AdventAI

Question Corner

From Signs of the Times, Vol. 38, No. 50., December 19, 1911

“IF YE WILL INQUIRE, INQUIRE YE.”

This Inquirers’ Department is conducted for the purpose of helping those who are studying the Bible. The answers are oftentimes only suggestive. They are never to be considered infallible, only as they agree with the infallible Word. The writer who may answer them does not consider that his opinion is infallible. He will simply give the best that he has, and plead with the inquirer to search the Word. Such questions only will be answered as, to the editors, seem to minister to the good of the readers and to the mission of the paper. We can not answer repeatedly in the same volume questions upon the same scripture. The name and address must accompany question, not for publication, but as an evidence of good faith, and that answer may be made by letter if deemed advisable. No letters are answered which do not contain the name of the writer. It is well always to enclose stamp for reply.

3622 — Questions to Seventh-Day Adventists

Where is the proof that man had ever before kept the Sabbath, except by special commandment, anterior to the proclamation of the Ten Commandments on Mount Sinai?

This is one of several questions which a correspondent sends us from Haiti. They are a revamping of a number of questions published in a tractlet several years ago, and still in circulation, entitled “Hard Nuts for Seventh-Day Adventists to Crack.” The edition in Haiti seems to have been published by a minister there as if they were original with him. Most of them are mere catch phrases. They puzzle no one who understands the Word of God. The one above quoted is a fair sample of several. We have God’s law proclaimed from heaven to Israel for the world, in Exodus 20. Exodus is a book of law. Genesis is not a book of law at all; it is simply a record of God’s providential dealings with His children, and of the channel through which the promised Seed who would save the world was to come. It gives us records of events, but nowhere does it give us a code of laws. We could as well ask concerning a half dozen other of the commandments: Where is the record that God ever told us to do this or that? Where is the commandment in Genesis that we should honor our father and mother, or that we should have no other gods before the Lord, or that we should not make any graven images, or should not covet? Of course the record shows very clearly that all these laws were in force, and that he who transgressed them committed sin before God. That record just as conclusively, and even more strongly, shows that the Sabbath was in force during all that time. The very record of its making, as Lange points out in his commentary on Gen. 2:2, 3, shows that God must have given a command concerning that day in the sanctifying, or setting apart, of that day to His glory. And when we come to the 16th chapter of Exodus, as soon as Israel was relieved from the slavery in Egypt, one of the first things done is to restore to them the Sabbath, spoken of not as a new institution, but as a well-known institution which was already in vogue. This the commandment also indicates: “Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy.”

3623 — Meaning of Circumcision

Will you please explain and harmonize Acts 16:1-3 and Gal. 5:2-4? J. A. P.

There is no inharmony in the texts. The apostle tells us in Gal. 6:15 that in Christ Jesus neither circumcision availeth anything nor uncircumcision, but a new creature; and the same elsewhere. Timothy was circumcised simply to relieve the Jews from prejudice. There was nothing against it; there was nothing in favor of it. It did not help to save Timothy. Timothy knew that; Paul knew that. The only reason it was done was that it took away the prejudice of the Jews. It is one of the things in which it was proper to yield to their prejudice when it cost no principle. Timothy could then go into Jewish synagogues and the Jewish temple and would be listened to. Gal. 5:2-4 tells us that there is no hope in circumcision. Circumcision stood in its beginning for righteousness. Abraham had accepted God, and his sins had been forgiven, and he stood clean before God, and circumcision was given him as a seal of the righteousness which is by faith. Rom. 4:11. Now, the men that did not look to Christ, but did look to circumcision, by that very fact were bound to stand holy before the law, and to do the whole law, which no man could do. Consequently it condemned them rather than justified them. And therefore the comment of the apostle Paul in Rom. 2:28, 29: “He is not a Jew, which is one outwardly; neither is that circumcision, which is outwardly in the flesh: but he is a Jew, which is one inwardly; and circumcision is that of the heart, in the spirit, not in the law; whose praise is not of men, but of God.” But all that can come only through Christ.

3624 — Jew, Gentile, Church

If Israel signifies church, or church Israel, why did Paul himself make a distinction between Jews, Gentiles, and church?

