AdventAI

PHARISAISM, ANCIENT AND MODERN.

By Lyman Abbott

From Review and Herald, Vol. 57, No. 19., May 10, 1881

A FRIEND who was present tells me the following characteristic anecdote of Mr. Beecher: He was preaching on the tenderness of Christ. “But,” said he, personating an objector, “did not Christ denounce the Pharisees? Did he not exhibit wrath and indignation as well as tenderness?” “That,” he replied, “depends upon the manner and spirit in which those denunciations are read.” Then he took up his New Testament and read some verses from the 23d chapter of Matthew: “Woe unto you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites.” He threw into his voice the impassioned earnestness of a wrathful indignation; then he re-read them in the impassioned feeling of a heart overwhelmed with pity. Then, without a word of comment, he laid down his New Testament, and went on with his sermon.

It is certain that the denunciations recorded in Luke, chapter 11, and Matthew, chapter 23, are capable of a double interpretation. They may be read simply as the language of pity. The Greek may be translated: “Alas! for you.” But the whole spirit of the passage seems to me inconsistent with such a rendering. So also does the character of Christ. It was not the power of pity before which the traders in the temple quailed; or which prevented the officers sent to arrest him from consummating their purpose; or which made the soldiers fall backward to the ground at the entrance to the Garden of Gethsemane when he came forth to meet them.

The language of pity would have been wholly lost upon the Pharisees; and Christ was not accustomed to cast pearls before swine.

It does not, however, follow that it was the language of wrath.

Who were these whose characters aroused Christ’s indignation and brought upon themselves his invectives? Hypocrites (ὑποκριταί), literally, play-actors. They were men who possessed a double character, an outside and an inside one, a seeming and a real one. Such men are common. Society is a masquerade. There are very few who go into it undisguised. The church is even more a masquerade; laymen as well as priests put on their ecclesiastical robes when they go to church. I remember, when a boy, seeing in Christie’s Minstrels a curious dance performed by a man who wore a double face, was negro on one side and a white man on the other. From time to time he whirled around, presenting now the negro, now the white man to the audience. Many a man is thus two men; one the real, the other a stage make-up. The boy at school who is demure when the teacher is present, but is the fomentor of disturbance and the breeder of evil habits and corruption in other boys less guileful than himself; the clerk in the counting-room who is apparently all devotion to business from nine till five, but is in reality all devotion to the billiard-table, or the theater, or the gambling-table from eight till twelve; the merchant who joins in the responses and between whiles reckons up the profits of last week’s business, or plans for new profits in the coming week; the politician who is rich in professions of devotion to the public service while scheming for his own advancement and aggrandizement,—these are all samples of play-actors in daily life, the upokritai whom Christ denounced.

Now, the only salvation for such men is to strip off their disguise and show themselves to themselves, and if need be, to others. So long as they judge themselves by their masquerade costume, there is no hope for self-improvement. The boy will be satisfied with his school rank and entirely unconcerned by his private rank in God’s judgment book; the clerk will think he performs the whole duty of man if he is at his desk at nine and stays there till five; the merchant will count himself a most devout Sabbath-keeper so long as he carries his ledger to church only in his head; the politician will enjoy the approval of his own conscience so long as schemes of self-aggrandizement do not involve open breach of the recognized laws of political morality. This was the case with the Pharisees. They were the orthodox Jews; the members of evangelical churches in good and regular standing.

To such men severity is mercy. Christ showed the only mercy that was possible. He thrust at them; dragged their masquerade costumes off from them; disclosed their true characters to others and to themselves. Such a disclosure he made to a Pharisee when he called out of Heaven to Saul of Tarsus, “It is hard for thee to kick against the pricks.” Underneath Paul’s seemingly unhesitating zeal as a persecutor was all the time a secret remonstrance. It was the disclosure to himself of this secret self that vanquished the persecutor. His outer life had been no true one; and in that instant and for the first time he saw it so. Nor was Saul the only Pharisee thus converted. Nicodemus and Joseph of Arimathea were others; perhaps not the only others. But in general this disclosure of themselves to themselves angered them. It is always a hazardous experiment; but it is an experiment of mercy. The surgeon is as merciful when cutting away the proud flesh, or probing for the ball, or piercing the gathering, as when administering an anodyne.

The general remedy for all Pharisaism is a disclosure of the real character; a stripping off of the stage costume. This is the general lesson; the application to modern Pharisees of Christ’s specific words in the address reported in Luke may be indicated in a few words. Each reader must complete the application for himself.

Pharisaism is scrupulous about external forms and ceremonies. Christ bids men cleanse themselves not by ritual, but by giving in compassion out of a sincere heart to the needy. (Verses 39–41.) Love is the great cleanser.

Pharisaism is precise and particular in conscientious observance of minute regulations; it pays its tithe of the smallest garden herbs, but is indifferent to judgment and justice (verse 42), like the Scotch waiter who was aghast when asked for hot water on Sunday for shaving, but brought with alacrity hot water and whisky for a toddy, and drank the whisky while the guest took the water. Many a man who will not blacken his own boots on Sunday will blacken his neighbor’s character on Monday; he will not pay three cents for a Sunday paper, but he will combine to push up the price of breadstuffs or of coal, though it brings cold and hunger into thousands of homes. The Pharisee pays a good pew rent; not because he loves worship more than his neighbor, but because he loves the center aisle. He is foremost in public works and charities, not because he loves his country or his fellow-men, but because he loves greetings in the markets and notices in the newspapers. (Verse 43.)

Akin to the Pharisee is the lawyer. He puts heavy burdens on men, but gives no help in carrying them. (Verse 46.) He is quick to punish crime and drunkenness; but he owns the rookery whose noisome atmosphere breeds drunkenness and impels to crime; he would stop all Sunday cars and trains; but he will not lift a finger to give the families of the poor, housed in stifled rooms and poisoned by reeking streets, a breath of fresh air or a glimpse of green fields. He gives unmeasured praise to the prophets and radicals of past ages, and persecutes the prophet and radical of his own age. By his teaching and spirit he buries the teachings of the very men whose memory he professes to honor.

He will not go forward into new rooms in truth’s palace; and he tries to shut the door against those who desire to do so. (Verse 52.)

But in all these specifications, and in many more which Christ’s longer indictment, reported in Matthew, chapter 23, contains, there is ever the double character; a man apparently zealous for the rights of religion, but really indifferent to its spirit; apparently eager for the observance of the law, really giving no help to men to observe it; apparently eager for the truth, really unwilling to learn himself or to allow others to do so. This spirit, however it manifests itself and wherever it is seen, is the worst and bitterest foe of Christianity, as it was while he lived the mortal foe of Christ himself.—Lyman Abbott, in Christian Union.