AdventAI

A DISCUSSION.

By J. S. Shrock

From Review and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 2., July 1, 1880

THE Sabbath question was the subject of a discussion held at Walkerton, Ind., June 8 and 9, between Eld. S. H. Lane and Eld. Seymour, First-day Adventist. Five sessions were held, three of which were devoted to the claims of the seventh day, while two were devoted to those of the first day. The usual arguments were employed on both sides. Eld. Seymour made several strong (?) arguments by endeavoring to make the Scriptures suit his own ideas. For example, after quoting Ex. 16:23, “And he said unto them, This is the Sabbath which the Lord hath given unto you,” etc., he remarked, “Moses was talking to the children of Israel; and were they in the garden of Eden? No, certainly not; yet Eld. Lane says that the Sabbath was given to man in the garden of Eden!” Again an attempt was made to make Acts 20:7 state that the disciples met on the first day of the week to break bread, and that Christ met with them and said, “Peace be unto you.”

We sometimes fail to see the full meaning of scriptures by reading them in too careless a manner; but I must believe that the Elder found all that would go to substantiate his belief (?) in Matt. 28:1. It was stated that the word σαββάτων in the first instance does not mean Sabbath, i. e., any holy day (what it does mean he failed to tell us), but that in the second instance it means, “the first day of the week,” “the first-day Sabbath,” or may have reference to the whole week; at all events it proves that the first day should be observed as a Sabbath.

When Eld. Lane quoted the second commandment, his opponent objected that the word “love” was not there; and to satisfy him, the moderators requested Eld. Lane to read it from the Bible.

The truth met with a decided victory. Sunday had to fall in with Matt. 7:26, 27, and Matt. 15:13. Oh, how thankful ought we to be for the truths of the third angel’s message! J. S. SHROCK.