AdventAI

Secret Organizations.

By Joseph Clarke

From Review and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 28., July 11, 1882

BY JOSEPH CLARKE.

A Friend.—You need only to become acquainted with the workings of our order, to see that we do a great deal of good in many ways. We admit no one who is not moral; and we expel a member if he does not maintain such a character. Our rules are good, and have a tendency to promote good order.

Neighbor.—I will give you a few of my reasons for remaining outside of secret orders. I believe I shall have all I can do to prepare for the Judgment. All my time, all my means, which can be spared from my actual needs, I must use in the Lord’s work. All my influence, too, be it little or much, must be used to win men to the truth, and to the God of truth; and after I have done all I can, I am an unprofitable servant; for Christ has paid an infinite price for our ransom. The cause of God often suffers for want of means; and if his children devote their means to upholding any of the various secret orders, they draw this amount from the treasury of the Lord, and will be held accountable for money so applied. All we have is from God, and is only lent us to be put where it will best promote the progress of truth among men.

You speak of the charity of your order. I have your own reports to show that your society spends three dollars out of every four in keeping itself in motion; while only one in four is used for charity. And this is not charity; it is only a dividend you pay to stockholders. It is a kind of insurance company; and your members, by paying heavy fees, are entitled to support when sick or in want; and it is done as a matter of justice and of business. Often the worthy poor, when sick, are put off with such help as is really no comfort or charity.

I could speak of many other objections to secret societies; for instance, that they are clannish in their tendency. This principle works out occasionally, as in Communism and Vigilance Committees, which are often only organized mobs, led on by hot-headed demagogues. In the Old World, where Nihilism with its godless principles sits in secret conclave, and assassinates with brutal fury and reckless zeal, fearful scenes are enacted, and no one knows who strikes the blow. Secret assassination is the legitimate outgrowth of secret societies. However, do not understand me to say that all secret organizations are of this character; it is the principle involved that I hold is alike in each case. There is an oath of secrecy; meetings are held in secret.

Friend.—In condemning secret societies, you also discourage temperance orders, as Knights Templar, etc.

Neighbor.—While I approve of every effort to uphold the cause of temperance, I see no call for any such order as Knights Templar or Sons of Temperance, and I believe the cause of temperance needs no such aid.

Friend.—The church of Christ is a secret order also.

Neighbor.—No, my friend; the church is wholly free from such a principle. No oath of secrecy was ever administered, no secret session was ever held, by the apostles or by their Teacher, Jesus Christ. On the subject of secret societies, I speak as a Christian, not as a man of the world. As a subject of our Lord Jesus Christ, no oath of fealty to any secret order shall ever cramp my action or consume my time, hindering my usefulness in the great and good cause I have espoused. How often the prayer-meeting is forsaken for the lodge room. How many professors of religion pay their fee to the order, but neglect the payment of their church dues! No; if the righteous are scarcely saved, I must leave no duty neglected, nor load myself with any weights but such as the gospel imposes. Christ’s yoke is easy, and his burden is light; but I fear that a yoke additional and outside of this would cause both yokes to be heavy and galling.

Friend.—If such are your principles, I will say no more.