AdventAI

The Strikes of the Season.

By Lyman H. Atwater

From Review and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 40., October 10, 1882

In a paper contributed by me to The Independent last autumn on the “Great Drought” then culminating, I asked attention to some probable consequences of it, which seemed very much overdrawn to those who had not duly measured its enormous magnitude and inevitable economic effects as respects the industrial, commercial, and productive interests of the country, and whatever is involved with them. In all essentials, these foreshadowings have unhappily been more than realized. Along with other consequences, the cost of living was very seriously enhanced by it for all classes, but in greatest proportion for people of slenderest resources. While it lessened the supply and increased the cost of flour and meats for all classes, it produced a far severer scarcity of those articles of subsistence which are the special dependence of the laboring classes and the poor in time of extremity. When have the vegetables and esculents, usually so abundant and cheap in winter, been so scarce and prodigiously dear? This made large importations of potatoes and cabbages from Europe profitable, a thing unprecedented in the memory of this generation.

Out of all this came not only a marked increase in the average cost of living for all classes, but a much greater ratio of increase in the cost of articles usually consumed by the laboring classes. It is not surprising, therefore, that the laborers have sorely felt the need of an increase of wages. So far my sympathies are with them. I should rejoice, if it were practicable, to see their wages advanced enough to meet this deficit, not only during its temporary continuance, but permanently, so as to augment their comfort and resources after the recent visitation of scarcity gives way to promised plenty; but impossibilities cannot be achieved. The tides cannot be arrested. Economic laws can no more be annulled than the law of gravitation. Let us note the difficulties which these strikes have encountered, whether special to the present case or inherent in strikes as such.

1. The deficiency of food-crops, and consequent dearness of living, bears heavily upon all but the more opulent classes, certainly upon all people of limited income. They are not, therefore, in a position to make good the deficit to the laboring classes, but must share it with them. Not only so, but their ability to purchase their wanted supplies of articles, the production of which gives employment to many of the laboring classes, is seriously curtailed. Out of this comes a falling market for many of these products, and a decrease of the wage-fund usually growing out of this class of manufactures. A rise of wages is, therefore, so far impossible, and a decrease either in rate of wages or the number employed is unavoidable. Strikes in all these departments simply betray the most absolute infatuation.

How far-reaching this may be is not easily seen. Each one may cast about for himself, and consider the vast number of things consumed by families of limited income covered by it in a greater or less degree. And these constitute the immense majority of families and consumers.

2. But, passing beyond this to some more conspicuous theaters of the recent strikes (the iron, coal, and railroad industries) which are largely, though not wholly interlocked, the food failure, felt so directly by the people, damaged railroads by a great diminution of their wonted business and income. They were thus, as a whole, exceptionally unfurnished with means to advance wages beyond the normal market rate, as determined by the law of supply and demand, or even to keep up their usual outlays in maintaining, improving, and extending their roadways and equipments. This reacts with force on the demand for iron, the chief material required inp. 630 iron rails and iron horses, the demand for which constitutes the great support of the iron market and manufacturer. And this, in turn, is one of the chief supports of the coal industry, so much of this fuel being consumed in the manufacture of iron. While all the industries of society are more or less mutually interdependent, depending upon the mutual exchangeability of products, and this again upon the possession of commodities to give and take by the exchanging parties, these three departments are peculiarly interlocked, first with one another, and then, above all, with agriculture, insomuch that it is impossible that from one-third to two-fifths of the annual food supply should fail in this country without causing a diminution of the share to be distributed to each one, which strikes or idleness, whether voluntary or enforced by combinations, may and do aggravate, indeed, but cannot relieve. Exceptions aside, all kinds of business showed the loss, and failed of their wonted prosperity. It could not be otherwise, unless man has acquired the divine prerogative of making something out of nothing. It is inevitable, therefore, that, as a whole, the strikes of the present year should meet the fate of all strikes seeking to force up wages in the face of a falling market and a diminished demand for labor, or, what is the same thing, its products. In sporadic cases there may be success, which generally costs more than it comes to; but generally the failure is unmitigated and the loss irremediable, consequent on all combinations to force wages above the normal standard from which the inexorable laws of supply and demand will not and cannot long allow them to swerve.

3. A circumstance almost fatal to the recent striking movement in a great proportion of cases is the immense importation of foreign laborers seeking employment, tending much more to a glut than a scarcity in the labor market. In the face of such swarms of immigrant laborers, what is the use of attempting to force up wages above normal rates? I say nothing of the policy of stimulating immigration to the extent which is now done by various transportation companies, on sea and land, whose immediate interests are furthered by it. The logic of Chinese exclusion, if good for that, is good for a great deal more. This will be unavailing for its end, unless it goes the length of causing the exclusion of cheap labor from all quarters. Be this as it may, the swarms of Old-World laborers are upon us and crowding in more and more. They must be fed and clothed; and, if so, they must either have a chance to earn their living or be supported from the earnings or savings of others. In other words, they must be allowed, nay, compelled to work for such wages as they can get, and there is no help for it. What futility, then, for men to quit work and give up wages, when so many are eager to take their places!

One thing is certain. The loss from these strikes to the laborers who have sacrificed their wages and to those whose contributions have sustained them, meanwhile, has been immense—far greater than all the increase of wages demanded by them, if gained, can make good. It may be answered, at all events, they have had the satisfaction of injuring their employers. Quite likely. One who shoots a gun that kicks him over may or may not hit, wound, or kill the party aimed at. Sometimes he does the best thing possible for his employer’s interest. He relieves him of the need of further production when the markets are already glutted, and thus enables him to dispose safely of his accumulated surplus. Suppose he does hurt his employer. Cui bono? Suppose some loads of perishable food were lost by the railways. What is the effect, but to render such food dearer to the laborers, who most need to get it cheaply? At best, what is the effect, but to increase the risk and cost of production to employers, and thus to enhance the cost of the article to consumers, including laborers themselves?

No doubt employes can sometimes force a momentary rise of wages, by striking for higher prices when the delay of work to procure other laborers is ruin to their employers. If building laborers strike when the contract or the state of their employer is such that a month’s delay will ruin him; if harvest laborers strike for double wages in the face of a coming storm; if a surgeon, in the midst of a delicate operation, says, “I will leave it unfinished unless you double my pay,” they can, doubtless, extort it; but it is extortion, neither more nor less. It is sure to cost the extortioners too dearly. Their services will not be in demand. All productive occupations subject to such risks must provide for covering them in the price of their products; i. e., the increased cost of them to others, certainly to the laboring classes, who may need them.

Since the foregoing lines were written, a surprising illustration and confirmation of their truth has reached us. In the region of the great iron strike, at a moderate estimate, the loss in wages to the striking operatives has been fully $8,000,000; but there is one great iron mill in which, we learn from one of its proprietors, six hundred men have worked without cessation or loss of wages, in the midst of thousands of idle strikers. How and why is this? Because the workmen are non-union men. The proprietors years ago determined to employ none but non-union men, and at severe cost fought the battle of their independence through triumphantly, in the face of threats and prophecies that they would be compelled to succumb. They did not succumb; and they and their workmen have been reaping the advantages of this dearly-won independence ever since.—Prof. Lyman H. Atwater, D. D., LL. D., in Independent.