THE SOUL.—NO. 4.
BY REV. N. WARDNER, D. D.
The Doctor shows a peculiar disposition to push aside every passage of Scripture that conflicts with his theory, under the plea that it is figurative language, while he relies upon the most figurative of all compositions—Hebrew poetry—to prove his doctrine, and insists that it must be taken literally, irrespective of its context. He refers to Eccl. 9:5, “The dead know not anything.” The context clearly shows that Solomon was talking about what occurs “under the sun,” i. e., in this world. To human view, the wicked are as well off as the righteous. One event (death) happens to all, and then they cease to know or be known “under the sun.” But see how careful the Doctor was to quote only part of a sentence. The reason is very apparent. The other part of the sentence spoils his argument. “The dead know not anything, neither have they any more a reward.” Now the Doctor insists that there is to be no rewards or punishments till after the resurrection. But Solomon says that these have no reward after their “breath goeth forth.” Thus the Doctor stabs his own theory with his own weapon. Solomon repeatedly states that he was talking about what was occurring in this world, “under the sun,” “under the heaven.” “What profit hath a man of all his labor under the sun?” Again, Ps. 146:4 is quoted, “His breath goeth forth, he returneth to his earth; in that very day his thoughts perish.” Does this teach that he will never think again? If so, there can be no reward or punishment after the resurrection, and so this also demolishes the Doctor's theory, who insists that there are no rewards and punishments till after the resurrection. The psalmist evidently meant that their worldly schemes, what they thought to accomplish, would come to naught at death; and here is the ground of his exhortation: “Put not your trust in princes, nor in the son of man, in whom there is no help” (verse 3). Why? because “his breath goeth forth” (verse 4). But “happy is he that hath the God of Jacob for his help;” because his plans cannot be affected by mortality. He “exalteth judgment for the oppressed,” “giveth food to the hungry,” and “looseth the prisoners.” Everything goes to show that the psalmist is talking about the affairs of this life.
As a parallel to 2 Cor. 12:2–4, “Whether in the body or out of the body, I cannot tell, God knoweth,” etc., the Doctor quotes 1 Cor. 5:3, “For I verily, as absent in body, but present in spirit,” and says that in both cases, Paul was present only in imagination. This may be the Doctor's idea, but evidently not Paul's idea. The first passage was written fourteen years after the event occurred, and he had had all that time to decide whether it were a fact or an imagination. He declared it to be a fact that he was so caught up, and a fact that he did not know whether he was, at the time, in the body or out of it. He emphasizes this part by repeating the statement twice. This proves that he believed it possible for the inner or spiritual man to be thus conscious, apart from the body (outer man), or else the statement was a deliberate deception. Any man would destroy his reputation for veracity, who should practice making such positive statements, if he did not mean what he said. Paul's expression in 1 Cor. 5:3 was a form of speech common then and now, and could deceive no one. He knew where he was, and that he was not out of the body. Hence the passages are not parallel.
