent you a note Thursday, but thought I should meet you in the evening at the church sociable and could give you Ellen’s message quicker than by mail.’ ‘I never attend the sociable,’ she replied, as though reproving my ignorance of her habits. But I can seldom go myself, so I did not know, I explained to her. ‘I like the people,’ she said, ‘and I quite believe they would like me better if they knew me, but I am a “stranger” there.’ ‘How long have you been a stranger?’ I inquired (knowing she attends every Sunday morning). She replied, ‘Twelve years.’”

“I told you so!” said Mrs. Frank Littlefield; “that’s just the way folks feel.”

“Mrs. Atherton has good New England sense, and is ‘a saint’ if there are any on the face of the globe,” said Casper Wren.

“I’ve made a mistake,” said Mrs. Jenny Wren, “and I have been acting on it as a basis without a demur or question. I have always supposed the church was our Father’s house, and have felt more at home in it than anywhere else in the world. Even socially, in England, people entertained by the same host consider introduction superfluous (though I believe a lady who had lived abroad discovered that the ignominious failure of her first dinner party after she returned to New York was due to the fact that she forgot that people’s ideas of decorum differed on this point this side of the water). In churches, at all events, I have thought all were on common ground. I have never felt hurt nor neglected. If I have ever been ‘snubbed,’ I have been too well grounded in my theory to perceive it, and have thought the persons either troubled, preoccupied, or strangers themselves, in which last case I have unconsciously, I believe, resolved myself immediately into an impromptu reception committee. But what everybody says must be true, and I am willing to reconsider and discover the dimensions of my mistake.”

A little rustle just here attracted the attention of the animated group gathered around the cheery grate in the extension, and Mrs. Littlefield, in telling the story a long time afterward, said she came very near giving a little scream as the massive head and portly figure of Dr. Goodman appeared, framed in the open door leading from the back parlor.

“Ex-cel-lent mistake, ex-cel-lent mistake,” said the doctor rubbing his hands delightedly as he slowly advanced to an arm-chair which Mrs. Jenny Wren, with the color coming and going in her cheek, drew forward for him in genial welcome. “Ex-cel-lent mistake,” he continued to repeat after exchanging a handshake all around. “I wish seven-eighths of my church-members would make the same kind of mistake; I think we would all stumble right into a state embodying the essence of things longed for. I certainly owe you an apology, and I am very willing to make it, for I feel as though I had received a great deal of instruction and edification without any right to it,” and thep. 23 fine, deep-set eyes gleamed with hearty mirth beneath the shaggy projecting brows.

“I had coughed, and changed my seat, and dropped my keys all to no purpose,” continued the doctor; “your pleasant gabble rippled over all. But having heard my own name, and in such pleasant connection, waking gratefulness on my part in knowing that I had the prayers of the daughters of the church, I was afraid I might hear something not so pleasant ere long if I did not face the battery of your eyes and ‘like a man’ announce myself, which it appears your servant did not do for me.”

“Did a servant admit you at the door?” asked Mrs. Wren.

“Unequivocally,” said the doctor, with a twinkle in his eye. “I did not come through the keyhole, although I found myself crowded into a very small place to-night. My wife is away from home. My right-hand elder is gone too. A perplexing matter came up requiring some visiting which I have no time for. I didn’t know what I should do, when all at once the helpful faces of Mr. and Mrs. Wren came up before me, and I thought, The very ones to know just how to go to work, and only around in the next block, too! I will just go and ‘drop in upon them!’”

“You came just in time to give your dictum, Doctor Goodman,” said Ray Littlefield. “Mrs. Wren had suggested some new ideas to my mind. It occurs to me whether after all the ‘mistake’ in regard to this social side of the church question which is so much discussed just now, may not be to some degree on the side of the great mass of the disaffected, who wait to be warmed from without instead of from within.”

“I think it is, and to a great degree,” said the doctor, “although there is something to be said on both sides.”

“Doctor Goodman,” said Mrs. Wren, when at length there was a pause in the animated discussion which all had entered into with great heartiness, “I have just thought I ought to give you ‘the key to the situation’ you found yourself in to-night, left so inhospitably alone in our dimly lighted back parlor.”

“Has the Swede immortalized herself again?” asked Casper Wren with a sudden look of illumination.

“Doubtless,” replied his wife, and then turning to the doctor, “I was obliged, Dr. Goodman, to reinforce this week, by taking as my second girl a Swede, who hardly understands a word of English. Her misapprehensions have involved us in uncounted mystifications. My father arrived this afternoon, and after dinner went down to Aunt Kate’s. He is about your age and figure, and my ‘new acquisition,’ who had taken his valise to his room, no doubt thought when she admitted you that he had returned, and that there was nothing to be said or done on her part.”

“Another excellent mistake,” said the doctor with great glee, “if you will permit me to consider it so, since it has given me a chance to participate in this fireside ventilation of the church-fellowship question, ‘opened up’ lately in so many of the religious papers, and especially well shown up by your home group in this snuggery of yours, madam, under your ‘own vine and fig-tree,’” and the doctor facetiously referred by a gesture to the luxuriant ivy that had sent a wandering spray out to reconnoitre just above his head.

“It is seldom that the pulpit and the pews have just such an opportunity to compare views. I must say that the longer I dwell on the subject the more strongly confirmed I become in my first impression regarding the excellence of your ‘mistake.’”—Mary E. Comstock, in Christian Weekly.