BY ELD. R. M. KILGORE.
(Concluded.)
Mr. Investigator.—As I am much interested in this subject I would like to know on what basis you do your tithing. Do you pay a tenth of what you receive, or a tenth of your increase?
Adventist.—A tenth of the income, and not of the increase.
Bro. C.—What distinction do you make between income and increase?
A.—Our income is what we have made after we have paid the actual expenses which have enabled us to make our entire receipts. Suppose Mr. I., here, has two thousand dollars invested in merchandise at the commencement of the year. By strict economy and diligence in business, his books, which have been faithfully kept, show, at the close of the year, a total of $1,200 as receipts, and that he has paid for help $200; for rent and occupation tax, $200; for incidental expenses, $50.00; making a total of $450, by which outlay, with his own labor, he has been enabled to make the $1,200, and that must therefore be deducted to ascertain the actual income, which is $750, on which he pays tithes. Now, if he deducts from this his tithe and family expenses, amounting to $500, it will leave the increase, which is $250.
Mr. I.—In the case of those who have no property, and are laboring by the week or month, such as maid-servants, men-servants, school-teachers, clerks, etc., how should they estimate their tithes?
A.—On what they receive, for that is all clear income; and if they are boarded by those for whom they are laboring, they should add to their wages what their board would cost them, and pay tithes on the whole amount.
Bro. C.—In this respect the farmer has much the advantage over the mechanic, and day laborer. His living costs him but very little in actual outlay. We have to buy our flour, meat, butter, eggs, and vegetables, while he raises them.
A.—He would have no advantage if he should be careful in tithing everything he raises, and return to the Lord the first-fruits. Christ says that they ought even to pay tithes of their little garden herbs. Luke 14:42. They have no more moral right to consume what they raise without returning to God the things that are his than the mechanic, merchant, or professional man has. The apostle says, “I mean not that other men be eased, and ye burdened, but . . . that there may be an equality.” 2 Cor. 8:13, 14.
Mr. I.—In order to be correct in this matter, every one will have to keep a regular book account.
A.—Certainly. We should be as particular in our use of the Lord’s property as we would be were we doing business for one of our fellow-men. The apostle enjoins this: “Be not slothful in business;” Rom. 12:11; and the prophet says, “Cursed be he that doeth the work of the Lord negligently” (margin). Jer. 48:10. All successful business men, and prosperous incorporations are able to know at any time their exact income, their expenses, their profits, and their losses; because they are very particular to note a careful record of every business transaction. If all would do so, greater prosperity would attend them, and the sin of robbing God, which is so extensively committed, would be avoided by those who recognize the claim.
Bro. C.—I have one more objection, and that is to the plan of pledging at the beginning of the year that we will lay by one-tenth of our income when received, or on the first day of the week, and pay it into the treasury quarterly. As for myself, I sometimes want to use all I receive before the end of the quarter. And then, again, for more than a month or so at a time, I do not receive anything while I am at work; so that I could not fulfill my pledge.
A.—The design of our General Conference in framing and recommending the pledge was, doubtless, to arrange some system whereby all our brethren could act in unison. Without concert of action, armies could gain no victories, municipalities could not enforce their laws, or support their officers. Order is Heaven’s first law; and it seems highly proper that some plan should be arranged by which those who are standing at the head of the work of God on the earth, and in the different State Conferences, may know how many are willing to support it, and about how much means they can command, so that their plans for future operations can be arranged accordingly. As to the time when it should be laid by, the best and surest is at the time when it is received; for the Lord is more certain to get his own; and as it is generally in small sums, if we are inclined to be selfish or covetous, it will not look so large to us as it will after several receipts. Our brethren are sustained by the apostle who ordered: “Upon the first day of the week let every one of you lay by him in store [at home], as God hath prospered him, that there be no gatherings when I come.” 1 Cor. 16:2. If you have not been prospered, so that you have not received anything, or if you have failed for more than a month at a time to receive what you have earned, you violate no pledge if you lay nothing by during such time; for how can you lay it by when nothing is received? It is both reasonable and Scriptural to say before God, angels, and men, that we will do that which it is our duty to do.
Bro. C.—But don’t the Bible say that it is better not to vow than to vow and not pay?