In regard to my comment upon Luke 24:39, “A spirit hath not flesh and bones,” hence no brains, the Doctor says, “This seems to be a strong argument for the possibility of a conscious existence independent of a brain, but a little attention to the original words employed will relieve the difficulty.” He evidently hangs all his hopes of relief from his difficulty upon the Greek text—a hope doomed to perish. He says, “According to the learned Griesbach, the word rendered spirit in verse 37, is not pneuma, but phantasma, and that Christ referred to the same kind of a spirit which the disciples supposed they had seen, viz., a phantom.” But Griesbach, in his Greek Testament, put pneuma into verse 37, and not phantasma. Even if phantasma were in that verse, it would in no sense invalidate, or even weaken, my argument: for the disciples believed they saw Christ's spirit. Had they thought it was merely an imaginary phantom, they were men of too much sense and courage to be so afraid of it. Christ's sudden and unexpected appearance among them, the resemblance he bore to him who they knew was slain a few days before, and their disbelief of the report about his resurrection, were what made them think it was his spirit. It proves that they believed it possible for the spirits of the dead thus to appear to the living. And the fact that Christ used the word pneuma when assuring them that it was not his spirit, shows that he knew they thought it was his spirit which they saw. I have Griesbach's Greek Testament before me, in which phantasma not only does not appear in verse 37, nor any where in this chapter; nor in Greenfield's or Tischendorf's Greek Testaments, or any other text I ever saw or heard of; nor is it referred to as being in this verse in any concordance, lexicon, author, or commentary (except Dr. Kellogg), and I have taken unwearied pains to ascertain. It is stated that Griesbach, in his original work, put phantasma in the margin, which is, doubtless, all the foundation there is for the Doctor's statement. But Griesbach says phantasma, though suggested as a reading in verse 37, is yet without authority, and is to be repudiated; while in respect to verse 39, no such reading had ever been suggested. As stated before, even with phantasma in verse 37, the fact that Christ used pneuma as meaning what the disciples had in their minds, makes his testimony positive and unequivocal.p. 211
But the fact that pneuma is in both verses, makes the testimony of Christ as positive as is possible for language to make it, that spirits have a conscious, intelligent, existence, without flesh and bones or brains. What Christian can go back upon such testimony as this? If there be no such thing as a disembodied spirit, Christ knew it, and this was the time and place to correct their idea. But neither he nor the apostles ever showed the least inclination to do so, nor toward the Sadducean sentiment; but all the other way. His language is a positive confirmation of the truth of their idea of the conscious existence of disembodied spirits, or else he meant to deceive them, and through them deceive the world at large. Luke wrote this account thirty years after the occurrence, and if “the Spirit of truth,” whom Christ sent to guide them “into all truth,” and “bring all things to their remembrance whatsoever he had said unto them,” had given them any different instruction, he would not have recorded this as without a word of explanation. But in harmony with its teaching, the disciples went on casting evil spirits out of those possessed by them, just as Christ did, and declared them to be pneuma, as was generally believed, giving no hint that there was any error in that belief, while all they said and did went to confirm its truth beyond question.
Again, the Doctor says, “The kind of spirits which Christ cast out must have been of a different order; and, as shown, his (Christ's) remarks had no reference to them. He only said, 'A phantom hath not flesh and bones,' which is evidently true, since it is only an imaginary existence.” Reply: Where is the evidence that the spirits which Christ cast out were of a different order, since he called them by the same term, pneuma? Such an effort to escape shows that he feels himself to be in a tight place. Christ never said “A phantom hath not flesh and bones.” I call for an instance. Why should the Doctor say, “Christ asserted that he was not a phantom,” when there is no such statement in the Bible? Let the reader notice the significant fact that he very prudently passes over in silence the proofs I adduced that the demons cast out by Christ and the apostles were believed to be the spirits of dead men, and that they acquiesced in, and confirmed, that belief. I will add, Josephus (Ant. vol. 4, chap. 1, sec. 3) says, “They [Pharisees] also believed that souls have immortal vigor in them, and that under the earth there will be rewards and punishments, according as they have lived virtuously or viciously in this life, and that the latter are to be detained in everlasting prison. But the former shall have power to revive and live again; on account of which doctrine they are able greatly to persuade the body of the people; and whatever they do about divine worship, prayer, and sacrifice, they perform them according to their direction, inasmuch that the cities gave great attention to them, on account of their virtuous conduct.” The Sadducean doctrine is this, that souls die with the body. “The doctrine of the Essenes is this, that all things are best ascribed to God. They teach the immortality of the soul.” Now when Paul declared himself a Pharisee, with direct reference to the point of their difference with the Sadducees (Acts 23:6–8), he clearly indorsed their sentiment upon this question. Dr. Campbell, of Scotland, says that according to the pagan antiquity, “All their divinities were ghosts of dead men.” Dr. A. Campbell says, “The demons of paganism, Christianity, and Judaism were the spirits of dead men.” Justin Martyr says, “Those who are seized and tormented with the spirits of the dead, whom all call demons,” etc. Lardner says, “The notion of the demons, or the souls of the dead having power over living men, was universally prevalent among the heathen at that time, and believed by many Christians.” Now, is it credible that Christ and his apostles should teach as though they believed the same, and confirm their teaching by miracles, while they entertained a different idea, and never give any explanation? Did they mean to deceive, and did God connive at the deception in empowering them to work such confirmatory miracles? We are shut up to the necessity of believing that they deliberately deceived, and God helped them, or else that they indorsed the common belief on this subject. The Doctor, denying this, is bound to prove that such was not the sentiment of the Pharisees, and that when Paul said he was a Pharisee he was not one. If he were a Pharisee, he held with them on this point, since he sided with them against the Sadducees upon this issue. The Sadducees did not deny that man had a spirit while he lived, but that it ceased to exist at death. And as the Pharisees believed in the existence of angels and disembodied spirits of men, and Christ (Luke 24:39) and Paul (Acts 23:6–8) clearly indorsed the Pharisees' views on this point, leaves no ground for doubt as to their position. It also gives positiveness to what Paul and Peter meant by departing from, or going out of, their bodies at death, and being with Christ.
