—The Clayton-Bulwer treaty comes to the front again in the publication of Secretary Frelinghuysen's exhaustive reply to Lord Granville anent the neutrality of the Panama canal. The reply follows the attitude taken by Mr. Blaine, in a practical assertion of the Monroe doctrine that the United States will not interfere in any European war, nor tolerate any attempt by any European power to acquire a controlling influence in this hemisphere. The Clayton-Bulwer treaty, upon which Great Britain bases its proposition for a joint protectorate to be exercised by herself and the United States over the Panama canal, with the consent of the powers and by treaty with the Central American States, was framed in 1850. Two subjects are covered by it, first, a projected canal through Nicaragua, to be, by the treaty, under joint control, and second, the establishment of a general principle of control to be extended over future isthmian waterways by treaty stipulations. The first part of the treaty became a dead letter by the nonconstruction of the Nicaragua canal. The British claim that the principle of control provided by the second part still holds good in the case of the Panama canal, is met by the secretary's reply that Great Britain in taking actual possession of Honduras has not complied with the conditions of the treaty, which provided that she should not extend her settlements in Central America for other purposes than those of temporary trade; and, again, that the treaty itself left the question of future joint control to be determined by other treaty stipulations, which thus far have not been made. In short, Mr. Frelinghuysen asserts that the Clayton-Bulwer treaty now has no meaning, or that if it has, it pertains only to a canal that does not exist. What reply England will make to argument of this kind it is hard to say. But whatever is said, it is plainly the duty of this government to renounce the treaty, so far as it admits joint European control over any isthmian waterway. The Panama canal practically converts commerce between the Atlantic and Pacific States into a coasting trade, which from its very nature belongs exclusively to this country.—Interior.
Frelinghuysen's Reply on Panama Canal Neutrality
From Review and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 25., June 20, 1882