A.—Solomon uses some such language, I believe; but you certainly would not draw a conclusion from that that it was wrong to vow at all. A vow is a solemn promise. If the Bible forbids vowing, then all mutual relations are destroyed. There could be no marriages, no civil contracts. It was wrong for you to give that note yesterday, or to promise your child a new dress to-morrow. Now, what does the Bible teach? “Vow, and pay unto the Lord your God.” Ps. 76:11. “And Jacob vowed a vow, saying, If God will be with me, and will keep me in this way that I go, and will give me bread to eat, and raiment to put on, so that I come again to my father’s house in peace; then shall the Lord be my God; and this stone which I have set for a pillar, shall be God’s house; and of all that thou shalt give me I will surely give the tenth unto thee.” Gen. 28:20-22. “When thou vowest a vow unto God, defer not to pay it; for he hath no pleasure in fools; pay that which thou hast vowed. Better is it that thou shouldest not vow, than that thou shouldest vow and not pay.” Eccl. 5:4, 5. Here is a plain command to vow; a clear example of vowing, a part of which was in regard to tithing; and a strong exhortation to pay what we vow. God has “no pleasure” in the “fool” who promises but never pays. It is just as proper for me to make a promise to God as to the woman who became my wife, or to my employer, on entering his store. You and I both vowed that we would “keep the commandments of God, and the faith of Jesus,” and yet that was our duty before we put our names on the church book. Now for you to vow, or sign that pledge, does not increase the duty of paying your tithes, nor does your refusal to sign it make it any less.
Bro. C.—How do you make that out? I always thought it did.
A.—It merely affords you an opportunity to say, on paper, that you will return to God what belongs to him. And for you not to do this affords occasion for suspicion. A few days ago you handed me twenty dollars for safe keeping till you should call for it. In two weeks you want it. I tell you I got cramped and used it. You look chagrined and disappointed. On returning home, your wife informs you that Mr. I., here, gave me ten dollars a year ago in the same way, and that I did not return it, and refused to give him any written obligation to secure him. In a few days you come back, and ask what I propose to do about it. I carelessly reply, “Oh, I’ll pay it sometime.” You ask me to give you a due-bill or my note; but I object. “I never sign any pledge paper. It is better not to vow than to vow and not pay.” Are you not suspicious that I am not just right? Although the money is yours, I have spent itp. 210 for my own use, which was a breach of the trust imposed; and the fact that I am not willing to say, on paper, that I would return it to you, shows, indeed, that I am not actuated by a right principle. Then, again, if I should give you my note, it does not increase my obligation to pay you back that twenty dollars; but a failure on my part to pay it adds the sin of lying to the crime of robbery. This is why “it is better not to vow, than to vow and not pay.”
Bro. C.—I see now, and am fully convinced that I have pursued a wrong line of policy in this matter, by not viewing it in the right light; and just as soon as I get out of debt, I shall sign the tithing pledge, and pay my vow to the most high God.
A.—Suppose I should take that twenty dollars of yours, and pay Mr. I., here, for the cow I bought of him last week, would it be right? It would simply be robbing you to pay him. On this same principle, would it be legal for me, after I have been robbing God all my life, to still continue it when I knew my duty, in order to pay my debts which I owe to God’s creatures? I think, Bro. C., that the prospect of getting out of debt would be greater by paying what we owe to the Lord first, and receive his blessing, than to continue to rob God in order to pay his creature, man. The one claim is as much higher than the other as heaven is higher than earth. A desire for the approbation of our fellow men, being greater in us than for the approval of God, is, doubtless, the prompting motive which would lead us to take such a course. God is our judge, and he knows our hearts. To know that we have the favor of God is more valuable than to be esteemed honest by our fellow-men. Doing our duty to God, and receiving his blessing would be a more certain way of placing us on a good financial footing. I have no fears, since God asks the first-fruits, but that if we will pay the higher claim first, we shall be enabled to meet all other claims. I Kings 17:13, 14.
