Questions of the Day

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 26, 1882

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 39.

Read the full edition

Questions of the Day.

The address delivered by Lyman Abbott, at Chautauqua Lake, Aug. 11, cannot fail to be of interest to any one who wishes to be intelligent on the questions of the day; and it is doubly interesting to the student of prophecy, who is watching the omens that indicate the approach of the great day of God. Especially notice what is said of the concentration of wealth, and the conflict between labor and capital. We regret that the length of the address prevents its publication entire, but the following extracts are quite copious:—
My object to-day is to ask questions, not to answer them. It is to put problems before you for your consideration, and to suggest some of the lines along which they must be considered, with reference to the future welfare of our great and loved country.
It is scarcely possible for us to conceive, though it has often been spoken of, the great growth which this country has undergone in the last century—yes, within the memory of men now living. Along with this growth in size and in population there has been a wondrous growth in wealth. It is not three-quarters of a century ago that the pilgrims in Maine were discussing by their firesides what they would do when Maine had been denuded of its forests, and the fuel of the country was gone. Since then Pennsylvania has unlocked her doors and opened her treasure-house of coal to us. It is not half a century since the citizens of Massachusetts, finding the whale traffic dying out and the supplies of whale-oil diminishing, were anxious and perturbed concerning the problem what they should do for illumination in the years to come. Within that half-century Pennsylvania has again flung open her gates of stone and poured out her treasures of oil to us. During this period of three-quarters of a century, wealth has multiplied; the desert has blossomed as the rose; cities have sprung up where before there was not a single house. Men have taken advantage of this general growth in wealth and prosperity, and boys that were beggar boys at ten have become millionaires at forty, not in single or isolated instances, but again and again.
Now, this great growth in size, in population, and in wealth, carries with it also growth in danger, and the mechanism which our fathers devised for our government, admirably adapted to a little nation of five millions of people, has proved not adequate for a nation of fifty millions. We have outgrown the original device and thought. With the growth of the nation has come growth in political corruption. The very prosperity of the nation, which makes it possible for politicians to take every year a hundred and fifty millions of dollars out of your pockets that are not needed for the government's administration, and hoard it in the Treasury at Washington, gathers about the Treasury a horde of thieves and robbers; for it is just as true now as it was eighteen centuries ago, “Where the carcass is there shall the vultures be gathered together.”
In 1870 the letter carriers of a single town in New Hampshire, Manchester, had as many letters to carry as were carried by the whole United States in 1790. Such has been the growth of our civil service. And this immense growth of machinery has involved, and almost unavoidably, a growth of covetousness and corruption in the administration of public machinery. Paganism has entered into our public service, and Christianity has been driven out. For the pagan conception of government is that the offices belong to the governors; and the Christian conception is, that the officers are the servants of the governed. The doctrine, “To the victor belong the spoils,” does not date, as men imagine that it does, from the days of Andrew Jackson. If age gives respectability, that doctrine is very respectable, for it is very aged. It dates from the day when Achan hid his spoils in his tent.
To-day we have in America, in round numbers, a hundred thousand officers. I have not been able to ascertain what is the combined salary paid to these men. Whether it is intentional or unintentional I do not know, but the statistics are so reported that an accurate discrimination is impossible. The civil list reported is seventeen million dollars a year. In addition to that is the expense of the collection of the revenue; that is, the salaries paid to custom-house officers and revenue officers. It is certainly safe to say that the salaries paid our national office-holders make a gross amount of not less than twenty-five million dollars a year. Consider for a moment what is involved in the principle that these offices belong to the dominant party. It means that every four years the United States holds up before the gaze of all its people a hundred million dollars, and says to each party: Whichever of you can win the election shall have the bag.
The growth of our country has brought with it not merely growth in corruption and danger from corruption. It has brought with it a danger which threatens the integrity of the nation, and it has set at work disintegrating elements in our national life of which we have not, as yet, taken sufficient account. Our nation is not only vast in territory, but it is varied in interest, because varied in its climate and its capacity of production. Under the one American flag we have the productions of Sweden and Norway in the North, and the products of Central India in the South; we have the manufacturing interests of England, and the agricultural interests in which no other country is our peer; we are miners, and manufactures, and agriculturists, and a commercial nation. There is no other nation on the face of the globe that has such sea coasts and such harbors; no other nation has such water powers; no other nation has such treasures of coal, and gold and silver; no nation has such treasures locked up in its soil of agricultural wealth. But these four interests—agriculture, commerce, mining, and manufactures—oftentimes come into conflict. We are not alike in our interests, and inevitable conflict is the consequence of these conflicting interests.
