A LETTER by Chas. S. Bryant of St. Paul, Minn., originally addressed to the editor of the Popular Science Monthly, and published in that journal several months ago, has been going the rounds of the papers, and unsettling the minds of some.
This writer, by a new and original application of what he is pleased to call the “true rule of the Hebrew uses in case of concrete numerals,” reduced the age of Adam from 930 years to the more nearly modern figures of 139, and dealt with the ages of the other patriarchs after the same manner. All this was done so positively and, seemingly, with such an array of argument, that doubtless many were deceived.
Desiring to obtain an authoritative opinion of this remarkable letter for the benefit of the readers of the REVIEW in general, and of a certain correspondent in particular, the article was sent to W. R. Harper, Professor of Hebrew in the Baptist Union Theological Seminary, Morgan Park, Chicago, and Manager of the American Institute of Hebrew. The following is his reply:—
ELDER URIAH SMITH;
Dear Brother,—
The article referred to has already been called to my attention several times. I can only say in reference to it; (1.) That subsequent numbers of the Popular Science Monthly contained replies to this article, and that it would only be fair if those papers which published the article would also publish the reply. (2.) That no more false conception of Hebrew syntax could be penned than that which lies at the foundation of the article. The writer shows himself to be lamentably ignorant of the most common principles of the language. A more brazen, unreliable, unscholarly statement could not well be imagined. It is so absurd as to be unworthy of a reply. Yours truly,
W. R. HARPER,
Baptist Union Theological Seminary, Chicago, Ill.