BY. N. J. BOWERS.
That many of our hymns and devotional songs are excellent, cannot be doubted. They are good, as regards poetical merit and devotional fervor, but some are sadly marred by the manifest errors in sentiment which they set forth. This is to be regretted, as one of the best ways to propagate and keep alive error is to embody it in popular songs. The people get attached to the songs, and the errors in sentiment they contain will be cherished as a matter of course. We are admonished to “sing with the spirit and with the understanding also.” We are to make what we sing our own thought and feeling. How are we to do this when that which is sung, though good in other respects, is false in expression and untrue in itself? It cannot be done, and so before we can sing many of our good hymns, there will have to be more or less change. One can no more sing an error than he can preach it, or believe it. Let us be careful what we sing as well as how we sing.
Some hymns not only teach false sentiment, but are contradictory in their statements, and even teach truths their authors did not intend. We have an illustration of all these particulars in one of Charles Wesley’s popular church productions. It is found in one of the editions of the Methodist collection of hymns, page 641. I will copy the greater part of it.
“And am I born to die? To lay this body down? And must my trembling spirit fly Into a world unknown?— A land of deepest shade, Unpierced by human thought, The dreary regions of the dead, Where all things are forgot.”
With a slight amendment in the third line the above would pass for good “soul-sleeper” doctrine. It agrees well with the Bible teaching of the sleep of the dead. Good Charles Wesley hardly escaped teaching soul-sleeping in this effusion; yet we are told the Wesleys were orthodox, and we think they were in many things. Do our Methodist brethren indorse the sentiment put forth in the stanza? Does the spirit, when freed from its clay, instead of returning to God who gave it, fly into
“A land of deepest shade, Unpierced by human thought, The dreary regions of the dead, Where all things are forgot,”
or is here where God, who dwelleth in the light unapproachable, is?
“Soon as from earth I go, What will become of me? Eternal happiness or woe Must then my portion be. Waked by the trumpet’s sound, I from my grave shall rise, And see the Judge with glory crowned And see the flaming skies.”
At the beginning of this stanza the question is asked,
“Soon as from earth I go, What will become of me?”
The answer is,
“Eternal happiness or woe Must then my portion be.”
This hardly agrees with the last four lines of the preceding stanza. Is the famous “world of spirits” indeed
“A land of deepest shade, Unpierced by human thought, The dreary regions of the dead, Where all things are forgot?”
How, then, is it possible to experience “happiness or woe” in such a place and in such a condition? And again, if such was to be his condition, why was it necessary to arise from the grave at all? He continues:—
“How shall I leave my tomb? With triumph or regret? A fearful or a joyful doom, A curse or blessing meet? Will angel bands convey Their brother to the bar? Or devils drag my soul away To meet its sentence there?”
He speaks in this stanza as though all were undecided, as though all in the resurrection would know, and not till then, what their “eternal portion” would be; that then the soul would be conveyed to the bar of God to receive its sentence; yet it had already been in bliss or woe, and that, too, without a sentence. Here is award without acquittal, and penalty without a sentence.
The truth is, popular theology in hymns and sermons and current religious literature, needs a complete overhauling, that its errors be expunged, and that it assume consistency with the Bible, with common sense, and with itself.