Yet more serious is the conflict which comes out of our heterogeneous population. If we were simply Anglo-Saxons, and if we had only ourselves to take care of, our problem would be a very simple one; for the Anglo-Saxon race, as we all know, is very intelligent, virtuous and self-restrained. But into this nation God has been pouring, by his providence, all classes and conditions of men, until in our nation to-day there is a greater variety of race, of tongue, and of character, than is to be found anywhere else on the face of the globe. It is said that in New York City alone you can hear German spoken, in all the various dialects of the various German provinces, to greater perfection, and with greater variety than in any city of Germany itself. All languages are here—Italian, French, German, Spanish. All races are here—Anglo-Saxon, Celt, Latin, Mongolian. All colors are here—black, white, and all shades between. And, what is perhaps more important, all religions are here. Here is the negro race with its emotive religion; here is the Puritan race with its intellectual religion; here is the Roman Catholic with its ceremonial religion; and here is the great body of Nothing-arians with its pagan religion. Now what shall we do with this incoming and oncoming foreign population—half a million landing on our shores last year, with fair prospect that it will reach three-quarters of a million, if not an entire million, in this present year? What shall we do with them?
In the first place, we cannot exclude them if we would. Now, our problem is to take this heterogeneous population, of various races, languages, habits of civilization, and of various religions, and fuse them into a common nationality. We are to do it, I believe, in the first place by welcoming them to all the privileges of citizenship; and I mean by that, we are to welcome them to the ballot; we are to welcome them to universal manhood suffrage. There are a great many persons who are afraid of foreign voting. They say, “Is it safe to allow an ignorant population, coming to our country, untrained in American thought, unfamiliar with American ideas, or even with the English language, is it safe to allow them to vote?” But have you considered the other question, Is it safe to have a great ignorant population without a vote? Have you considered the danger of a great population in your midst that have no power to express themselves, and no opportunity to represent their interests in national affairs? Have you turned over the pages of history, learning something of the experience of the past? Have you read the story of what the Chartist riots meant in England when the ballot was held back from the ignorant population there, and all England trembled on the verge of a volcano of insurrection, from which she was saved by the extension of the suffrage? Have you considered what is the meaning of the great uprising and revolution in France, where the great ignorant population were denied the ballot, and took the bullet, and fought their way to the defense of what they accounted their rights? An ignorant population in any community is full of threatening danger, but with representatives it is far safer than without. Have you considered what is the educative power of the ballot,—how every election brings this whole nation to school?
And we are to welcome this great foreign population—and this is yet more important—to a universal, national education. We have done something toward education in this country, and yet we have only begun. To-day thirty-three per cent of the voters of the Southern States cannot read and write. Is that safe? One of the great problems before us to-day is this: Is it the function of the church or of the State to carry on education? The Roman Catholic Church maintains that the State has no right to educate. It belongs to the church to educate, and to the State to govern. The American doctrine is that the Republic has a right to do everything that is necessary for its own preservation and perpetuation. The royal family has a right to educate its own children at the State expense. Every family in America is a royal family, and therefore every family in America has a right to have its children educated at the State expense. That education must be unsectarian. We must not by our schools strengthen, but obliterate, the dividing lines. It must be national, not German and Swedish, not French or Irish, but American. It must be universal. We do not realize how tremendous is the responsibility of education laid upon us by the very fact of our growth and our prosperity.
Yet more serious in some respects, certainly more immediately threatening, are the dangers which confront us from the concentration of wealth and the conflict between labor and capital. Wealth in all ages has had a tendency to concentrate. It flows together naturally. In England twenty-five men own one-tenth of the whole soil. The wealth of England is in her land, and her land has been brought together into the hands of a few men. In America that concentration has taken a different form, not in land, but in money, and through the influence of great corporations. What is a corporation? It is a contrivance by which many men put their wealth into the hands of one man, or of a few men, to wield its concentrated power for them, and get the benefits of that concentration on their behalf. This concentration of wealth has been steadily going on and rapidly increasing. To-day the railroad corporations of the United States own property that is estimated to be worth four and a half billions of dollars! The figures convey no conception to the mind, for no imagination is able to form an image of that enormous wealth. They are estimated to earn every year two hundred millions of dollars. No wonder that they can buy legislatures and courts and judges, if it be necessary.
