AdventAI

LETTER FROM A BOARDING-SCHOOL-MISS TO A FRIEND.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 14., September 23, 1880

Dear Dolly: Just think, now! It’s not so at all; After all we have heard of our loss by the Fall, The New-lights of Science now make it quite clear That that’s not the cause of our sinning, my dear!

Papa says, “Our preachers will now have to change The field of their vision, and take a new range; For the world has, at length, grown too wise to believe The old-woman’s story of Adam and Eve!”

He says, “Mr. Darwin conclusively shows, That man was not made in his present fair shape; He was not created, as people suppose, But grew by degrees, from the monkey or ape!”*

But who made the monkey he could not explain, And so answered sharply, “Now, Kate, I must beg That you will not expose this your folly again— Don’t you know he came forth from the primitive egg?”

But what that egg came from, or how it was hatched, Is more than this poor brain of mine can conceive; Or that the first ovum, like quilt-work, was patched With all shapes of life, is too much to believe!†

There’s father! I’m sure, now, that people must own, That he’s noble and manly—quite free from low sins— And his father, and his; why, as you go down, Pray where, tell me where, this new process begins.

It must begin somewhere! For don’t you suppose, If monkeys were given to turn into men, We should sometimes fall in with the cases of those Who were true to this law of their kindred again?

It would be too funny—part monkey, part man, The one fading gradually off to the other, Till what as the meanest of monkeys began Grows into the laughing Miss Blank or her brother!

Perhaps, too, it is so! Papa says it’s clear— How else could it be that the very same men Should one day so noble and manly appear, And the next jabber off into monkeys again?

But isn’t it awful? Just think of it, dear! For just as you’re thinking you’re something divine, And how lovely the lists of your kindred appear— To find an old ape at the head of the line!

But pa says there’s one thing that can’t be explained; One question, to solve which no labors avail; You can’t guess what it is? After all they have gained, They can give no account of man’s losing his tail!‡

It’s the fly in the amber, that can’t be removed; The dross in the silver, that won’t purge away; It’s the test of their folly, that can’t be disproved, Let them argue against it as much as they may!

And then, too, I think that too much is required, When we’re not to believe that food strengthens the frame; But that hunger itself, at the first, was acquired, To furnish the pleasure of filling the same!§

I prefer to believe, as I’ve always been taught, That language was God’s gracious gift unto man; And cannot but smile at the comical thought That an ape, accidentally, hit out the plan.||

If these are the New-lights of Science, my dear, We’d better hold on to the old-fashioned creed; For the Bible, although not in all things quite clear, Still shows us that God and the Saviour we need!

And it’s something to know, though not wholly divine, There’s a spirit within us that came from above; And learns, ’mid the changes of earth, to recline Like a babe on the bosom of Infinite Love —The Covenant.

Notes

  1. *“Man is descended from a hairy quadruped, furnished with a tail, and pointed ears, probably arboreal in its habits, and an inhabitant of the Old World.”—Darwin’s Descent of Man, Appleton’s Ed., vol., ii. 372. “In a series of forms graduating, insensibly, from some ape-like creature to man as he now exists,” etc.—Ibid., vol. i. p. 226. “The early ape-like progenitors of man.”—Ibid., vol. i. 81, 83, etc. “Man alone has become a biped.”—Ibid., vol. i. 135. ↩
  2. †It is evident that Miss Kate had not profited by her reading; for has not Hugh Miller put into the mouth of the Lamarckian philosopher, this comprehensive declaration: “Where the ditch now opens, the generations of the man atop, lived, died and were developed. There, flourished and decayed his great great great great grandfather, the sea-pen; his great great great grandfather, the mussel; his great great grandfather, the herring, his great grandfather, the frog; his grandfather, the porpoise; and his father, the monkey.”—Footprints of the Creator, p. 219. ↩
  3. ‡“No explanation, as far as I am aware, has been given of the loss of the tail, by certain apes, and man!”—Ibid., p. 144. ↩
  4. §“In the same manner, as the sense of hunger and the pleasure of eating were, no doubt, first acquired in order to induce animals to eat.”—Ibid., p. 77. ↩
  5. ||“It does not appear altogether incredible that some unusually wise, ape-like animal should have thought of imitating the growl of a beast of prey, so as to indicate the nature of the expected danger. And this would have been a first step in the formation of a language.”—Ibid., p. 55. ↩