(Concluded.)
An address delivered in Assembly Hall at Harrisburg, Pa., March 17, 1881, by D. E. Maxson, D. D., Seventh-day Baptist.
SECOND PROPOSITION: This Sunday law of 1794 is in derogation of the immutable principles upon which the American Republic was founded, not less than of those upon which the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania was founded, both as a colony and as a State.
The doctrine of religious liberty came to the American shores with the Mayflower, and until the American people can forget their origin, and taboo their Pilgrim Fathers, religious liberty will be secure in the land of the Pilgrims, the home of Roger Williams and William Penn. “I will make them conform, or I will harry them out of the kingdom, or else worse,” was the exclamation of King James, respecting the Puritan nonconformists, the Pilgrim Fathers of our Republic. He could not make them conform, and so he “harried them out of the kingdom” with fire and sword. Says the historian Neale, “Many a conscientious Puritan was driven from the shores of his fatherland to seek an asylum in a foreign country; and thus England lost some of her richest jewels, if citizens of integrity and uprightness be a nation’s wealth.”
“The honest man tho’ e’er sae poor, Is king of men for a’ that.”
This harrying them out went on till, under James, and his weak and infamous successor, Charles II., says the historian (Neale, vol. 4, p. 554), through twenty years of persecution, there was an amount of suffering greater, perhaps, than had been endured in the same space of time since the Reformation. Another chronicler, Jeremy White, collected a list of 60,000 Dissenters, who suffered the bigoted intolerance of the religious establishment under James and Charles, and no less than 5,000 of them died in prison. Others, including noble men and women, were executed; some on the scaffold, others at the stake, suffered martyrdom for their faith and refusal to conform to the decretals of the established Church of England. Lady Alice Lisle, for giving comfort to a nonconformist minister, was charged with treason, and her jury were bullied by the infamous Jeffries, then on the bench, to find her guilty, and the monster condemned her to be burned (the king commuted her sentence to hanging, and the aged woman died forgiving her enemies). Another woman, on charge of hiding a nonconformist, was tried, but no evidence was found against her; but when bigotry determines to compass its ends, evidence is of little consequence. Without evidence, she was condemned and burned at the stake, rejoicing that she was deemed worthy to suffer for Christ’s sake. Of this martyrdom, Sir James Mackintosh says, “Thus was this poor woman supported, under a death of cruel torture, by the lofty consciousness of suffering for righteousness’ sake, and by that steadfast faith in the final triumph of justice which can never visit the last moments of the oppressor.”
But I will not protract this painful history further than to quote the historian of the Puritans, in words following: “The number of the nonconformists did not decrease, though the engines of intolerance were so long and assiduously worked against them”—a fact well enough to be known by all bigots who resort to arguments of persecution, of fines, and penalties, and scaffolds, and fagots, to silence the opposition they cannot cope with on the fair field of debate. The Pilgrims went to Leyden, in Holland, and remained there eleven years, but it was not a genial home for their free spirits. Where should they go next? They had heard of a far-away land across the sea, whose soil was rich, whose air was free, a land on which despotism had shed no blight, a land where
“Freedom, winged, might raptured roam, And find at length a genial home.”
They resolved to go to America. It was a great thought, the seed-thought of a mighty nation. In the secret thoughts of that immortal one hundred and one, there were germinal impulses which were to strike most powerfully on the destinies of the world; and when the history of great souls shall be written on the scrolls of eternity, the words and deeds of these and such as these will shine brighter in the annals of greatness than those titled and gowned dignitaries of the great church which put its ban on them and inspired its facile tools to “harry them out” from their homes in
“England’s sunny dales, and Scotia’s heather hills.”
The story of these, our Pilgrim Fathers, belongs to the heroic age of America, and may well inspire the enthusiasm of her historians; for no other nation can boast such an origin, in such an idea, nor adorn its earliest annals with a tale as true as it is beautiful, as authentic as it is sublime; and when America shall produce her Virgil, he will find in the voyage of the Pilgrim Fathers a theme for his muse far surpassing his of olden time, who sang the adventures of an Æneas, “Who, a fugitive by fate, from the Trojan shores, first came to Italy and the Lavinian coasts.”
Religious liberty is the watchword and the basilar idea of the whole American movement. The Pilgrim Fathers are our types of men, and the Mayflower is our type of destiny. The sea over which we are sailing our noble Ship of State has never been cut by the keel of another vessel, and the basilar doctrine of our Republic has never illumined the constitution of any other nation. The Magna Charta of King John guaranteed liberty to Englishmen because Englishmen, and to none others. The American Constitution guarantees liberty to man as man. The American Declaration of Rights “holds these truths to be self-evident that all men are created equal, and endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights; that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness; and that to secure these rights governments are instituted among men.”
