AdventAI

THE IRREPRESSIBLE CONFLICT.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 26., June 27, 1882

A FEW years ago the country was aghast in the presence of a riotous strike having its headquarters in Pittsburgh, Pa.; a strike which resulted in great destruction of property and terrible suffering, and was only suppressed by calling in the aid of the military. No such excitement prevails now as attended this riotous demonstration, and yet the country is witnessing a conflict between labor and capital that is perhaps of greater magnitude. Though it is a very quiet demonstration, it is wide-spread, and the strikers appear to have a fixed and definite purpose, and to have set about the attainment of their object with a determination to succeed, after having deliberately counted the cost. The following extracts, both from Harper’s Weekly of June 17, give a good idea of the extent and nature of the strikes:—

“That the great strike begun in the Pennsylvania iron district on the 1st of June must necessarily entail much immediate loss on those engaged in it, and on those depending on them, is something which the most ardent trades-unionist would not venture to deny. That it will be necessarily, in the long run, a losing game for the strikers, is something which the most irritated employer would hesitate to assert. It is a desperate remedy for what the strikers believe to be an actual evil; but that it is a remedy which sometimes alleviates the evil, and for a long period, is proved by experience. A strike is war—nothing more nor less—and like war, it is a hard thing for the conquered, and by no means an unmixed advantage to the conquerors. It is the final settlement, when all other settlements or attempted settlements fail, and it is a harsh, costly, irritating settlement at best, but it does settle. That there is no disputing.”

“It is estimated that from 100,000 to 150,000 men are on a strike in different parts of the country at the present moment. Their wages, taking a low average for the smaller number, are not less than a half-million dollars a week, which they are losing, and, except so far as they may make up by higher wages, if they succeed, are losing forever. There are dependent on these now idle men more than half a million persons, whose comforts and even whose needs are denied for the time, and who may be rendered permanently distressed if the strikes fail. Involved in these losses are those which fall upon the tradesmen and the workmen who supply what the strikers ordinarily consume, and what they must now consume less of, or none at all. It is not a pleasant picture for those who would have the average of human well-being and contentment high in our favored land. It implies a good deal of suffering, disturbed social relations, temptations to drink and disorder, neglect in families, and the possibility of a much lower standard of home conduct hereafter.”

So much for the extent and nature of the strike. Its object is thus stated:—

“One of the leaders of the iron strike is reported to have said that what is really wanted is a permanent understanding by which the workmen’s representatives can meet the mill-owners at the Board of Trade to discuss intelligently prices and rates. This shows the disposition by which alone industrial troubles can be settled satisfactorily. When the situation is one of a strike on one side and a shut-down upon the other, it is a situation of mere sullen endurance, during which feeling becomes mutually more exasperated, and adjustment more difficult. The remedy lies in some kind of individual understanding Huge organized bodies, whether of employers or workmen, deal with each other as corporations, and the old saying that corporations have no souls arises from the fact that their action is always official and not personal. An agent can but obey directions. He has practically no discretion, and merely represents an aggregate will. The great strikes are against corporations, and are angry and unmanageable just in the degree that individual understanding is impracticable.”