THE IMPRECATORY PSALMS.
There has been a warm discussion on the subject. The principal disputants were Mr. Jim Manly on one side, and Dea. Thresher on the other. Each one was aided by petty reinforcements of remark from time to time as some idea struck the listeners.
Mr. Jim “did not wish to make any reflection on the text, nor to find any fault with the spirit of the writer of the psalms in question. Still he did think, and he hoped he might be excused for saying, that, as it appeared to him, human nature occasionally got the better of grace, and even David in his vexation would say severe things about his enemies, wishing them a great deal of harm, which was not in accord with the gentleness of the gospel.” He was inclined “to make allowance for David’s circumstances,” but thought he was not to be taken as a pattern in this respect.
When he had finished his first preamble, and was looking down on the floor with an air of judicial abstraction, Dea. Thresher opened fire from a neighboring bundle of shingles where he was sitting.
“Well, we may conclude that, on the whole, David has your forgiveness, may be, and you are still willing his Psalms should be read in the churches, though always to be taken with Mr. Manly’s caution?”
“I did not say that,” said Jim, starting up, stung a little by the prominence given to his conceit.
“But that is what you mean, is it not? You are just now putting us on our guard, and giving us your opinion as to just what David ought to write, and how far he ought to be followed. Now,” said the deacon, turning to the other shingle bundles and their occupants, “there is a great deal too much of this same thing. People tell us just what the Bible ought to say, and just what the prophets ought to predict, and just what the apostles ought to preach. They set themselves up to be wiser than Inspiration, and more merciful than Christ, and more just than God. Better to take what God does say than presume to dictate to him what he ought to say.”
Jim rallied after a moment and proceeded to explain himself as best he could. As an argumentum ad hominem, he addressed himself to the deacon in this way: “Now, do you mean to say that these speeches that David makes use of were always kind and gentle and forgiving?”
“I will answer that directly,” said the deacon, “if you first name some one in particular.”
“Well,” said Manly, “take Ps. 109, where David says, ‘Set thou a wicked man over him; and let Satan stand at his right hand. When he shall be judged, let him be condemned; and let his prayer become sin. Let his days be few; and let another take his office,’ and much more of the same kind that follows. Surely you won’t say there is much gospel about that.”
“No,” replied the deacon, “there is not much gospel, but there is a great deal of law and justice. The profound mistake all you critics of the imprecatory psalms fall into is to suppose that the divine government is to consist of all softness and no severity. You leave no room for righteous indignation. No matter what outrage an Ahithophel or a Judas may be guilty of (and the Psalms are supposed to have been written in the times of the former, and to refer certainly to the latter), there must be no outburst of righteous indignation. Judas may be met coming back with the thirty pieces of silver jingling in his pocket; but he must be received with vapid wishy-washy sentimentalism. No distinction must be made between him and Peter. With you it would be, ‘Our poor unfortunate Bro. Judas, lately one of the disciples, who fell into an inadvertency owing to the pressure of financial embarrassment, has, we regret to learn, been deposed from his apostolic office. Such narrowness and bigotry ill becomes the generous doctrine of forgiveness which the gospel inculcates. Poor Judas, as we learn, under a momentary insanity, was driven to commit suicide. Under such circumstances it is with the more surprise and grief that we learn that the remaining eleven apostles met and said, Let his habitation be desolate and his bishopric let another man take. It grieves us also to learn that these words were reported as originally spoken by the Holy Spirit concerning Judas.’”
“But I did not say that!” shouted Manly.
“No, you did not say it, but you mean it, if you mean anything at all,” persisted the relentless deacon.
“Here,” continued the deacon, “let us change the psalm a little, take out the ‘imprecation,’ as it is called (but very improperly, as that word is now used), and substitute blessings, as neighbor Manly would have had David do had he been David’s confidential adviser and literary guide. Remember, you have it on divine authority that these words refer to Judas. Go back once more. Consider the crime of Judas, the black, damning crime of selling Christ for money, and consider the inspired writer giving expression to appropriate human feeling in view of it. Hear, then, the reward of treachery, Mr. Justice Manly presiding:—
“‘Set thou a good man over him, and let not Satan stand near him. When he is judged for his conduct, let him be justified; and let his prayer be considered righteousness itself. Let his days be many, and let no man take his office away from him. Let his children be among the favored ones of earth; let them always have abundance of bread. Let everybody show him mercy. Let his posterity be multiplied; let even the sins of his father and the iniquity of his mother be blotted out for his sake.’”
“Now, I say, what a horrible administration would that be, in which the distinction between virtue and vice is confused after that style, and where traitors and villains like Ahithophel and Judas are to be loaded with benedictions. If that is the way you propose to treat Judas, pray how are you going to treat Paul? Better to be a Judas than a Paul, in such a government as you would have.”
Once more, Manly raised his voice almost to a shout: “But I never said benedictions ought to be given to Judas. Judas was a wretch; the devil had taken possession of him, and he ought to have suffered.”
“Oh, ho!” said the deacon; “but that is just what David says, and yet you have been finding fault with him for it. What would you have David say?”
“Well,” said Manly, “he need not have said what he did. He might have refrained from saying anything.”
“And you think that would better the matter, do you? Men may be traitors and sell their Lord, but nobody must say anything severe about them. Not so have we been taught the doctrine of either human or divine justice. Consider, there are only three attitudes which it is possible for men to assume in relation to great criminals and incorrigible transgressors: 1. To denounce them; 2. To commend them; or 3. To say nothing about them one way or the other. You must take your choice; which shall it be?”
Just here, while the deacon was in full swing, our friend Riggs, the hotel man, came into the group. He had been hunting Manly. His big pump had given out, and he wanted a new pump-log bored as soon as possible next day. I think Manly was really pleased at the interruption, and it was doubtless because he would need to be up early, that he concluded he had better go home and get to bed earlier than usual. As an exegete, Manly is not always a success; but as a pump-log-borer no one can surpass him. I have no doubt he will give Mr. Riggs entire satisfaction.—Selected.