The Doctor, who claims that a spirit cannot exist without a body, and that it is mere breath or life, labors to make it appear that where the Scriptures say, evil spirits entered into and were cast out of men, it does not mean that they actually did enter into or go out of them. Such is evidently his only hope of escape out of his dilemma. He says, “The language is figurative, evidently referring to the mental condition of the individual, having particular relation to the purposes and motives. A person in this condition would be really possessed by Christ, having become, as expressed in 2 Cor. 5:17, 'a new creation.' Just so with demoniacal possession. The evil spirit did not actually enter into the person possessed, but controlled him by filling his mind with evil thoughts and purposes. Casting out evil spirits was simply delivering an individual from its influence, and thus casting out of the mind the evil designs and purposes placed there by it.”
Let it be remembered that the Doctor insists that a pneuma (spirit) has no life nor mind, but is mere “life-imparting breath;” that it “is never represented as having life.” Then how can an unintelligent, lifeless breath of air control man and fill their minds with evil thoughts and purposes? Or how can one puff of air do it more than another?
Again, the Doctor claims that the brain, and not the mind, controls the man; and that “mind is merely the manifestation of its action.” If a man's brains, and not his mind, has power to control him, how could another brain outside of him control him by thrusting thoughts and motives into his mind, yet not get into his mind after all? What he says about becoming “a new creation” could only, according to his theory, result from a change wrought in the brain, and thus cause it to originate thoughts of a different kind. This would make man an irresponsible machine.
It seems, according to the Doctor, that a legion of spirits (breaths?) got after one man, and so filled his mind with evil thoughts and purposes, that no fetters or chains could bind him; and when Christ appeared for his deliverance, they asked to be allowed not to enter into, but to go near to, a herd of two thousand swine, that they might “fill their minds with evil thoughts and purposes;” and their request being granted, they went for them, and so vitiated their “purposes” that they ran near to the sea and were choked, not by the water getting into their lungs, but near to. Again, when Christ and the eunuch were baptized, they did not actually go down into the water or come out of it, but near to it. This may explain, also, why the three worthies were not destroyed in the fiery furnace. They did not get into the fire at all. And Daniel was not cast into the lion's den, but only near by it. No wonder they all escaped unharmed. The Doctor's rule of interpretation also opens a very comforting thought to the wicked, as it removes all occasion to fear of being cast into hell, or into the lake of fire, but simply close by, outside. On the other hand, it cuts off all hope of the saints getting into Heaven or the New Jerusalem, but only near enough to see and feel their privation and loss. The very identical words used in the Greek and English texts, where it says these demons entered into and went out of the possessed, are used when stating that Christ and the eunuch went into and came out of the water when baptized, and where it says the wicked shall be cast into hell, into the lake of fire, and that the saints shall enter into the heavenly Jerusalem, etc. The Doctor would find it hard to stem the weapons he thus furnishes when wielded by Pedobaptists and infidels. They have as good authority for using these words in such a figurative sense as he has. If he insists upon a literal interpretation of Scripture language when it favors his theory, and upon a figurative sense when the literal goes against his theory, he thus justifies such liberty in them. The only show of necessity he has for so interpreting these words, is that his theory is endangered and can only be saved by this means.
