A FRIEND in Berkshire, Vt., to whom Bro. C. P. Whitford has sent reading matter, having charged the Signs and the writings of sister White with being Pharisaical, Bro. W. replies as follows:—
DEAR BRO. E——: Believing, as I do, in your sincerity, I attempt with pleasure to answer the points mentioned in your letter. It seems to me you have labored under serious misapprehensions while acquainting yourself with our views. You speak of the writings in the Signs as being more Pharisaical than Christian. Let us calmly think what were the characteristics of the Pharisees which the Lord disapproved. 1. Pride and hypocrisy; 2. Scrupulous observance of parts of the law, while neglecting other parts; 3. Obedience to traditions of men, even though such traditions caused them to disobey God.
In all candor let me ask, Where do you find in our writings exhibitions of these odious characteristics? I do not ask this question, I trust, in a boastful spirit, but because, as I have said, I feel sure you have misunderstood the tenor of the writings of which you have spoken. Think seriously of this in the light of that charity that speaketh no evil. We assail that which we regard as the traditions of men,—traditions that cause people to break one of the commandments of God. The whole force of our writings is to induce men to obey, not a part only, but all of the commandments of God, and to have faith in Jesus Christ. With you, we believe that we must love God, and that “this is the love of God, that we keep his commandments.” 1 John 5: 3, 4. The Bible ever teaches that this is the highest way of manifesting our love to God. Nor do we ever teach, as did the Pharisees, that mere outward observance is sufficient. Indeed, your grave charges surprise me. Let us together seek God, and ask that his Spirit may write his holy law upon our hearts, thus inducing us to walk in the light as he is in the light. We shall then have fellowship one with another, and the blood of Jesus Christ shall cleanse us from all sin. Do you remember what God says sin is? “Whosoever committeth sin transgresseth also the law; for sin is the transgression of the law.” 1 John 3: 4.
You refer to chapters 19 and 22 of Matthew’s Gospel, as giving the commandments of Christ; but you will certainly remember that Christ here only repeats what God had before commanded. “Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind,” is signified by the ten commandments; and this truth you have learned from your infancy. It is taught by the Methodist church as well as by the Bible. Perhaps at present I need say no more by way of explanation.
Dear brother, remember that the truth of God has ever been despised by the masses, even of those who profess to love him; and take heed lest in this matter you may be found fighting against God. His law will meet us in the day of judgment. We must be judged, not merely by the summary, but by the particulars of that law. May God bless you in your earnest efforts to know the truth, and may you and I be sanctified through obedience to the truth (1 Peter 1:22), that we may at last meet in the kingdom of God.