This is another of those “hard” questions. He who has read Paul’s epistles will have no trouble in answering it. The text referred to is, “Give no occasion of stumbling, either to Jews, or to Greeks, or to the church of God.” By the Jews Paul meant the unbelieving Jews. He declares in another place, “They are not all Israel, which are of Israel.” Rom. 9:6. He makes very clear distinction between the unbelieving Jews and the true Jews. The true Jew is not the one who is a Jew outwardly, but he is a Jew who is one inwardly. Circumcision is that of the heart, in the spirit, not in the law. Now the Jew to which he refers in 1 Cor. 10:32 is the unbelieving Jews: “Ye shall give no occasion of stumbling to them, or to Greeks, or Gentiles—the unbelieving Gentiles. We should give no occasion of stumbling to them. And we should bring that still closer home: give no occasion of stumbling to the church of God, composed of believers from both Jews and Gentiles; but having accepted of the Lord Jesus Christ, all of those believers become the true Israel of God. So the apostle declares, “If ye be Christ’s, then are ye Abraham’s seed, and heirs according to the promise.” Gal. 3:29. And so, also, he declares in the 2d chapter of Ephesians, that those who believe in Christ “are built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Jesus Christ Himself being the chief Corner-stone.” They are all then of the true Israel of God.

This is a sample of these questions. They are mere quibbles, efforts to evade duty. There is but one thing, and only one thing, that men may bring which can not be answered, and that is the carnal heart, because “the carnal mind is enmity against God: for it is not subject to the law of God, neither indeed can be,” and no scripture can be brought which will satisfy the carnal mind regarding God’s law. But when the individual is willing to put away that carnal mind and accept of the everlasting, universal, unlimited authority of God in Jesus Christ, he will have no question or quibble over a single commandment of God. Rather, he will say, with the psalmist, “O how love I Thy law! it is my meditation all the day,” and he will say, with the apostle, “This is the love of God, that we keep His commandments: and His commandments are not grievous.”

3625 — Strong Drink

Please explain Deut. 14:25, 26. Does it mean that a man is allowed to drink strong drink, as fermented wine, or something like it, or liquor? F. G.

There were no such strong drinks in the days when that scripture was written as we have at the present time. There were no distilled liquors in that day, and the strongest of all liquors were fermented liquors. And even these could have had no such effect as the drug-doctored wines and fermented liquors of the present time. Our inquirer should take the context also. God is talking to a people who are devoted to Him, who have yielded themselves to Him, who are doing His will, who are coming together to rejoice in Him. And this very feast referred to in Deut. 14:23, 26 is a place where they were to rejoice before God. We can not believe that when His people stood in that relationship to Him, they would be lusting after the things that were evil and wicked. In all such cases, the Christian especially ought to take home to the heart the apostle Paul’s rule in 1 Cor. 10:31: “Whether therefore ye eat, or drink, or whatsoever ye do, do all to the glory of God.”

3626 — Great Sacrifices

Solomon offered 142,000 animals as burnt offerings. Explain how this was possible. 1 Kings 8:63. M. H. W.

Simply by multiplying altars and using more priests. The 64th verse tells us that he hallowed the middle of the court which was before the house of Jehovah. It does not tell us that he had any altar there, but it shows that he did have probably many altars there—the burnt offerings, and the meal-offerings, and the fat of the peace-offerings, because the present altar that was before Jehovah was too little to receive the burnt offerings and the meal-offering and the fat of the peace-offerings. And this lasted fourteen days. This was about 10,145 offerings a day—about 845 an hour. These doubtless were multiple offerings, that is, many offerings may have been offered upon one altar at once. There are many ways in which this could be done. We do not know just how. We have the fact stated, and we may be sure that in that great assembly and with all the facilities at hand, the thing could have been carried on without any difficulty.

3627 — Jonah’s Case

Please explain Jonah 2:5. J. J. W.

In the song of triumph which he sang after he was delivered from the sea-monster, Jonah 2:5 reads, “The waters compassed me about, even to the soul; the deep was round about me; the weeds were wrapped about my head.” He is simply, in a poetical phraseology, telling of his experience in the stomach of the great fish. That is all. “Compassed about even to the soul” means even to the life. Of course he would have died there if it had not been for God’s providential care over him. He would have drowned, or smothered, in the stomach of the fish, as truly as he would in the waters themselves, if it had not been for God’s goodness in keeping him. We do not know what other point our correspondent may have in mind. He will have to make it plainer, if we do not touch upon it.