AdventAI

MICHIGAN

By W. H. Littlejohn

From Review and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 26., June 27, 1882

Byron Center, Kent Co., June 19.—At the time of my last report, I was holding meetings in this place. Our lectures still continue, the attendance being as good as could be expected at a time of the year when the farmers are so busy as they are at the present time. Just before the camp-meeting at Allegan, very unexpectedly to us Eld. H. T. Barnaby of the United Brethren denomination was imported to combat the views which we were presenting. He did so in the hall where we were holding our lectures on an evening when it was not occupied by us. We gave notice that we would review him the next night; but the rain prevented, and we were not able to carry out our design until after the close of the Allegan camp-meeting. When the time arrived for the review, Eld. B. was present, and listened to what we had to say. When we had completed our discourse, we gave him opportunity to ask any question which he might see fit to ask, but he simply gave notice that he would reply to us the next evening. This he did, and we made our rejoinder the evening following.

So far as we are aware at present, it seems to be generally admitted by the candid and impartial that Eld. B.'s effort has been a failure.

We believe that the interests of our cause have been materially advanced by the discussion. Eld. B. is a man of fair ability, and an experienced debater—having had several discussions with our ministers—but neither ability nor experience in debate can make a man strong in the defense of error. The positions taken by Eld. B. were such as are frequently taken by our opponents. He argued that the ten commandments were the first covenant; that they are abolished, therefore, with that covenant, but that nine of them had been incorporated into the new covenant by virtue of the fact that they were either directly or indirectly alluded to in the New Testament. Perceiving that such a position rendered him liable to the charge of no-Sabbathism, he finally took the position that all which is moral in the fourth commandment remains; thus really abandoning the original theory that there were only nine commandments binding, and adopting the one that there are nine and a fraction of the tenth still obligatory.

The answering of these incongruous and contradictory views to the satisfaction of all who are capable of reasoning intelligibly, and are desirous of knowing the truth, was not at all difficult. In the first place we proved that the ten commandments were not the first covenant, and in the second place that the law of God, which is nothing more nor less in this dispensation than the decalogue, is in force under the new covenant. Having done this, the answer to Eld. B.'s argument was complete.

There is one thing commendatory of Eld. B. which we can say, as it regards this discussion. His treatment of us, throughout, was unexceptionally courteous and gentlemanly.

We cannot tell how long our meetings will continue in this place. Thos. A. Smith has been elected leader of the class; a club of ten subscribers for the Instructor has been raised, and a Sabbath-school is about to be organized.

W. H. LITTLEJOHN.