The Doctor closes his paragraph by saying, “We do not find the evidence that either Christ or the apostles sided with any one of the various sects which existed among the Jews at the time of the first advent, or indorsed any of their notions which were contrary to the Bible.” Well, who does? This last clause looks as though the Doctor is so thoroughly convinced that Christ and the apostles did side with the Pharisees in regard to disembodied spirits, that he dare not deny it, and therefore throw in that remark so as to give the appearance of denying it and yet not do it. If otherwise, why did he tack it on? The fact, which is indisputable, that they indorsed the prevailing sentiment, that disembodied human spirits could and did exist, proves it to be not “contrary to the Bible,” but in harmony with it. It proves, also, that Paul and Peter meant as they said, that at death they should leave, or depart out of, their bodies and be with Christ.
In his summary, the Doctor says, in regard to the soul and spirit, “The question is a peculiarly scientific one.” This implies that he despairs of sustaining his position by the Bible, which he complains leaves us so much in the dark. I do not wonder that he wants to get away from the Bible in this investigation, when he feels driven to such extreme methods of interpretation in order to present even a plausible apology for his position, and then fail. If this “is peculiarly a scientific question,” let us have scientific demonstrations that a human soul is an immaterial concept, a mere abstraction, a form, pure and simple, aside from matter or any other means of representation; that God and other spiritual beings are mere breaths; that life results from organization, and not organization from life. Let us have proofs, and not mere assertions.
REPLY.
Eld. W. seeks to weaken the force of Eccl. 9:5, which is a complete refutation of his view of the nature of man, by asserting that Hebrew poetry is very figurative, and does not mean what it reads: Upon this basis he contends that Solomon did not really mean, “The dead know not anything,” but, “The dead know not anything,” “under the sun,” or “in this world.” In other words, according to Eld. W., the real fact, according to Solomon's statement in this text, is that while the dead know more than they ever did during life, they know nothing about what is going on “under the sun,” or “in this world.” According to this view, there is something within a man which leaves his body at death and leaves this world, goes off to some other planet, to some other part of the universe, or to some subterranean place in this globe, perhaps, as the ancient Jews believed; at least, gets so far away from the sense of earthly activity that it can know nothing of anything which transpires here. The reader will please mark this point, and observe that Eld. W. emphasizes his statement by repetition, that Solomon “was talking about what was occurring in this world, 'under the sun,' 'under the heaven.'” We shall revert to this point again, for we shall soon find that our reviewer “stabs his own theory with his own weapon.” We have no difficulty at all with the text, notwithstanding the attempt to make it appear otherwise. Solomon says, “The dead know not anything.” We believe him, and take his testimony without questioning. He also says, “Neither have they any more a reward,” which we believe just as much. Does Eld. W. believe that a dead man can have a reward? He speaks as though he really believed it possible for a dead man to be both rewarded and punished. We believe no such absurd doctrine, and we have Solomon's testimony to sustain us. The prophet Isaiah evidently agreed with Solomon also; for he said, “The grave cannot praise thee.”—“The living, he shall praise thee.” Isa. 38:19. So also the psalmist. “In death there is no remembrance of thee,” Ps. 6:5. “The dead praise not the Lord.” Ps. 115:17. There is perfect unanimity of sentiment among Bible writers on this point; yet Eld. W. will insist that a dead man knows more than a live one; that death is not death, but an introduction to a higher state of existence; that the grave is not a place of silence and gloom, and a state of unconsciousness, as always described in the Bible (“In the grave who shall give thee thanks?” Ps. 6:5), but the opposite in every particular. Undoubtedly Hebrew poetry is highly figurative, but even poetic license will not excuse such laxity in the use of language as to employ it to express exactly the opposite of what is meant. Solomon says, “The dead know not anything.” Eld. W. holds that the dead know more than the living. Solomon says, “Neither have they any more a reward.” Eld. W. holds that they are both rewarded and punished. We agree with Solomon in both particulars. While a man is dead, he knows nothing, and is incapable of being rewarded or punished. When he is resurrected, he is capable of receiving both rewards and punishments. Will our reviewer point out to us a little more clearly how “the other part of the sentence” spoils our argument?
