Congregationalism.
The Detroit Evening News of May 17, 1882, asks the question, in view of the facts stated below, “What is Congregationalism, anyhow?” Are we to be forced to the conclusion that Congregationalism means a standard of religious faith so low, and a system of interpretation so lax, that it takes in almost every class, and so embraces the largest “congregation”? The News says:—
“The Rev. Mr. Merriman, formerly president of Ripon College, ‘one of the ablest and most scholarly ministers in the Congregational ranks,’ was recently examined by a tribunal of his church, preliminary to his installation as pastor of the Congregational church at Somerville, Mass. It turned out that as regarding hell he was a Universalist, and in respect to purgatory he was a good Roman Catholic. That is to say, he refused to believe in eternal punishment, and substituted a condition of probation after death, in which the soul would be purged from its impurities preparatory to entering Heaven, which probation he thought might be mitigated by the prayers of Christians still in the flesh. The doctrine of prayers for the dead was the particular popish bête noir of the early Puritan—indeed, of the Puritan of twenty years ago—but its acceptance by Mr. Merriman did not prevent his installation as the pastor of Somerville. What is Congregationalism, anyhow? It authorizes Beecher to set aside half the Bible, and lets Mr. Merriman abolish hell and set up purgatory. Isn’t it wide enough to let in Mr. Ingersoll?”