AdventAI

The Journey of Paul from Troas to Assos.

By W. H. Littlejohn

From Review and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 27., July 4, 1882

BY ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN.

In the absence of any positive testimony that Christ or the apostles changed the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day of the week, it would seem that any effort to show that such a change actually took place would be utterly fruitless; since it is hard to believe that God would make a change of as great practical importance as that of the change of the Sabbath without giving us the most positive assurance, not only that the first day of the week had become a Sabbath, but also that the sanctity had been removed from the seventh day of the week, which had previously been enforced by positive command. Notwithstanding the difficulties of the situation, however, first-day observers, with a zeal worthy of a better cause, have ransacked the New-Testament record to establish the custom of first-day observance on the part of the apostles. This they attempt to do by showing that they were in the habit of meeting on that day for the purposes of worship. To an unprejudiced mind, it seems to us, their laborious efforts must result in utter failure.

To begin with, it is not the plan or purpose of God in this dispensation to leave important doctrines to be enforced by the doubtful practice of the apostles. Christ declared that the word which he had spoken should judge men in the last day. John 12:48–50. Paul again echoes this sentiment in the declaration that “all Scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness; that the man of God may be perfect, thoroughly furnished unto all good works.” 2 Tim. 3:16, 17.

From the foregoing we learn that we are to be judged by that which is written, and not by that which is unwritten; also, that the written Scriptures thoroughly furnish us unto every good work. Ignoring, however, for the time being, the absurdity of the notion that it is possible to predicate the change of the Sabbath upon those Scriptures which barely mention the fact that meetings did sometimes occur on the first day of the week during the apostolic age, let us regard, as favorably as possible, the efforts of our friends to make out their case. If they are candid, they will agree with us that if we are to rely upon the custom of the apostles, that custom must be made out in the most unequivocal manner. Granting this point, and looking with as much favor as possible upon the efforts of our friends, let us see what they have really proved. Should we give them all the latitude which they can possibly ask, we shall find that, between the crucifixion of Christ and the termination of the period covered by the book of Acts, there are just three specific first days on which it is even claimed that religious meetings took place. These were respectively, the day of Christ’s resurrection (John 20:19), the Sunday following (John 20:26), and the first day of the week mentioned in Acts 20:7.

Bearing in mind, now, that the first and last of these days are separated by twenty-eight years, we are confronted by the startling fact that the apostolic custom of Sunday observance depends, so far as specific occasions are concerned, upon the fact that, according to the record, they met together for worship on three first days out of 1,456. The reader will see that this is correct by multiplying 28, the number of years which intervened between the resurrection of Christ and the meeting at Troas, by 52, the number of Sundays in the year. He will also perceive that the predication of an apostolic custom upon such a record as this must necessarily be an utter failure. No intelligent person with the facts before him, could candidly argue for a moment that such a record could ever have been designed as the basis of an argument for a custom on the part of the apostles of sanctifying the first day of the week. That custom, by the history in question, approximates as nearly to demonstration as the number 3 approximates to a sum equal to 1,456.

Here we might leave the matter. Or, if they saw fit, we might show that on neither of the three days mentioned a religious meeting took place except on the one spoken of in Acts 20:7. Should we do so, then our friends would have left them but one first-day service out of 1,456 days on which services must have taken place if their theory is correct.

Should it be replied to the above that in 2 Cor. 16:1, 2, a custom is implied of first-day services, we answer, Such is not the case. Mr. J. W. Morton, by a careful comparison of eight versions in different languages, as well as by reference to the signification of the original terms in the Greek, has shown that the laying by there spoken of was to take place at home, and not at the synagogue or the place of worship, thus depriving that testimony of all its force in the controversy, since it is only available to our friends when they can show that the laying by in question was done at the place of meeting through the aid of contribution boxes, etc.

Finally, now that we have seen that the argument of first-day defenders from the standpoint of apostolic custom breaks down at the first trial, even when we grant them all they claim in regard to the only three days which they insist were devoted by the disciples to religious worship, we wish to call their attention to a very significant fact brought to view in the account given in the twentieth chapter of Acts. We admit frankly, that in this chapter we have the record of an assembly on the first day of the week. We also admit that Paul preached on that occasion and administered the Lord’s supper. Do not let it be inferred, however, from these admissions, that we concede that there is any evidence in these facts that Paul or the church at Troas regarded the day as holy. Religious meetings frequently transpire on secular days. For example, Thursday night is quite generally devoted to the purpose of prayer; nevertheless no one will insist for a moment that the day itself possesses any degree of sanctity.

Again, Thursday was the day of the ascension. Acts 1:9–11. On that occasion five hundred brethren were assembled, and the Lord Jesus Christ addressed them. But does any one argue that for this reason the early church regarded the Thursday as holy time? The reply is, that such is not the opinion of any intelligent man. By parity of reasoning, we come to the same conclusion in regard to the meeting recorded in Acts 20:7.