Bro. C.—Well, I presume I have been wanting in one important ingredient in my religious experience, and that is more faith; this may be because I did not make my works correspond with what faith I possessed. I am resolved to do better; and by the grace of God, I shall strive for a deeper experience in the things of God. I shall not rest until I see myself a complete victor over all my wrong habits, with tobacco, tea, and coffee under my feet. And instead of my wife and daughters being adorned with gold, jewels, feathers, and flowers, I will not be satisfied until I can realize that they possess that inward adorning, “even the ornament of a meek and quiet spirit, which is, in the sight of God, of great price.” You may look for me to attend the next camp-meeting with my whole family. I thank you for this long talk. You may put my name down on the tithing pledge; and if you will hand it to me, I am now ready to sign the teetotal pledge, also.
A.—When we take one advance step, with the light we have, it always affords us an opportunity to see where we can take another. I am glad to know that you will be at our next camp-meeting. You missed a great deal by not being present at the last one. At these meetings the wants of the cause at large are usually presented and talked over, and the spiritual interests of those who are present are considered. Our institutions at the head of the work,—the Publishing Houses, the College, the Sanitarium,—and our foreign missions, all need our support. And as we learn from the servants of God, of the struggles and embarrassments under which they are laboring; of the extent of the field which, in the providence of God, is opening up before them, and which is greater than their facilities can operate; of the amount of good which these institutions are accomplishing; and of what might be done—and must be done speedily—had they the means,—we are led to embrace the privilege of assisting them with our freewill-offerings, our sin-offerings, and our thank-offerings, in sending this present glorious message “to every nation, and kindred, and tongue, and people.”
Mr. I.—Is it so that the S. D. A. church make this tithing system a test of fellowship? It was reported to me that you compelled every one to adopt it before they could join your church.
A.—No; there is no compulsion about it. It is called among us “systematic benevolence.” We understand that all our service rendered to the Lord must be voluntary. I have been a member of the church for some time, and I have never yet seen any rejected or expelled because they did not pay tithes. We cannot see how a forced service can be acceptable to God. The soldiers of Christ must be volunteers. He wants no drafted or conscript recruits. Our tithes, gifts, offerings, and sacrifices must be given of our own free will. The Father gave his Son, and the Son gave his life, for the world, not because they were compelled to do so, but because they loved the world. The same principle must actuate us.
Mr. I.—I have listened with much interest to this evening’s talk, and I must say, the more I learn of it, the more I like it. I look at it as a perfect system of raising means for the support of the gospel. Its author must be the Author of salvation. This will obviate any necessity for church fairs, church raffles, festivals, and lotteries. If every one would adopt it, and bring “all the tithes” into the treasury, there would be a sufficient supply to meet every demand. I have been so disgusted with this modern mode of raising means, and with the weekly custom of passing ‘around the hat,’ that I have come to the conclusion, that I would rather remain away from church than to be dunned, and compelled every time I go, to hand out something under a tremendous pressure on my pride of character; for a niggardly person I despise. I call that a system of systematic compulsion.
I have said that if I could find them, I would unite myself with a people who were not indulging in any of these wrong practices to draw money from sinners, in order to relieve themselves of the burdens which they ought to bear; who were carrying out some system of equality in which all could share according to their respective financial conditions; and who were willing to send their ministers out to labor for sinners instead of keeping them at home to preach for themselves. How many develop into spiritual dwarfs, because they do nothing in the Master’s cause but listen to a sermon once or twice a week, while they grow into giants in worldly affairs, and become masters in music, millinery, and mantua-making! I am much pleased with the idea that those who have the light of the gospel should be ready to sacrifice for the good of those who have it not; and the fact that your people are all, with undivided interest, enlisted in the support and prosperity of such institutions, is, to my mind, the best evidence that their leader is Christ. Viewing this subject as I do now, I can see no way to avoid the conclusion that simply being a member of the Seventh-day Adventist church does not make this duty any more binding. It rests upon all alike, whether a man is a member or not; whether he likes it or hates it. The reason why any hate it is because they are ignorant of its beauty and justice. I am ashamed that I suffered false reports and rumors about this people to blind my eyes so long; and now, since they are opened, I look upon this tithing system as the crowning feature of the whole system of truth which your people are laboring so ardently to spread before the world. If fully adopted and carried out, it cuts the cords of avarice, selfishness, and haughty pride, and connects us with God, and identifies us with Him who died to take “away the sin of the world.” If you will, you can put my name on that pledge with Bro. C.’s. Good night.