These, gentlemen, are human-nature rights, such as our government was founded to take care of, and rights with which no law can interfere. That the founders of the government meant just this, let them testify. Midway between the Declaration and the adoption of the Constitution, when the great thought of human liberty was ripening toward its organic life in the American Republic, the American Congress, in the City of Brotherly Love, issued the following authoritative declaration of the basilar doctrine of the nation coming to birth. It was drawn up by James Madison, in words following: “Let it be remembered, that it has ever been the pride and boast of America, that the rights for which she contended were the rights of human nature. By the blessing of the Author of these rights on the means exerted for their defense, they have prevailed against all opposition, and form the basis of thirteen independent States.” It is ever the pride and boast of America, that the rights for which she contended were the rights of human nature, and that by the blessing of the Author of these rights, they have prevailed and gone into the corner-stone of our magnificent edifice. Yes, sir! and that is just what makes it magnificent; and that alone it is that will keep it magnificent so long as her citizens remain faithful to their birthright, doing the work of true sons of noble sires; keeping blazoned in living light the eternal axiom that “the laws of nature are immutable, and are the laws of laws;” and that which does not conform thereto is not law,—cannot be American law. Man’s religious nature is his deepest, broadestp. 292 highest, and grandest nature, and around his religious nature does all law, all American law, throw its stoutest ramparts. And around this religious nature has its divine Author thrown the rampart of the Sabbath law. A Sabbathless people will inevitably become a godless, an atheistic people.
The first amendment to the Constitution adopted in 1791, is in words following: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion.” It was from the bigotry and despotism of a State-established religion that the founders of this nation had to flee; their human-nature rights to order and exercise their own religion according to the dictates of their own conscience, had been invaded. Naturally enough, they put this inhibition against “established” religion into the fundamental law of the land they had come to inhabit. That they might have the religious liberty denied them, was the all-prevailing reason of their coming to the new world and establishing a new government. But it was not enough to inhibit the establishment of religion by Congressional enactment. The article goes on to say, “Congress shall make no law prohibiting the free exercise of religion.” Now, it is against this last clause of the article that the Act of 1794, under which we are suffering, is operating, in that it does prohibit the free exercise of religion as practiced by American citizens, numerous in more than three-fourths of the States of the American Union. It is not always, nor most generally, that we make opposition to what we do not like, by direct assault. But opposition by indirection, by inference, by innuendo, is often and generally more harassing and hurtful. The Act of which we complain does not face us squarely, and in direct terms forbid us to keep holy the seventh day of the week, the Sabbath of Jehovah. If it did, it would have more chivalry, not to say more dignity, than it has now. Instead of this, it places before us one of the strongest motives for not doing it known to men; viz., the motive of pecuniary interest. For while it does not forbid us in direct terms to Sabbatize on the seventh day, it does forbid us to work on the first day of the week, thus taking away one-sixth part of our industrial earnings as a forfeit, or drawback, for our faithfulness to religious conviction and duty. It is saying to us, Yes, keep on in the observance of the Sabbath, of the seventh day, but know ye, that, doing so, there remain to you only five more days of that week in which you may work and earn your subsistence of life and profit of business; know ye that for that year your earnings will be less by the value of fifty-two days’ work. Now, allow the moderate average earnings per day to be one dollar, there is $52 per year for us to pay as the price for our fealty to our religious conviction. In a lifetime of common length it would amount to a somewhat onerous tax. Disguise it as you will, it is a constant push against that “free exercise of religion” which is guaranteed in the article of the Constitution under consideration. That is very far from being a “free exercise of religion,” which is put to such a disadvantage by statutory enactment, and that enactment is just as far from being constitutional law which puts such religious exercise to such disadvantage. But not only by indirection does this act infringe religious liberty. It does it by direction, palpable and imperious. It is as much a duty, under the fourth commandment, to work the other six days of the week as it is to rest on the seventh. Man’s law of life is the law of labor, and God has ordained that “he who will not work shall not eat;” that “the hand of the diligent shall bear rule, while the sluggard shall come to poverty.” “Diligent in business, fervent in spirit, serving the Lord,” is God’s programme for every human life. “Whether therefore ye eat or drink, or whatsoever ye do, do all to the glory of God.” “Whatsoever your hands find to do, do it with your might.” These are some of the forms through which the life-duties, the religious duties of men’s lives, are expressed. This law of labor is as imperative, both in the nature of things, and the divine voicings of that nature, as is the law of rest. Men do as conscientiously observe the law of labor as they do the law of rest, and thus observing it are as religiously engaged as when resting on the Sabbath. Indeed, what is the primary end of resting on the seventh day according to the commandment, but to gather strength to go through the toil of the succeeding six days? When you forbid me to work on the first day of the week, you strike as cruel a blow at my religious liberty as when you forbid me to rest on the seventh day; for sacred obligations to my family, and to the cause of humanity and of God, demand the fruit of the toil of that day, and I may not deny it them except by recreancy to high religious and moral obligations. Nor can you deny it them by restraining me without trenchment on rights God has made inherent in my nature, and which the Constitution of my country has guarded with scrupulous care.