Referring to Ps. 146:4, “In that very day his thoughts perish,” Eld. W. asks, “Does this teach that he will never think again?” Of course not. It teaches simply that while a man is dead, he does not think, instead of thinking clearer and faster than ever before, as held by Eld. W. The question is utterly irrelevant, and the poor pretense of an argument based on his irrelevant query, is utterly worthless. Our reviewer's language needs a little modifying to make it read in accordance with truth. It should be, “And so this [does not] also demolishes [demolishes] the Doctor's theory.” This argument irresistibly reminds us of the toy balloons often seen on the streets on pleasant days. Just cut the string, and the gas bag quickly goes up out of sight of its own levity and explodes.
Eld. W. asserts that we show “a peculiar disposition to push aside every passage of Scripture which conflicts with our theory.” We are unconscious of doing so, and shall not feel convicted of such illogical conduct until the texts thus pushed aside are mentioned. We have been surprised, however, that notwithstanding our repeated references to such texts as Ps. 146:4, Isa. 38:19, Ps. 6:5, 115:17, our reviewer has made no serious attempt to explain or reconcile them with his view. If this is not pushing aside, it is ignoring altogether whatever scripture cannot be made to appear to support a favorite position.
Eld. W. again brings up Paul's figurative expression in 2 Cor. 12:2, “Whether in the body or out of the body.” We have given a fair explanation of this text (See our third article in reply), and Eld. W. has not shown our explanation to be in any way unfair nor invalid. If he will give as good an explanation of the texts just referred to which represent death as a state of unconsciousness, we shall feel in duty bound to abandon our position and accept his. The learned Dr. Benson says that Paul had a vision. In this all commentators agree. Indeed, we do not need to refer to any commentator; for Paul himself says at the beginning of his account of his extraordinary experience, “I will come to visions and revelations,” and then immediately begins his description of a vision which he had, probably when in the trance referred to in Acts 22:17. Paul simply had a vision; that is, he had a mental representation which made so strong an impression upon him that he could not tell whether he was taken bodily to Heaven or whether he had hadp. 212
an ordinary vision. In expressing his doubt he used “a form of speech common then,” similar and entirely analogous to that used in 1 Cor. 5:3, “absent in body, but present in spirit.” It would be just as reasonable for a person to insist that Paul actually asserted that his spirit was in Corinth while his body was at Ephesus, basing the position on 1 Cor. 5:3, as to take Eld. W.'s position respecting the meaning of 2 Cor. 12:2. Paul does not say that there is in man an intelligent, conscious entity that can leave the body and retain consciousness. That he held a very contrary view is evident from the following passage from his first letter to the Corinthians, 15:17, 18: “If Christ be not raised, your faith is vain; . . . they also which are fallen asleep in Christ are perished.” According to Eld. W., they “which are fallen asleep in Christ” are “happier than while in the flesh.” According to Paul, their only hope of happiness is through the resurrection. Will Eld. W. assert that Paul taught one doctrine to the Corinthians in his first letter, and the very opposite in his second epistle?
Again, according to Eld. W., the separation of the “outer” and the “inner” man is death. Then “in the body” is the state of being alive, while “out of the body” is the condition of death. It follows from this that Paul's meaning in the expression, “whether in the body, I cannot tell, or whether out of the body, I cannot tell,” was simply that he did not know whether he was alive or dead. That is, according to Eld. W.'s view, he did not know whether he was taken to Heaven bodily, or whether he died, his body remaining in a state of death while his spirit was in Heaven, being resurrected again upon its return. If this was what happened to Paul when he had a vision, it must be held that the same thing happened to Samuel, David, Isaiah, Daniel, Peter, John, and all others who have ever had visions, as well as to Paul himself on every occasion when he had a vision. Paul must have experienced death and resurrection many times in the course of his life! Really, this view is too absurd for credence when carefully examined. The fact is, Paul had a vision, and his query was whether he really went to Heaven, or only in imagination, just as he made a visit to the Corinthians while writing them from Ephesus. John, the Revelator, describes a similar experience thus: “He carried me away in the spirit.” John seems to have had a more definite idea of his condition than did Paul, for he knew that he did not go bodily, but only in mind or imagination, “in spirit.”
