A DEMAND FOR MORE OF THE PUBLIC’S MONEY—WHY IT SHOULD BE REFUSED.
Three years ago, this institution applied to the Legislature for a large grant of money from the State, and its representatives then stated to the Legislature that if the money was given to the institution, they would not apply to the Legislature for any more grants. The money was given; but the very next year, to wit, 1880, they asked for another large amount. It was refused. In 1881 they applied again. That was refused. And each year they were informed that the grant in 1879 was only given them on the express understanding that they should not apply again. This year, 1882, like Monsieur Tonson, they have “come again,” and now beseech the Legislature for a little grant of $75,000 in addition to the allowance of $110 for each child and adult in the Protectory,—an allowance which ought not to be made,—which alone yields an annual profit of $50 each inmate, aggregating about one hundred thousand dollars annually on the two thousand children in the Protectory.
This private institution, under the sole control of one religious denomination, and carried on in the interest of that denomination, has already received from the public treasury, in the last thirteen years, the sum of $2,639,296.79.
What is it that this denominational establishment does that it should be so munificently endowed from the public treasury of the city and State of New York—nearly its entire revenue being contributed by the tax-payers of the city of New York?
A late occurrence in the town of Westchester tells in part, and this is the story: The Protectory gets possession, through the public authorities, of children, and then claims to be entitled to a weekly stipend for supporting these children—collecting together some two thousand of them in one caravansary, in order that they can more conveniently and surely make Roman Catholics of them. But, in fact, they are not even entitled to a dollar of this compensation, much less to a $75,000 bonus;—it is the duty of Protestants and Catholics to take care of their own poor. It is a well-known fact in our Sociology, that children brought up in large herds, as they are in this Protectory, are not well-fitted to become citizens of a free republic, where each one is expected to take care of and support himself, and keep out jail. When they reach maturity, they are like trees that have grown up in a dense forest. Transplant them to the open country, and they have not the lateral, moral, and intellectual bracing that will enable them to withstand the temptations and social demands that are made upon them. Children should be transplanted from these large nurseries as soon as possible to families, and be brought up and educated in families after the manner that parents bring up their own children; and then they acquire the habits and methods of thinking and acting that are likely to fit them to be independent, self-supporting citizens when they reach adult ages. The Catholic Protectory does not do this. On the contrary, it refuses absolutely to put out children into families at all, unless they can secure Roman Catholic families. They do this because the main end, aim, and object of the institution is to make good Catholics rather than good citizens, and because there is a large profit per capita on all the inmates kept at the Protectory at the rate of compensation allowed by the State, as already noted.
The town of Westchester has a number of children there; and good places have been found for them in families, but the Protectory refuses to surrender them up, that they may go to these families, and very properly the town of Westchester has refused to pay the weekly stipend for the support of these children in the Protectory.
We have in this city [New York] a corresponding institution for the aid and support of poor children, but which is not afflicted with slavery to a religious denomination,—the Children’s Aid Society,—which has assisted to provide for a great many thousand poor children, and is doing it every day. They keep the children in the institution no longer than is necessary to enable them to find homes in families and earn their own living. To secure this result, the Society searches the country, from New York to the Mississippi River, for healthful locations and good homes,—on farms if possible,—in which to place these poor children and enable them to be educated and brought up, and thus become thrifty and useful citizens. For doing this work the Children’s Aid Society is not paid $2,639,296.79 from the public treasury. It receives aid annually from the public, but only sufficient to enable it to put the children out, to be brought up as children should be, instead of herding them till some two thousand are collected under one roof, thus converting what should be simply a Protectory in the right sense of the word into an immense pauper hotel sustained at public expense, the profits going to the managers! The Roman Catholics have a perfect right to bring up their children in their own religion, and no good citizen objects to it; but, like the other denominations, they should do it at their own expense, and not tax the public to enable them to support their religious sect.
So profitable is this “Protectory” business that a lobby annually visits the Legislature in its interest. Bills are devised to be put through to enable them to compel the courts and public authorities to commit children to the Protectory, and then to compel the public treasury to give them the money, at high rates, more than double what it costs on farms to support these children. The support and education they give them in that institution is far below what the children would get if they were scattered abroad among farmers. They keep their drummers on the watch, at the different courts, to secure as many committals as possible, as the more committals the more money.
Every dollar of the public money appropriated to this institution, is a clear violation of the Constitution of the State of New York.
The children would be a great deal better taken care of, and brought up and educated, and fitted for self-supporting American citizens, if the Protectory did not exist. In any event, the public treasury should have nothing to do, directly or indirectly, with any religious denominations. The laws should protect them all equally, but favor none. Let our legislators consider this, when this application for the Protectory comes before them for action. Just what the Legislature does or fails to do will be regarded with keen interest by the people, who are about tired of seeing their money worse than squandered in sustaining an institution which is purely sectarian, and has therefore no claim upon public beneficence.—Christian at Work, April 13.