From Les Signes des Temps.
RESPONSE TO A PASTOR.
BY ELD. J. N. ANDREWS.
(Concluded.)
We have seen that there is no apostolic example for first-day observance. There is not one case in which we find any evidence that the apostles sought to honor the first day or to abase the seventh. One meeting in the night-time of the first day of the week, without any intimation that it was a customary act, or one done in obedience to some rule or law, is nevertheless supposed to prove that all the apostolic churches regularly observed the first day and did not observe the seventh. If we are to be governed by apostolic example, we ought to be sure that it actually exists before we venture to use it as an excuse for breaking the commandment. Let us give an example of seventh-day observance after the crucifixion. “They rested the Sabbath day according to the commandment.” Luke 23:56. Here we have an example in regard to which there is no uncertainty. If we are to disobey the fourth commandment on the authority of apostolic example, we should know that we have such example. We need something like the following: “And the apostles, as their manner was, rested on the first day of the week, in honor of the resurrection of Christ, and did no longer rest on the seventh day.” This is no more than is necessary if we are to change the commandment.
Our correspondent next appeals to the church fathers. He first names Barnabas, A. D. 50. This shows that he thinks the so-called epistle of Barnabas was written by the companion of Paul; but church historians, with one voice, declare that this epistle is spurious. The reader can judge from one of its declarations, which is that the hyena changes its sex every year, and is sometimes male and sometimes female! Barnabas, chap. 10.
Our friend next refers to Ignatius, A. D. 105. But it is by translating the term Lord’s life as though it read Lord’s day, that this father is made to mention the first day of the week. (Ignatius to the Magnesians, chap. 9.) Our friend next refers to Pliny, A. D. 110. But this writer only speaks of the Christians as assembling upon a stated day, without telling which day of the week it was. The historian, Coleman, says of this testimony, that it does not show whether they met on the first day of the week, or on the last. (“Ancient Christianity,” p. 528.)
Justin Martyr, A. D. 155, is next referred to. He is the first writer who actually mentions the first day after the time of the apostles. He does not call it the Lord’s day, nor the Christian Sabbath, nor by any sacred title whatever. On the contrary, he held that the Sabbath is abolished, but he speaks of the Christians assembling for worship on the first day, though he claimed no divine authority for it. He calls it the day of the sun. The heathen worshiped the sun on that day, and it was more convenient to conform to the customs of the world, in the day that was observed, than to keep the day which God has hallowed.
Denis Dionysius, A. D. 172, is next named. But he uses the term “Lord’s day” once, without making any application of it. This is his entire testimony. This is also the first instance of the use of Lord’s day in church history. It proves nothing for first-day sacredness.
Tertullian, A. D. 198, is his next witness. This is the first of the fathers who makes undoubted reference to the first day by the title of Lord’s day. But to see how far apostasy had progressed in his case, we refer to his book, “De Corona,” sections 3 and 4, in which he says that he made offerings for the dead, and used the sign of the cross, and counted it unlawful to kneel on the Lord’s day. He adds that for all this he had no Scripture, but only tradition.
Clement, of Alexandria, A. D. 204, is next named. But in all the writings of Clement there are but two instances in which he uses the term “Lord’s day,” and there is nothing to show that he certainly meant the first day of the week, or even any literal day, by this term. Origen is the last of the fathers named by our correspondent. Origen, so far as I have been able to discover, had only one reason to give from the Bible for the day which he calls the Lord’s day. He gives it thus: “The manna fell on the Lord’s day, and not on the Sabbath, to show the Jews that even then the Lord’s day was preferred before it.”—Opera, Tome 2, p. 158. But Ex. 16 shows that the reverse of this is the truth.
It is interesting to examine these fathers on this subject, 1. To see, how many are either falsely quoted or wholly spurious; 2. To mark by their writings the progress of apostasy in the church, and the progress of tradition in setting aside the fourth commandment. I have complete editions of all these fathers except Origen and shall be glad to verify fully any statement which may be disputed.
Our correspondent closes with an extract from M. Rochat, which says beautiful things in favor of the change of the Sabbath. M. R. does not pretend that these things are presented in the Bible as reasons for keeping the first day, but he thinks them good enough to establish the authority of the day, even at the expense of changing the fourth commandment. If the Lord had viewed things as M. R. does, he would have commanded us to keep the day, and would have given these thoughts of M. R. as the reason. M. R. does not hesitate to destroy the memorial of the Creator, in order to establish a memorial of the resurrection of Christ; but baptism, the divine memorial of the burial and resurrection of Christ, he wholly overlooks. (Rom. 6:3–5; Col. 2:12; 1 Peter 3:21.)