Our authority for the statement with reference to the word translated “spirit” in Luke 24:37, was Greenfield's Greek Testament. The word phantasma is put in the margin, with a reference which indicates it to be “a reading adopted into the text, while the received reading is placed by Griesbach at the bottom of the page.” If our statement is incorrect, we must make Greenfield responsible for it, unless we greatly misunderstand him. The evidence is at least positive that some manuscripts contain phantasma, else the word would not be suggested as an emendation. If, as Eld. W. states, Griesbach has pneuma instead of phantasma, it is high time that the publishers of Greenfield's Testament should be made aware of so grave an error. As we have not a copy of the original edition of Griesbach's Testament published at Leipsic in 1805, we cannot decide between Eld. W. and Mr. Greenfield. Dr. Olshausen, the well-known and eminent German theologian, commenting on Matt. 14:26, “And when the disciples saw him walking on the sea, they were troubled, saying, It is a spirit [phantasma]; and they cried out for fear,” remarks, “Pneuma, pneuma, stands in a similar connection at Luke 24:37. The term is to be understood in all its latitude like our word apparition.” According to this learned authority, the meaning of the word in Luke 24:37, is phantasm, or apparition, whether the original is pneuma or phantasma, so we need not have any difficulty about the original text. Tertullian, who lived in the second century after Christ, regarded the text in the very same light. In referring to it he remarks: “When they were doubting whether he were not a phantom,—nay, were supposing that he was one,” etc. The evidence is, it appears to us, as strong as need be that the position taken by us on this question in a former article is the correct one; viz., that the disciples were frightened when the Saviour appeared to them after his resurrection, for the same reason that they were when they saw him walking upon the sea (Mark 6:49), because “they supposed it had been a spirit,” (phantasma). Nevertheless, if it should be shown conclusively that pneuma is the proper word, and that it is here used with the significance of spirit or angel, we are still prepared to meet the argument fully and conclusively, since the term is not in a single instance used with words which indicate that it means an immortal, immaterial entity.
It makes not the slightest difference to our view whether a pneuma, or spirit, an angel, has flesh and bones or not, provided it is material, the contrary of which still remains to be proven.
Our reviewer next attempts to prove that Christ and the apostles were believers in the doctrine that demons were the spirits of dead men. He thinks it a “significant fact” that we passed over in silence the proofs he adduced to sustain this position. It certainly did not occur to us before that an attempt had been made to “prove” so strange a position as this. But we will show our willingness to consider the argument adduced as fully as our reviewer can desire.
The chief argument made, is this: The Pharisees believed that the spirits of dead men have power to take possession of living persons. “The notion of the demons, or the souls of the dead, having power over living men, was universally prevalent among the heathen at that time.” Paul said he was a Pharisee, hence he believed that demons were the spirits of dead men! Now let us try the same reasoning on another point. The Pharisees believed in works of supererogation, in self-atonement for sins by good works, and that thoughts were not sinful, no matter how vile, unless carried into action. If Eld. W.'s style of argument is worth anything, Paul also believed these unchristian doctrines. The Pharisees also held many foolish notions; for example, they believed it to be wrong to eat eggs laid the day following a feast-day, because they were formed the day before, or on the feast-day. Was Paul a believer in this foolish doctrine? According to Josephus, the Pharisees held the doctrine of transmigration, according to which the souls of human beings at death enter the bodies of lower animals. Paul said he was a Pharisee. According to Eld. W.'s mode of reasoning, Paul also believed this Egyptian fallacy. According to the quotation from Josephus cited by Eld. W., the Pharisees believed that the dead receive rewards and punishments “under the earth.” Did Paul believe the same?
If Eld. W. is willing to accept the above results of his theory, he must also accept these absurd notions. According to the quotation cited from Lardner, this notion in question was a heathenish doctrine which was adopted by some Christians, just as the doctrine of transmigration was adopted by Origen, Porphyry, and others of the “early Fathers.” How does this prove anything? Is it probable that Christ would adopt and teach a doctrine which originated in heathen darkness? Our reviewer must offer stronger evidence than he has yet presented before we shall be willing to believe such a doctrine as this.
Says Eld. W., “The Doctor, who claims that a spirit cannot exist without a body, and that it is mere breath or life,” etc. This is not a fair presentation of our definition of spirit. It may refer to the mind, to the spiritual or moral nature or faculties in contrast with the carnal nature or the propensities. It is also used as relating to the influence of a being.