The apostle had been there for several days. No doubt he had addressed them on the previous day, which was the Sabbath, and on every other day during his continuance in the city. The last meeting which he held with them was on Sunday evening. That was made the occasion of the breaking of bread, because it was to be the last meeting before his departure. The record is given in full, also, because of the desire to record the miracle performed by Paul in the restoration of life to Eutychus, who fell from the window and was killed that night. These facts, we say, furnish sufficient reason for the holding of a meeting on the evening of the first day of the week and for the space given to the account of the same in the book of Acts. To make certainty doubly sure, however; i. e., to prove beyond all dispute that the disciples did not assemble at Troas on the evening in question because they had any idea that the first day of the week was more sacred than any other day, we submit the following facts:—

1. The Sabbath of the Lord, as well as the other days of the Hebrews, commenced at sunset. Lev. 2:32 and Mark 1:32. (See also American Tract Society Bible Dictionary, article “Day.”)

2. The meeting in question occurred on what answers to our Saturday evening, since it took place on that portion of the day when lamps were needed; i. e., the dark portion, in other words, on Saturday night; as, according to the custom of the Jews, that first day terminated with the setting of the sun on Sunday evening, thus proving that the only dark portion of the day when lamps would be employed fell between the setting of the sun Saturday night, and the rising of the sun Sunday morning.

3. Paul commenced to preach, therefore, onp. 418 Saturday evening, his meeting continuing until Sunday morning.

4. On Sunday morning, Luke and the other disciples went on board of the vessel, and started for Jerusalem, sailing their craft that day around Cape Lectum to Assos (a distance of forty miles), where they took Paul on board.

5. On that same Sunday morning, Paul traveled on foot from Troas to Assos, across the base of Cape Lectum, a distance of nineteen and a half miles. (Acts 20:13, 14.)

In view of the foregoing, what becomes of the favorite theory of the first-day sanctity, as based upon the record in Acts 20? The answer is obvious. That chapter not only demonstrates the futility of the theory that the apostles were in the habit of assembling for worship on the first day of the week; but it also forever demolishes the doctrine that that day was regarded by them as sacred in its character. This will appear the more unquestioned when we recollect that the apostle Paul, as the great apostle of the Gentiles, and one whose example we are instructed to follow (1 Cor. 4:14, 15), would never have allowed himself to stand upon the record as a violator of the Sabbath. Such he appears to be, however, and such he unquestionably was, if the first day of the week was holy time in A. D. 58; i. e., the year in which the meeting was held at Troas. No amount of logic, however ingeniously framed, can set aside the record of this chapter. No array of distinguished names can blunt the point of its testimony. Paul traveled on foot, nineteen miles and a half, on Sunday, while his fellow-disciples sailed a vessel twice that distance on the same day. To argue that the Lord would first change the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day of the week without giving us a positive declaration to that effect, leaving us to infer the change from the practice of the apostles, to be gleaned from the pages of the New Testament, and then cause the record of the travels of Paul and the disciples on that day to be made as conspicuous as they are in the twentieth chapter of Acts, is too preposterous to be admitted for a moment. Beneath the weight of such testimony, the theories of our opponents are crushed so effectually that they need no further attention.

Should there be a doubt in the mind of any individual as to whether the journey of Paul and the disciples actually took place on the first day of the week, we invite them to read the following from the pen of Dean Howson. This distinguished scholar is a member of the English Committee on the Revision of the King James Version of the Bible; and as he is a firm believer in the sanctity of the first day of the week, his capacity as well as his lack of impartiality for the views of Sabbatarians will be conceded by all. Here are his words:—

“With minds solemnized and filled with thankfulness by this wonderful token of God’s power and love [i. e., the restoration of Eutychus] they celebrated the Eucharistic feast. The act of holy communion was combined, as was usual in the apostolic age, with a common meal; and St. Paul now took some refreshments after the protracted labor of the evening, and then continued his conversation till the dawning of the day.

“It was now time for the congregation to separate. The ship was about to sail, and the companions of Paul’s journey took their departure to go on board. It was arranged, however, that the apostle himself should join the vessel at Assos, which was only about twenty miles distant by the direct road, while the voyage around Cape Lectum was nearly twice as far. He thus secured a few more precious hours with his converts at Troas; and eagerly would they profit by his discourse, under the feeling that he was so soon to leave them; and we might suppose that the impression made under such circumstances, and with the recollection of what they had witnessed in the night, would never be effaced from the minds of any of them, did we not know, on the highest authority, that if men believe not the prophets of God, neither will they believe ‘though one rose from the dead.’ But the time came when St. Paul, too, must depart. The vessel might arrive at Assos before him; and whatever influence he might have with the seamen, he could not count on any long delay. He hastened, therefore, through the southern gate, past the hot springs, . . . and across the wild water-courses on the western side of Ida. . . . We have seldom had occasion to think of the apostle in the hours of his solitude. But such hours must have been sought and cherished by one whose whole strength was drawn from communion with God, and especially at a time when, as on this present journey, he was deeply conscious of his weakness and filled with foreboding fears. . . . And strength and peace were surely sought and attained by the apostle from the Redeemer, as he pursued his lonely road that Sunday afternoon in spring, among the oak woods and the streams of Ida.

“No delay seems to have occurred at Assos. He entered by the Sacred Way among the famous tombs, and through the ancient gateway, and proceeded immediately to the shore. We may suppose that the vessel was already hove to, and waiting when he arrived; or that he saw her approaching from the west, through the channel between Lesbos and the main. He went on board without delay, and the Greek sailors and the apostolic missionaries continued their voyage.”—Conybeare & Howson’s Life and Epistles of St. Paul, pp. 594–566.