The Temporal Side of the Question.
Much has been published on the subject of Christian giving, chiefly by ministers, who naturally and rightly give prominence, first to the duty itself, and secondly to the spiritual blessings that accompany and follow its performance. The infinitely greater importance of this side of the question is conceded; but the temporal side should not be ignored, and it is next to useless to exhort to the observance of this duty, which especially requires business judgment and system, without giving practical directions for its performance.
The law of giving rests upon precisely the same foundation as the law of the Sabbath,—both are sometimes called Mosaic laws, yet both were observed hundreds of years before Moses was born. The seventh of time and the tenth of income belong to the Lord. We may appropriate both to our own use, but we thereby lose both in temporal and spiritual blessings. All Christians will concede this to be true as regards the Sabbath, but all may not so willingly concede it when applied to the law of tithes, yet both statements are equally susceptible of proof.
Every intelligent man, whether Christian or not, will admit that more and better work can be done in one, or five, or ten years, resting every seventh day, than by working every day. Can any one give an intelligent physical reason for this? “Needs the rest,” may be said. Certainly, but why not the fifth day, or the tenth, as the French once decreed? Why is not the nightly sleep enough? The only answer is, that it is one of God’s well-known and accepted, but unexplained laws. In like manner it may be impossible to explain why, if a man shall pay back to God one-tenth of his income as it accrues, he will be more prosperous in temporal things than if he kept or tried to keep the whole, but it is true nevertheless. The object of the following pages is to bring out this truth, give some of the reasons and results, both from God’s word and human experience, and to give such plain, practical directions to those who desire to adopt the system as will enable them to put it in practice. The colloquial form is adopted, the more clearly to express the thought of the writer, and to meet the possible doubts and questions that may arise in the minds of readers.
Questions and Answers.
1. Was not tithing a Mosaic institution, and consequently has it not passed away?
No; Abraham paid tithes. Gen. 14:20. And in Gen. 28:22, Jacob promised to God one-tenth of his income, and doubtless kept his promise.
2. Were not tithes required for the support of the priests, and when the priesthood passed away was not the law abrogated?
No; the language in the fourth commandment, “The seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God,” is no more emphatic than that in Lev. 27:30, “All the tithe of the land is the Lord’s,” not shall be, but is. In Num. 18:21, he says, “I have given the children of Levi all the tenth in Israel for an inheritance,” and in verse 26 he requires that even the priests shall pay tithes. It is true the priesthood has passed away; but the title to the tenth of increase reverted to God, not to us certainly, and there being now no intervening priesthood, we owe it and should pay it directly to him.
3. Was not the obligation to pay tithes a civil as well as a religious one? Was it not the Jewish method of paying taxes?
It was purely a religious service. How would this language from Mal. 3:8 sound, reference being had to the non-payment of taxes? “Will a man rob God? Yet ye have robbed me. But ye say, Wherein have we robbed thee? In tithes and offerings.”
4. Was the law of tithes perpetual in Hebrew history? Was it always binding?
Abraham paid tithes, so did Jacob; so, it is fair to presume, did all the patriarchs. More than a thousand years after the death of Moses, God through Malachi denounced the Jews for not paying their tithes. They were uniformly prosperous when they paid them, and adversity was certain when they did not.
5. Were not the blessings promised for payment of tithes spiritual rather than temporal?
Both temporal and spiritual. God united them; why should we separate them? Read the third chapter of Malachi, perhaps the strongest in the Bible on that subject. The promises there have almost sole reference to temporal blessings.
6. Did our Saviour sanction the payment of these?
Yes. Read Matt. 23:23 and Luke 11:42.
7. But did he command that tithes be paid?
Not directly that we know of, but he recognized the law, commended it, and did not abrogate it. He did not command the keeping of the Sabbath, neither did he abrogate the law, and we all regard it as binding. There was no need to command the Jews either to keep the Sabbath or to observe the law of tithes. They did both so scrupulously, and in such detail, that while our Saviour commended the observance of both laws, he reproved them for sacrificing the spirit for the form.
8. Does not this presentation of the subject make the love of gain the basis of the argument?
Of gain, yes; of purely personal gain, no. That we may have more to rightly enjoy and do good with, yes; more to selfishly use and enjoy, no. There is so much seeming plausibility, and yet so much real misconception in this objection that it deserves a more extended answer. Did God make a mistake in appealing to what we might call our “selfishnessp. 419 ” is there in every prayer you offer; how much in your hope of Heaven?
9. It is conceded that there are higher motives. Why not appeal to them?
Are there any that are more practical; any that enter more into our every-day Christian life? Admitting that these are among the lower rounds in the ladder of Christian motives, should we therefore ignore or neglect to use them? Is it better to look up than mount up?
10. I cannot afford to give one-tenth of my income.
How do you know? Did you ever try it? Did you ever know any one who had practiced it that was not thereby prospered? No matter how rich; no matter how poor; no matter how small the income; no matter how large the family. Do you think your Heavenly Father will make an exception in your case, and not keep his promise with you? Can you afford not to do it? To which of two men would you rather lend money without security; one who observed this rule, or one who did not, both being equally honest, equally worthy, and possessed of equal advantages and abilities?
11. Why not practice the New-Testament rule,—“Give as God has prospered you?”
Certainly, that is an Old-Testament rule also. But how much? what proportion?—one-twentieth; one-fifth; one-tenth, or just as you happen to feel at the time? One-tenth of the prosperity was God’s rule then; when was it changed, and what is the New-Testament proportion?
12. Why should I think so much of the temporal side of this question?
Because it is the practical side. All of us do something for a living. We are Christian farmers, mechanics, merchants, teachers, laborers, clerks, physicians, lawyers, etc. We are not called to be preachers and missionaries; yet by helping to support the ministry and missions, we can and do have a personal interest in the salvation of every soul brought to Christ through their efforts. We can help care for “God’s poor,” and thus “lend to the Lord.” Upon the Christian laity depends, under God, the support and prosperity of all charitable, benevolent, and religious institutions, schools, and colleges. If we earn the “well done,” it must be in our own sphere of life. System, method, rule, pay in everything else; why not in Christian life and Christian giving? This conceded, what rule is better than the only one God ever gave, and the observance of which for thousands of years has never failed to bring both spiritual and temporal blessings? Let us take our Heavenly Father at his word, and let him take the responsibility of permitting us to give much or little, leaving us nothing to do but bestow his share where it will the most honor him.
(Concluded in next number.)