I have to add that this Act of 1794 is opposed to the spirit and genius upon which the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania was founded, so that while it is neither good common law, nor good American law, it is not even good Pennsylvania law. One of the proud names of modern history is that of Wm. Penn, the founder of the proud old Commonwealth that perpetuates his name in hers, and whose characteristic virtue is memorialized in the beautiful metropolis of that Commonwealth, the City of Brotherly Love, the second city in size and importance in the American Republic. The principles of religious liberty upon which Penn founded his American colony were such as had been imbibed and intensified amid the scenes of intolerance and persecution of his native home in England. Of the bitterness of that intolerance he had had abundant experience. He had been imprisoned in Newgate six months for refusing to violate his conscience against taking an oath; had been fined for wearing his hat in a court-room; had been repeatedly imprisoned for attending Quaker meetings, and had been confined in London Tower nine months for writing a book against the dogma of the Trinity, as it was held by the so-called orthodox sects. From out such a personal experience, we do not wonder to read of him, when he became the founder of a State, such words as the following, by his historian: “In framing the colonial government, he provided for the largest religious liberty, allowing every one to worship God according to the dictates of his own conscience.” We do not wonder when another chronicler says of him, that “he is always mentioned with honor as a law-giver who, in an age of persecution, made religious liberty the corner-stone of a State.” While we do not wonder at this, the outcome of the inexorable logic of events, the utterance of God’s voice in history, we do wonder, and shall never cease to wonder, that in that same State, corner-stoned in religious liberty, such an Act as that of 1794 came so early into existence, and has remained in existence so late into the nineteenth century,—a century distinguished above all preceding ones for its liberalizing tendencies, for its liberty-giving impulses, for its costly enfranchisements.
Before concluding this argument, let me add that if this Act were valid, constitutional law, those upon whom it most heavily bears at present are of all people least deserving its penalties. Gentlemen, the Seventh-day Baptists are no new-comers, seeking to set up utopian enterprises and to propagate dangerous and heretical dogmas in this country. Our organic existence in the United States antedates that of the Federal Government by more than a hundred years. We celebrated the bi-centennial of our denominational existence in this country away on the prairies of the West, five years before the American Government celebrated its centennial existence in the metropolis of Pennsylvania. The founder of our denomination in this country, Stephen Mumford, came from England to Newport, R. I., eighteen years before Wm. Penn, the founder of Pennsylvania, came to Philadelphia from the same country. And there were in Pennsylvania alone five Seventh-day Baptist churches eighty-seven years before the Constitution of the State was adopted. They were organized under the lead of a Seventh-day Baptist minister from England, Abel Noble by name, and nobler by nature. He drew his adherents mainly from a branch of seceding Quakers, known as Keithian Baptists. From that day to this, our denomination has never been without a representation in Pennsylvania, respectable both for numbers and intelligence, valuable and loyal citizens of the Commonwealth. We are not ashamed of our history, nor of the part we have taken, and are still taking, in maintaining the government of our nation and educating the people in the principles of civil and religious liberty. Our mother church in Newport gave to the State two of her best governors, and a Secretary of State who held the office for several successive administrations. That same church gave to the Continental Congress, holding session in Philadelphia, one of its most active and influential members, who held position on an important committee of the Congress during the most critical period of our formative era. The Newport church also furnished substantial aid in founding that noble institution of learning at Providence, my own dear Alma Mater, Brown University. One of the Newport members was for years a most active and influential member of her Board of Trustees. From that day to this, members of our churches have occupied positions of influence and honor in the country and State governments where they have been located.
