UNCLE JOE BARKER was a modest man. He never boasted that he had been in more than one naval conflict; but when he visited his sister Mary, her boys made him tell stories, until at last he fancied they were thinking quite too much of glory and too little of principle.
One night Ned said,
“Tell us of the worst fight you ever had, the one that used you up most completely.”
“Well, when I was seventeen years old—”
“You were not in the navy then?” put in Tom.
“In that year the battle was fought. I was at L——, and up to that year I had been the best mathematician in my class, but at last I had a rival, Howard by name. He was a snobbish, conceited fellow, clear-headed and cold-hearted. I detested him from the first; for if he ever gained the least advantage over me, he would sneer and take on great airs.
“At the end of a year we were contending for two prizes,—one for the best composition on a given subject, one for mathematical proficiency. I was confident I should get the first; for Howard’s essays were unequal, sometimes rather original, but lacking always in finish and delicacy. When, however, I came to hear his read, I could not doubt the result; it was better than mine. There were exceedingly effective points in it, ideas we wondered at, coming from him, and of course he received the prize with many compliments.
“It was a week before the other prize was to be given, and our rivalry became more earnest. This last was to be awarded after a new fashion that year. The mathematical class was to be thoroughly examined, and honor given to whom honor was due. Then, those who sustained certain exceptional tests were to have four problems given them to solve in the presence of a committee. The one who worked correctly and did the four the quickest, was to receive the prize.
“A few days before the trial, I found on the class-room floor a slip of paper covered with figures, the statement of a puzzling problem. The professor’s text-book was often full of such papers, and I did not once think of its being one of our four tests. I put it in my pocket, and, such things being always fascinating to me, I studied over it until I mastered it. I must have spent in all an hour on it, doing it at my ease as pleasant practice.
“About that time I was much disgusted to hear a schoolmate hint that Howard’s older brother, who was in a university, very likely did the best work on Howard’s essay for him. He said that when the subject was given Howard, he did not begin his essay until the day after a bulky paper came to him from his brother. I feared I had been cheated out of that prize, but there was no redress; to equalize matters I must gain the other.
“The day came. There were at first five of us competing; three were soon out, Howard and I being left. What was my surprise, then, to have given to us the very problem I had found and already studied out! I said to myself, ‘I will be fair; I will go about it as deliberately as if I were trying it for the first time, and must not make a mistake.’ I glanced up, Howard was working well, confidently, but he had to think, to choose between methods, while my brain work had been done before. I could show the whole problem, finished, in ten minutes, and explain the why and the wherefore. When I stopped work and smiled, Howard knew the prize was mine.
“The professor requested him to go on, and he finished it in twenty minutes—just twice as long as I had apparently been. Yet even in that time of silence and excitement, conscience kept whispering loudly, ‘You know you really took an hour, and he has not taken half that time.’ I answered that then I had no motive for rapidity, or I could well have done it faster. In the ability to do it was the proper test, and I was able. Conscience said, ‘No; the test is of the quickest thinker. Have you stood that test honestly?’
“‘Did Howard stand the essay test honestly?’ I answered. ‘This at the worst only makes us square.’
“The prizes were to be presented publicly that evening, but before I left the class room I was warmly congratulated, and saw Howard disappear full of rage.
“Well, boys, I went to my room, and then came this battle I tell you of. There was no cannon roar or streaming blood, but no conflict since ever cost me the struggle that one did. I wanted that prize beyond words to express. I firmly believed I might have earned it had things been otherwise. Ordinarily I thought as rapidly as Howard. The devil suggested that I had gained it honestly enough, all things considered; conscience said honesty was all there was to consider, and I had it not. The devil said, ‘How like a fool you will appear confessing! How Howard will triumph! He could not appreciate self-sacrifice.’ Conscience replied that that was no reason for my being deceitful. I said he was a cheat; conscience said I was likely to be another. On the ocean, boys, I never fought two foes at once. That day, on land, it was first a hand-to-hand fight with Joe and Satan, then a tough struggle with conscience.
“At last conscience won the day, and I said I would go and tell the professor the whole story. But in a minute we were all up and at it again, hot and heavy. ‘I hate that Howard; I will turn his triumph into humiliation, if I can get the matter of the essay sifted,’ said self. It was revenge, not justice, I then wanted; so conscience again conquered me, and I was prettyp. 678 well used up when I started out for my confession.”
“And you lost the prize after all?”
“Yes, Ned.”
“Howard got and kept both?”
“Yes.”
“So your battle was a regular defeat after all? How mean in him!” said Tom.
“I am not so sure of that; there are defeats and victories. Self and Satan defeated, means victory for truth and honor.”—Selected.