FALSE THEORIES OF GEOLOGISTS

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 5, 1882

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 36.

Read the full edition

FALSE THEORIES OF GEOLOGISTS.

A correspondent wishes some facts with which to refute the theories of many scientists concerning the origin of stratified rocks and the immeasurable periods occupied in their formation.
It is the commonly received opinion that the immense beds of rock, which compose the bulk of the earth’s crust, were formed from detritus, washed down from granite mountains by rains and torrents, carried to the then existing seas by rivers, and spread forth in layers upon the bottom in the form of mud, and sand, and gravel, where, gradually forming into stone, they would forever have remained beneath the surface of the water, had not other forces been afterward employed to raise them into dry land. In predicating the great age of the world from the formation or wearing away of rocks, it is always assumed that the forces which produced these results were the same in kind and energy as those now going on. Thus Sir Charles Lyell says: “It is presumed that the reader will . . . be convinced that the forces formerly employed to remodel the crust of the earth, were the same in kind and energy as those now acting.”—Lyell’s Principles, pref. xi.
Applying the above principle, the Falls of Niagara, which—owing to the wearing away of the rock by the action of the water—have been estimated by the above writer to have receded at the rate of about a foot each year, have been nearly thirty-seven thousand years in cutting that mighty gorge from Lewiston back seven miles to their present position. But it is just here that the theory fails. The underlying principle upon which the whole structure rests is an assumption. Unless it be true that the forces which have acted in the remote past are the same as those now acting, who can possibly determine, even approximately, the length of time required for them to accomplish a given result? And that this principle is true, who has ever proven or tried to prove? Nobody. Usually it is either “presumed that the reader will be convinced” of the matter, or certain results are “supposed to have been effected by such causes as are operating at present.”
Having seen that this principle, so necessary to the life of the theory, is not a demonstrated truth but a convenient supposition, let us now inquire whether it is even a probable one; and that it is not so, from many reasons which might be given we offer the following:—
1. The most extensive formation of rock is the granite. “It wraps, it is generally believed, the whole circle of the globe, and is the basis, on which all the other formations rest; and it has come into existence, or received its present form, at least to a vast extent, since the formation of large portions of the rocks which now repose on it.” It was formerly supposed that granite was formed before the stratified rocks that rest upon it, and Lyell says, “It is not half a century since the doctrine was very general that all granitic rocks were primitive; but,” he continues, “so greatly are our views now changed, that we find it no easy task to point out a single mass of granite demonstrably more ancient than known fossiliferous deposits.”—Elements, p. 574.
But no granite, so far as is known, is produced at the present time, nor has been since the formation of the masses that constitute the main element of the great mountain ranges, and were the instrument by which the sedimentary strata that clothe their sides, and rest on many of their heights, were thrown up. There is not the slightest proof, or probability even, that a particle of it has been crystallized for ages. What the conditions are, indeed, that are essential to its formation, are not fully known. It is generally held to be the result of fusion; but what the precise combination of causes is, or what the circumstances are in which they must act in order to unite the ingredients of which it consists in the proportions and forms that constitute its peculiarities, there are no means in the present state of the science of determining.
“The greatest and most important geological process that has ever taken place on the earth’s surface, and that was wrought on its greatest scale at a late period in the formation of the sedimentary strata, is thus wholly unlike any that is now in progress, or has been for ages, and confutes therefore the theory that the forces by which the crust of the earth was formed and modified, exist and operate with the same energy, and give birth to the same species of effects, and on the same scale, at all periods.”—Lord.
2. Concerning the formation of coal, geologists are much in debate. That it was formed beneath the ocean, and is of vegetable origin are about the only points upon which they agree. It is held by one class that those vegetables grew where the coal lies, and that by a sinking of the land they were submerged beneath the waters of the ocean, and covered over with deposits of earth, etc. Others maintain that by some mighty cataclysm this material was swept here, and overwhelmed with vast masses of debris. We think the latter supposition the more reasonable, and it is just such a work as we would expect to have been accomplished by the flood. But whichever theory be adopted, we have a contradiction of the assumption upon which the theory of the great age of the world is built. “That the principal beds are of a single period, proves that the causes by which they were generated acted only at that epoch; and that they are confined to a few limited areas, shows that they acted only on those scenes, and confutes the doctrine accordingly that the geological agents by which the strata were formed have acted at all periods, and given birth to their effects at a uniform rate. Coal ought, on that theory, to be found in as great abundance in the primary and tertiary series as in the secondary, and to be forming as visibly and rapidly at the present period as any other geological effect that is now taking place.”—Lord.
3. The following testimony from Humboldt is applicable in this connection, and needs no comment:—
“When seated on the bank of the Oroonoko, our eyes fixed on those rocky dykes, the mind inquires whether, in the lapse of ages, the falls change their form or height. I am not much inclined to believe in such effects of the shock of water against blocks of granite and in the erosion of silicious matter. The holes narrowed toward the bottom, the funnels that are discovered in the raudales, as well as near so many other cascades in Europe, are owing only to the friction of the sand and the movement of quartz pebbles. . . .
“We will not deny the action of rivers and running waters when they furrow friable ground covered with secondary formations. But the granite rocks Elephantine have probably no more changed their absolute height during thousands of years than the summits of Mont Blanc and of Canigou. When you have closely inspected the great scenes of nature in different climates, it is impossible not to admit that those deep clefts, those strata raised on end, those scattered blocks, those traces of a general convulsion, are the results of extraordinary causes, very different from those which act slowly on the surface of the globe in its present state of tranquillity and repose. What the waters carry away from the granite by erosion, what the humid atmosphere destroys by its contact with hard and undecomposed rocks, almost wholly escapes our perception; and I cannot believe, as some geologists admit, that the granitic summits of the Alps and the Pyrenees lower in proportion to the accumulation of pebbles in the gullies at the foot of the mountains. In the Nile, as well as in the Oroonoko, the rapids may diminish their fall, without the rocky dykes being perceptibly altered.”—Humboldt’s Narrative, vol. v. pp. 62, 64, 65.