In educational enterprise, we have not been behind our brethren of other denominations, nor have we confined the advantages of our academies and colleges to students of our own denomination. As a rule, there are in our colleges three or four times as many students from other denominations as from our own. Families of all religious proclivities send their young men and women to us for literary training, and out on the field of action, all over the land, are graduates of our schools. In the pulpit, in the professor’s chair, in editorial chairs, at the head of banking and other business houses, in legislative halls, on judicial benches,—everywhere,—we find them. Five of our Alfred graduates have been members of the Pennsylvania Legislature within the last decade, three of these members of the present House. The first Superintendent of Public Instruction in Kansas was a former teacher and graduate of Alfred University. He was slain at the post of duty by the Rantell raiders upon Lawrence. One of the ablest Attorney Generals of Kansas was an Alfred graduate, and son of a Seventh-day Baptist minister. The present Chancellor and popular President of the State University at Lawrence was a graduate and long-time professor of Alfred University. One of the present Supreme Judges of Kansas is a graduate of Alfred. The editor of the leading Republican journal of that noble State is a graduate and former teacher of Alfred. One of the first men to die at his post resisting the Border Ruffian invasion of that State was an Alfred student, and among the foremost, both in the Legislature and in the field of the noble men who saved that magnificent State to freedom, were Alfred students. An Alfred graduate has been the postmaster at Lawrence for the last eight years. Among the Superintendents of Public Instruction of the State of Missouri has been an Alfred graduate, and son of a Seventh-day Baptist minister. At the present time, a Seventh-day Baptist minister, and President of one of our colleges, is Superintendent of Public Instruction of Wisconsin; he is upon his second term, and by his indefatigable energy, is working a thorough and radical reform in the whole system of public instruction of the great and growing Badger State. A graduate of Alfred is now one of the Supreme Judges of Wisconsin, and a graduate of Milton was not long ago Lieutenant Governor of that State.
From the very beginning of the controversy that came to its bloody arbitrament on six hundred battle-fields, to its close in a regenerated nation and a liberated race, through every phase of the grand unfolding of this our tragic history, our people have stood true as the needle to the pole. In the national cemetery at Baton Rouge, there stands a beautiful monument erected in memory of a brave man who fell in front of his regiment. His regiment put the monument there as a token of love for him. He was my noble brother. Somewhere under the field of Seven Pines lie together the remains of three noble soldiers, who fell struggling against vast odds. They were Seventh-day Baptists, students of mine. With myp. 293 own hands I buried them there, finding them out from the debris of two days’ carnage. Then, in that fearful thunder of battle, as our regiment was hard pressed by a whole Rebel brigade, I saw a young man, a captain, mount full length top of the rifle pit behind which the regiment was entrenched, and, in face of a murderous fire, load and deliberately fire sixty rounds in the face of the oncoming enemy. He was a Seventh-day Baptist, a graduate of Alfred. Afterward, the regiment was captured and sent to the hell of Andersonville, where about one-half of them perished. But this same young man planned and executed an escape for himself and several companions by burrowing under the stockade, so skillfully hiding their tracks as to emerge outside the stockade in the night, escape the vigilance of the sentinels, and, by hiding days and traveling nights, they at length reached the Union lines. That heroic soldier is now head of a large mercantile firm in Michigan. One of the present deacons, and another member of my own church, suffered and at length escaped the immediate horrors of that dreadful prison, but to the day of their death will not be rid of its effects upon their physical constitutions. All this is not to boast, but only to say, We have shunned no duty, no danger, that we might fill our place as loyal citizens of our noble Republic.
And now, gentlemen, it remains for you to determine whether we shall share as fully and freely in the immunities guaranteed by our institutions as we have shared in the toil and danger of founding, ennobling, and defending them. Pennsylvania, whose history is so grand, whose corner-stone was laid in religious liberty, by some strange contradiction, is the one only State of the Union which puts us under legal disabilities for our religious beliefs and practices. We have Seventh-day Baptist churches in seventeen States, while in all the States are numbers exceeding our own who observe the seventh day. Nowhere but in the Keystone State is the hand of repression laid upon us. Why should it be there? Are we, like the Israelites in Egypt, growing so large a people that the Pennsylvania Pharaoh is afraid of us? Let me assure him his fears are groundless, and that when we come to hold the majority of votes in the State, and have a majority of members in this its august council, we shall glory in nothing so much as in bringing it back upon its corner-stone of religious liberty to all the inhabitants thereof. We have no spirit of recrimination to gratify, no bigoted hatred to indulge. If you keep on oppressing us, we shall keep on petitioning and protesting; and if by your oppression you shall give us more compactness of character, more steadiness of eye and nerve, more boldness of speech, more strength of organization, it will not be so much because we shall will it to be so, as because the inexorable logic of events, and the resistless laws of action and reaction, shall make it so. Patiently, kindly, and, if need be, heroically, shall we endure what we cannot cure. In the grand unfoldings of God’s providence, we are coming more and more to believe that what is true will live forever; that “truth, crushed to earth, will rise again,” because “the eternal years of God are hers.” Outside show of strength and of beauty are often in vast disparity to internal and eternal verities. The humble and unpretending, but industrious Daniel C. Waldo can better afford to pay the fine imposed for obedience to conscience and God by the proud old Commonwealth of Pennsylvania than she can afford to impose it. The small and unpretending denomination of Seventh-day Baptists can better afford to be persecuted and proscribed by legal discrimination and disabilities than the large and popular denominations can afford to urge on such interference; for—
“Of what is small, but living, God makes himself the nurse, While, Onward, cry the voices Of the great universe.” —Sabbath Recorder.