Beecher's Elmira Church

20%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 23, 1880

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 14.

Read the full edition

Beecher's Elmira Church.

Under this heading the Philadelphia Times thus fittingly rebukes that travesty of religious worship maintained by T. K. Beecher at Elmira, N. Y.:—
Among the blessings showered upon a hardly appreciative world by the family of Beechers, not the least important is an invention of Thomas K., the brother of Henry Ward, who lives at Elmira, in New York. This Doctor Beecher shares the Plymouth ideas to the extent, at least, that any religion is better than none, and that anything is better than to preach to empty benches. Addressing his powerful mind—was there ever a Beecher mind that wasn't powerful in its way?—to the problem of making the house of God a popular place of resort, he has invented, and will no doubt patent, a style of church which we are sure needs only to be known to become the rage wherever Beecherism, in the mild form propagated by Thomas K., has votaries. A church constructed on this principle is warranted to draw crowds in any weather, and it is asserted by the local journal whence our item is clipped that already the one in Elmira has thrown the other great institutions of the city, the Female Seminary and the Water Cure, completely in the background. How this can be will not be apparent to those who are familiar only with churches constructed and managed on the old-fashioned plan, but we have only to give details to convince the most skeptical.
Briefly stated, the underlying principle of the Elmira plan is the making of a church as little like a church as possible. The great thing to be kept in view is, to make religion and religious association so subordinate to everything else that men and women who are seduced within the walls of the building will never suspect for a moment that they are in a sacred edifice. There are the parlors, furnished in the Eastlake style; the black walnut floors carpeted with rich rugs; the walls adorned with no pictures that are likely to give offense to the sensitive skeptic. Here there is a regular round of tea parties, kettle-drums, game suppers, and, for aught we know, Germans, not to speak of such mild dissipations as sewing societies, which do anything else but sew. Convenient to this are the well-stocked pantry, and a kitchen with all the modern improvements, but the flavor of religion is never obtruded in the culinary department any more than in the parlors. Some of the Elmira people, however, did not succumb either to the parlor or kitchen, and were equally proof against a well-supplied reading room. So a billiard room was thoughtfully added for the recreation of the young men, and the tap of the cue and the kiss of the balls are now heard by day and by night. This, again, is supplemented by a cozy little theater, playfully styled a “romp room” in the guide books and the play bills. At one end of this apartment are the scenery, drop curtain, footlights, orchestra stall, and all the other indispensable adjuncts of a play-house. Here there are performances of a varied nature, but as a general thing the children are assembled once in two weeks for amusements in which the stage effects are not necessary, and a high old time they have. The Shakespeare Club meets weekly in the reading room. We would like to say something about the place where divine service is held, but no reference is made to it in the descriptions of the church furnished the public. There must be some closet or corner somewhere for this thing.
Enough has been said to show what Doctor Beecher's invention is doing for the cause of Christianity. The idea is capable of indefinite expansion and variation. The time has passed when churches were used simply for singing and praying. Those exercises may be indulged in at discretion by the fireside. A church is to be a place of amusement, and, if it is to be a place of amusement, is not the Elmira-Beecher's plan better than Henry Ward's or Bro. Talmage's? Why not give the young man his first lessons in billiards under the pastor's directions? Afterward, if he yearns for more steady employment in that noble game, or if he happens to be in a city where the churches have not the Elmira improvements, he may drop in at the more gorgeous establishments, where the bar is handy and the winner sets up the drinks. And why stop at square dances in the church parlor, or comedy in the church theater, or billiards in the church saloon? When these things pall upon the young, or they learn to go elsewhere for the same things on a large scale, new attractions may be devised. Every church may have its card tables on the Saratoga plan, or its weekly or monthly balls, or a variety show now and then, or its race track within walking distance of the sacred edifice, membership in the church society to entitle one to admission to the grounds. Doctor Beecher's is a happy thought. We commend it to Christians generally for careful consideration. It may not please the old school, but it will bring recruits to the new, and soon the old landmarks will be replaced entirely by those to which the unregenerate can offer no objection.