Eld. W. attacks our position respecting the manner in which Christ and the apostles cast out devils, and the nature of demons, with ridicule and “borrowed wit,” but presents nothing worthy the name of substantial argument. It seems too evident to require demonstration that the nature of spirit possession was as we claim; viz., that the demon, or evil angel, did not get inside of an individual, but simply obtained an influence over his mind. Casting out the demon was simply delivering the individual from the demoniacal influence. This seems to us much more consistent than the opposite view, that an evil spirit actually got inside of the person possessed, so that he had two souls or spirits in one body; or will it be claimed that one spirit went out as the other came in?
It is quite as easy for us to conceive how an agent outside of the body could control or influence the mind through the brain, as how an immaterial agent outside could affect another immaterial agent or entity inside; and much easier than to conceive how an immaterial entity can govern the material body.
The old question of the will and moral responsibility comes up again. Eld. W. will please not forget that the question of the will must be settled for the beast as well as for man. If it proves the possession of an immaterial soul for one, it does the same for the other. The question of demons' will is no more difficult than all other questions which relate to the nature of willing power. When Eld. W. has asserted that the willing power is an immaterial entity within man, he has explained nothing, but only put the question back one step: This is a favorite method of getting rid of difficulties which is often indulged in by scientists as well as by theologians. It is just as easy to conceive of a human brain which is self-controlling as to conceive of an immaterial entity which is not only self-
controlling but also able to control the body. If the brain is not self-controlling, and needs a regulating entity, what evidence is there that the same necessity may not exist for the entity which controls it, so that it also requires a regulating force or entity. Thus we might go back, finding a necessity for something back of all, as far as we can calculate. The great defect in the immaterial-entity theory, as an explanation of the will, is that it leaves us exactly where we start, viz., wholly in the dark as to the nature of the controlling power. Before Eld. W. offers this argument again, will he have the kindness to present a more credible theory which will remove these difficulties.
Eld. W. asserts that the fact is indisputable that Christ and the apostles “indorsed the prevailing sentiment that disembodied human spirits could and did exist;” but he has not yet presented anything more than assertions on this point. We are, indeed, not a little astonished that our reviewer should adopt a position which is the very foundation of modern spiritualism. If, as he asserts, the spirits of the dead have power over the living, what can prevent them from “rapping,” “table-tipping,” giving communications, presenting “materializations,” and, in short, doing all that is claimed for them by believers in modern spiritualism? Judging from the positions taken in the latter part of this article, our reviewer is as firm a believer in the main doctrines of spiritualism as its warmest adherents.
Again we are compelled to call attention to the disposition of our reviewer to commit the logical blunder of attempting to ride two horses at the same time. In this very article he has maintained that when Solomon said, “The dead know not anything,” he had reference to what occurs “under the sun,” “in this world.” This position he was driven to take to avoid the undesirable conclusion that the dead are unconscious. Now, in order to sustain another point, he has assumed the opposite position. If he can reconcile his position that when Solomon said, “The dead know not anything,” he “was talking about what was occurring in this world,” “under the sun,” with his later assertion that “the demons cast out by Christ and the apostles were . . . the spirits of dead men [his very words],” he will be able to convince us that black and white are precisely alike, and that the most diametrically opposite views are identical. Is it possible that a demon could get into a man, impel him to commit acts of violence, and finally be cast out of him by a miracle, and yet “know not anything” “about what was occurring in this world,” “under the sun?” Such obtuseness in such lively demons as those that drove the herd of swine into the sea, is utterly incomprehensible. Our reviewer must be very much at a loss for arguments to be compelled to resort to such contradictory positions as these. Indeed it seems to us that his logical forces are getting sadly demoralized when they allow him to run into such a dilemma as this.
In his last paragraph Eld. W. calls for scientific demonstrations, etc. In reply we have only to remark that we do not think it worth while to offer more arguments until what we have offered have received attention. In our last article we called attention to the fact that of the several primary positions in our view only one, and that really a conclusion, had been attacked, no notice being taken of the other and more important ones. J. H. KELLOGG.