DEITY DEFAMED

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 10, 1882

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 40.

Read the full edition

DEITY DEFAMED.

THERE are in the world great and saving truths. There are, on the other hand, alas! great and ruinous errors. It is one of the strangest anomalies to be met with in the religious world, that one of these errors, even the capstone of the temple of heathen darkness, should be enshrined in the temple of Christianity as one of the most sacred truths of the gospel. We refer to the doctrine of the eternal torment of the reprobate, which, as forcibly remarked by a recent writer, “involves God, his whole administration, and his eternal kingdom, in the deepest dishonor that the mind of man or angel can conceive. The human mind cannot be held back from abhorring such a theory, except by the most unnatural violence to its divinely-inspired convictions of honor and right.”
We can but regard most highly the views of those men who have had breadth of vision sufficient to enable them to see that possibly all truth might not be brought out in any one age, and that what was held to be truth, further light might show to be in need of modification in some particulars. God can lead and instruct such men, as compared with those who run their views into cast-iron molds, and bar the way to all further development.
Alexander Vinet described what he considered might possibly be the case with Christendom, even now, in the following forcible words: “Even now, after eighteen centuries of Christianity, we may be involved in some tremendous error, of which the Christianity of the future will make us ashamed.”
And Dr. Abercrombie gives utterance to the following salutary caution: “Beware of a nominal acquiescence in certain alleged truths, because you have been taught them in your infancy, or because they are the established opinions of those with whom you are connected.”
Dr. Chalmers also speaks to the same point, breathing the following petition, in which every one who esteems truth above creeds will heartily join: “Deliver me from the narrowing influence of human lessons, from human systems of theology. Teach me directly out of the fullness and freeness of thine own word. Hasten the time when, unfettered by sectarian intolerance, and unarmed by the authority of man, the Bible shall make its rightful impression upon all; the simple and obedient readers thereof calling no man master but Christ only.”
The doctrine of eternal misery is such an one as comes within the scope of Dr. Vinet’s language. It is a doctrine of which the plain teaching of God’s word is calculated to make us ashamed. But so tenacious is its hold upon some minds that they seem to be utterly unimpressible by the plainest truths and the most pointed and explicit Scripture declarations upon this subject. It generates a spirit of intolerance like that which prevailed in the Dark Ages, when this doctrine flourished in its greatest luxuriance; and dark and unscriptural as it is, it has permeated society everywhere as if it were of divine origin. But it all rests upon a mere fiction—the assumed immortality of the soul, or the deathless nature of all men. Upon this assumption rest many of the gigantic errors of heathenism, Romanism, and spiritualism; and to the dishonor of Protestants it must be said, these errors are largely upheld by them, on the same ground.
How potent this doctrine of the soul’s immortality is held to be in its sanctifying effects upon the human heart, and how sacred a place is assigned to it in the plan of salvation, is shown by the fact that when the acquaintances of the late Wm. H. Seward were casting about for some evidence that he was a Christian, and had certainly gone to Heaven, they at last found an instance in which he had expressed his belief in the immortality of the soul; and that was sufficient. He was immediately assigned a place among the redeemed.
Few have any idea of the fearful length to which the advocates of eternal misery go in their efforts to rivet that horrible dogma on the minds of others, especially the young. We present herewith two extracts which are utterly shocking to the moral sense of every intelligent reader, and we give them for this very reason. If the reader is a believer in the doctrine of eternal misery, we trust such pictures will shock him entirely out of such a God-dishonoring conception, and bring him to accept the Scriptural view of the dealings of a just God with his creatures; namely, that he will give eternal life to those who prove themselves worthy of it, and suffer all others to go back into that death which they choose as their portion. These extracts are from a Catholic work entitled, “Father Furniss’ Books for Children, for First Communion, Missions, Retreats, and Sunday-schools.” Book 10 gives “A Sight of Hell,” and section 20 has the following description of “a bed of fire”:—
“The sinner lies chained down on a bed of red-hot blazing fire! When a man sick of fever is lying on even a soft bed, it is pleasant sometimes to turn around. If the sick man lies on the same side for a long time, the skin comes off, the flesh gets raw. How will it be when the body has been lying on the same side on the scorching, broiling fire for a hundred million of years! Now look at that body lying on the bed of fire. All the body is salted with fire. The fire burns through every bone and every muscle. Every nerve is trembling and quivering with the sharp fire. The fire rages inside the skull, it shoots out through the ears, it roars in the throat as it roars in a chimney. So will mortal sin be punished.”
Section 27 is called “The Boiling Kettle,” and presents the following revolting conception of an imagination perverted by this fearful error:—
“Look in this little prison. In the middle of it there is a boy, a young man; he is silent; despair is on him. He stands straight up. His eyes are burning coals. Two long flames come out of his ears, his breathing is difficult. Sometimes he opens his mouth, and breath of blazing fire rolls out of it. But listen! there is a sound just like that of a boiling kettle. Is it really a kettle which is boiling? No. Then what is it? Hear what it is. The blood is boiling in the scalded veins of that boy. The brain is boiling and bubbling in his head. The marrow is boiling in his bones! Ask him, put the question to him, why is he thus tormented? His answer is that when he was alive, his blood boiled to do wicked things, and he did them. Ask him, does he think the punishment greater than he deserves? ‘No’—it is just.”
This doctrine is a most fruitful source of infidelity, and has led multitudes to slight and abhor that system of religion by which, as they had been made to believe, it is taught. But the tide is rising in another direction. A swelling army from almost all denominations is renouncing the unscriptural dogma, and rallying around the standard of the great truth of life and immortality through Christ alone. A critic in the New Englander laments the coming in of this heresy of “conditional immortality,” and looks upon it as “the spread of a contagion.” But somehow they do not succeed very well in arresting the progress of this contagion, which is becoming epidemic, although those who are employed to doctor the divinity for the people, are largely changing their treatment, and sugar-coating the eternal-misery pill with the idea that the torment is not literal, and that the sinner may, by a term of good behaviour, be finally relieved from it altogether.
But where the doctrine still prevails in its original deformity, let us hope that the mistake of the infidel judge will become much more frequent. After listening to an orthodox and forcible sermon on this subject, after the order of the old school, he was asked by the minister the next day how he liked the sermon. He replied, “Very much indeed.” “Ah,” said the minister, “I am glad to hear you say so; for I thought you did not hold to the view of the Deity I presented.” “The Deity, do you say? I thought it was the devil you were preaching about. You must excuse me; I am a little hard of hearing.”