Is Trial by Jury a Failure?
The difficulty of convicting criminals in our courts of justice, no matter how atrocious the crime or how plain the evidence, is quite generally conceded. This difficulty has just been strikingly illustrated in the star-route case, in which, after a tedious and expensive trial, the jury failed to agree in the case of the principal defaulters, although the evidence presented left little room for doubt of their guilt. The developments in the case lead the Christian Advocate to speak as follows concerning trial by jury:— The attempt to bribe the jury in the celebrated star-route case differs from most others chiefly in the fact that it has been exposed to and denounced by the Court. In all large cases, and in some small ones, where one or both parties have considerable money, honest lawyers—that is, men who would not bribe nor connive at bribery—have more fears of the jury’s being tampered with than of all other things. Wherever a disagreement is equivalent to a victory—generally when men are accused of crime, or liable to be compelled to disgorge stolen funds, or to indemnify others for losses—the temptation to use money to control the result is great. One man only needs to be bought to defeat the State or the plaintiff. The first thing done is to look up the antecedents of every one of the jury. In New York skillful men are employed to trace them and report before midnight. Good men take these precautions to guard against the wrong man’s getting on the jury, or in order to be able to watch him if he does. Bad men do it to know whom and how to approach. Yet the jury system is “the palladium of our liberties!” It was so once. Whether it is so now, South or North, is an open question.