Mark says the Sabbath was past when the women came to the sepulcher to anoint Jesus. Mark 16:1. But does not the statement in Matt. 28:1-8 prove that the resurrection transpired on the Sabbath? I think not. It is not stated that the resurrection occurred on the Sabbath.
Mark, Luke, and John state that it was upon the first day of the week when they came to anoint Jesus. All that is necessary to harmonize the four statements in regard to the day of the week upon which the event occurred is to translate the first word of Matt. 28:1 by after instead of by “in the end of.” Thus easily are the passages harmonized by this rendering, which is sustained by good authority. But if this method be rejected, then follows the impossible task of harmonizing the other three accounts with the assumed meaning of the phrase, “in the end of the Sabbath,” of Matt. 28:1. Let us see what it would take to do this. In Mark 16:1, when must be changed to while, and past to continuing. In the second verse, “Early in the morning of the first day” must give place to “late in the evening of the last day,” and the ninth verse must be mutilated in a similar way. Passing on to Luke, we must blot out the last half of verse 56, chapter 23, and put the twenty-fourth chapter to the same torture as that endured by Mark 16, with the additional infliction of changing same to next in the thirteenth verse and third to fourth in verse 21. When this is accomplished we must arrange the twentieth chapter of John to harmonize with our new versions in Mark and Luke; and by this time we would have little faith left in the record at all.
If the twenty-eighth chapter of Matthew teaches that the Saviour rose upon the Sabbath, it also proves that those women who proposed to anoint his body knew that he was raised upon the Sabbath. And if they knew this, and were not insane, then it is further evident that they would not go to the tomb the next morning to anoint him. Therefore, the arrangement proposed above is necessary to defend these women against the charge of insanity.
But we are told that if Christ was crucified on the sixth day and raised on the following first day, he did not fulfill his own predictions relating to the subject; as he was to be “three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.” To fulfill this prediction according to the understanding of those to whom he was talking, it was not necessary that he should lie in the grave seventy-two hours. The statement of the priests and Pharisees, who demanded a watch to prevent the disciples from stealing him away (Matt. 27:63), is proof of this. They would certainly desire the watch to remain on guard until the expiration of the time indicated in the prediction; yet they only requested a watch “until the third day.”
John was one who heard the Master’s teachings, and we will let him tell us how much time it takes to constitute a period reaching from a given point to the “third day.” “They came and saw where he dwelt, and abode with him that day; for it was about the tenth hour.” (Margin, two hours before night.) John 1:39. This is the first day of the series; in verse 43 we have the second: “The day following Jesus would go forth into Galilee;” and in Chap. 2:1 is found the third: “And the third day there was a marriage in Cana of Galilee.” There cannot possibly be more than one entire day and two parts of days included in the period cited above. Again, Acts 27:17-19, “fearing lest they should fall into the quicksands, strake sail, and so were driven. And we being exceedingly tossed with a tempest, the next day they lightened the ship; and the third day we cast out with our own hands the tackling of the ship.”
Not only do we find this manner of expression well understood and in common use among the followers of Christ, but we have the example of the Lord himself in Ex. 19:10, 11,—“Today and to-morrow and the third day.” All this agrees with the idea of the crucifixion of our Saviour on the sixth day, the Sabbath on the next day, and the first day of the week the “third day,” or resurrection day.
Taking this view of the subject, we are not under the necessity of misconstruing the testimony of those two disciples, who, on their way to Emmaus on the first day of the week, testified that this is the third day since these things were done. A positive proof that the Saviour indicated the “day after to-morrow” in speaking of the third day is found in Luke 13:31-33: “Go ye, and tell that fox, Behold, I cast out devils, and do cures to-day and to-morrow, and the third day I shall be perfected. Nevertheless I must walk to-day, and to-morrow, and the day following.” Although the Scripture does not refer to the time Christ would lie in the grave or remain dead, yet it clearly shows us how much time is indicated when he spoke of an event occurring the third day from a given point. The defense of the Sabbath is in no way strengthened by trying to maintain that Christ arose on the Sabbath.