Thus he says that the Sabbath during which Christ lay in the grave was a very sorrowful day, and that if we now observe the seventh day, it only serves to recall that sorrow and the triumph of Christ’s enemies. But if he will read the commandment, he will see that it is given to raise our minds to God, the Creator of the heavens and the earth, and to cause us to remember his infinite power. But he says that the first day was a day of joy, and that we should keep it as a joyful day in honor of Christ. Now, we should not at all object to this as a voluntary observance, if those who thus act because they please to do so, did not make this an excuse for neglecting the Sabbath and baptism, though both are commanded in the Bible. But the Bible does not contrast the sorrow of the Sabbath with the joy of the first day, as does M. R. It does not directly name the Sabbath in connection with the sorrow of the disciples, but it does show that their sorrow concerning Christ’s death continued till near the close of the day on which he rose. The disciples mourned and wept till evening. (Mark 16:10–14; Luke 24:11–17.)
He says that as Christ lay in the tomb during the Sabbath, in consequence of the crime of the Jews, the Jewish Sabbath was properly buried with him. He would punish the Jews by breaking the fourth commandment! This is quite as reasonable as it is for him to call the seventh day the Jewish Sabbath. The fourth commandment calls it the Sabbath of the Lord. (Ex. 20:8–11.) There were seven ceremonial sabbaths, which came once a year, which may be called Jewish sabbaths, because they were to be kept only in connection with their feasts and new moons. (See Lev. 23.) These did not come on the seventh day, but on any day, and these are abolished. (Col. 2:14–17.)
But since our correspondent speaks against the Sabbath because Christ lay in the tomb that day, and since he makes this a reason for not keeping the fourth commandment, we will now show how false is the conclusion he draws:—
“Why did Christ lie a certain time in the tomb? To show the fact of his death. But why did he die? He died in our place, because we merited death as the transgressors of the law of God. (1 Peter 2:24; 3:18; 1 John 3:4, 5.) How many precepts are there in the law of God? Ten precepts written by God’s finger on two tables of stone; or two great precepts representing the two tables. (Ex. 24:12;p. 66 Deut. 5:22; Matt. 22:36–40.) What was the nature of Christ’s death? It was that of a sacrifice for sin; the offering of an innocent victim in place of the transgressor who merited death. (Isa. 53:10–12; Rev. 5:6–9.) When Christ lay in death, what brought him to that condition? The sword of divine justice, or the curse of the law pronounced against sin. (Zech. 13:7; Gal. 3:13.) How much of this law that caused Christ to die for us related to the Sabbath? One-tenth part. (Ex. 20:3–17; Deut. 5:22.) How could the fact that Christ died for man’s transgression of the fourth commandment, as well as for his transgression of the other nine commandments, be made so manifest in any other way as to have the Son of God lie in death as our sacrifice for sin, during the entire Sabbath? The law of God was honored by the death of Christ in behalf of those that had broken it; for it was an acknowledgment that the law justly condemned the sinner. In like manner the Sabbath was honored by the fact that when Christ died for those that had broken the law of God, he lay in death during all the hours of the Sabbath, as a solemn testimonial that Sabbath-breakers merit death, and can only escape it through the death of Christ.”
We have now examined all the passages mentioned by our correspondent to establish the apostolic example for the observance of the first day. What have we found? Eight instances in which the day is named; and six of these are found in the record of the resurrection. How many of these say that the day was set apart to commemorate the resurrection? Not one! Four of these mention it in connection with the Sabbath; how many of them speak of the change of the Sabbath? None! How many of the eight apply to the first day a sacred title? None! How many of them speak of it as a day of abstinence from labor? None! How many of them speak of a religious meeting in the day-time of the first day? None! How many of them mention a religious meeting in the night-time on this day? One. Did Luke say that such meetings were customary? He said nothing of the kind. Did he, when speaking of services on the Sabbath, say that such were customary? He often said this. (Luke 4:16; Acts 16:13; 17:2; 18:4.) Does he name anything which accounts for this night meeting? He tells us that Paul was departing never to return. If Luke wished to inform us that the apostles were accustomed to meet on the first day, why did he not do it? He thought proper to speak of the custom with respect to the Sabbath, but why did he not speak of such custom for the first day? Was there such custom? If not, where is the apostolic example which authorizes us to break the fourth commandment?
Our friend reports that we keep the fourth commandment, and that we teach others to do this. We regret that he breaks it, and teaches men so. (Matt. 5:19.) He thinks to justify himself for this course in the day of Judgment by the example of the apostles; but would it not be well to know that such example exists, before going further in this course?