And this enormous concentration of wealth, two hundred millions of dollars every year, is in the hands and under the control of a comparatively small number of men. A few years ago—I do not know how it is now—six men, I think it was, met once a month at Long Branch to determine autocratically how much coal should be taken out of the mines of Pennsylvania and carried to the markets of New York. In the hands of those six men the control of the fuel of our metropolis was left. To-day four men combining together can determine what shall be the price of carriage, and therefore what shall be the price of breadstuffs in the metropolis of New York. To-day one or two men actually do control the price of our light. A half score of men, as many as you can count on your two hands, can to-day control on the Atlantic coast the price of our fuel, the price of our breadstuffs, and the price of our light. When the light, the bread, and the fuel of a great section of the nation is controlled by a dozen men, how far are we from oligarchy? These great railroad corporations control our State legislatures, in many cases our judiciary and our courts of justice. They are able to exercise a controlling influence to-day in the Senate of the United States, and probably, also, in the House of Representatives. Every Senator who has been added to the Senate list within the last four or five years, I believe, without exception—certainly with few, if any—is interested in railroad corporations. The brakeman stands upon the end of the car and turns his brake, working his ten or twelve hours a day, and gets his dollar and a half a day. Occasionally his wages are held back, as they were two years ago by one of our great railroad corporations, for a month or two, in order that dividends may be paid to the stockholders, and that the monopolists of the stock market may profit by speculation. While he is working at these wages, he sees men growing rich at such a rate that one railroad king accumulates ninety millions in a score of years, and another seventy odd millions in twenty-nine or thirty years. No wonder he grows discontented. The time is coming, fellow citizens, when this question must be met and solved by us. Either our railroad corporations will control our country, or our country must control the railroad corporations. When once that issue is fairly presented, so that the whole American people shall see it, the whole American people will not think twice in order to record their verdict.
The inevitable result of this concentration of wealth is the combination of labor and resulting strikes. One quarter of our workers are engaged in working for wages under the employ of capitalists. What is the relation between these wage-laborers and capitalists? The old political economy had nothing wiser or better to say to us on this subject than this: Labor is a commodity; capital is to go into the market and hire its labor at the cheapest possible price. That is, a man is like coal, to be bought at the lowest price. One quarter of our population are in the market to be hired by the day, the week, or the year, at the lowest possible figure. All the selfishness of capital is arrayed to bear the labor market; to depreciate and depress wages. All the selfishness of the laboring population is arrayed to bull the labor market; to appreciate and increase the value of wages. And capital on the one side and labor on the other are arrayed in arms, one against the other, in a perpetual state of chronic inquietness, ever and anon breaking out into open war. If there is in modern scientific thought no better solution of this great problem of the relations of labor and capital than this, if this is the latest word that Christianity has to say for this problem, then the inevitable result is a continuance of strikes until the bitter end. And what that end shall be, who can tell? Since capital is already a concentration for the purpose of getting labor cheap, labor will concentrate to make labor dear. Inevitably labor will combine to say, first, We will not work; and then, No man else shall work; and then—let the fires that blazed from Chicago to Pittsburgh only three or four years ago show us what the possible dangers of the not far-off future are.
Temperance is hardly one of the questions of the day. You were told only a few days ago, I see by this morning’s Chautauqua Assembly Herald, how old a question this is. Yet it ever recurs in ever new forms. I have only a word to say about it, for it has been much and fully discussed; but it is a question which somehow or other we in America must meet. Worse foe to American institutions than superstition, with all its power; worse foe to American institutions than ignorance, with all its capabilities of being misled and used by designing men, is intemperance; and in some way, by some method, we must learn how to solve the problem to make our nation intelligent, and to make our nation temperate.
I have thus endeavored briefly to sketch out before you, not all, certainly, but some of the great questions of the day that confront us. What shall we do to purify our government? What shall we do to consolidate our Union? What shall we do to harmonize and unify in one American nation, all the diverse elements which God in his providence is pouring in upon us? What shall we do to educate labor and to harmonize the relations between labor and capital? What shall we do to redeem and ransom the community from the stigma and the fever passion of intemperance? These are some of the problems that present themselves before us for the present and for the future.