Early education led me to look with prejudice, not to say with contempt, upon all theories of Second Adventism. I imbibed the notion, from Sunday-school and pulpit and literature, that the incarnation and death of Christ was the last and supreme manifestation of God to men; that the gospel was the ultimate and final message of God to men; that the conversion of the world and the redemption of mankind were going steadily and surely, though very slowly, on from the birth of Christ as the starting point and under the influence of Christian ministration to their consummation. The notion that the gospel dispensation was preparatory to another, as the Old Testament had been preparatory to the gospel, that the manifestation of God in the man Christ Jesus was preparatory to another manifestation of God in kingly and triumphant form, as the manifestation of God in the law and the prophets had been preparatory to his manifestation in his Son, never dawned upon or at least never took lodgment in my mind.
In this spirit I arrived, in a course of systematic and careful study of the New Testament, at the twenty-fourth chapter of Matthew. Previous utterances of Christ had already somewhat shaken my preconceived theories. I had not gone far in the careful study of this chapter before I discovered that the interpretations of those commentators who deny the second coming were inconsistent with a reverent, unprejudiced, and impartial acceptance of Christ’s own words. The principles adopted by this interpretation, if applied to other portions of Scripture, will make the Bible mean anything which the Bible student desires it to mean. The whole chapter is reduced to a mere prophecy of the destruction of Jerusalem, and the admonition with which Christ closes his discourse, “What I say unto you I say unto all, Watch,” is absolutely eliminated from it, since no Christian since the close of the first century has had occasion to watch for that destruction. The sublime description of earth’s dying days is robbed of all its sublimity. “The sun shall be darkened, and the moon shall not give her light,” is made to mean, Those shall be dark days; “The stars shall fall from heaven and the powers of the heavens shall be shaken” is interpreted, The great empires of the world shall undergo disturbances; the appearing of the sign of the Son of man in heaven is reduced to a declaration that the sign shall appear testifying that the Son of man is in heaven; the mourning of all the tribes of earth is supposed to be fulfilled in the sorrow experienced by the inhabitants of Palestine at the appearance of the army of Titus; the sending of the angels with the sound of the trumpet becomes, Messengers shall call into the church the true disciples of Christ; and “from one end of heaven to the other” is reduced to, from Dan to Beersheba. I certainly do not mean to impugn the honesty of other interpreters in declaring that this principle of interpretation is not an honest one, and is the product of that vicious but, alas! common endeavor, not to read in the Scripture what it contains, but to read into the Scripture what the reader desires to find there. In further pursuing this study, I found, from parallel passages in the writings of the apostles, borrowing Christ’s phraseology here in describing pictorially the last Judgment, that they who heard him clearly understood him to refer to a future coming in pomp and power. I found that Christ himself employed almost identical language elsewhere under circumstances which forbade all doubt as to his meaning. I found the interpretation put upon this chapter, as the prophecy of the destruction of Jerusalem, unfulfilled by the events; the inhabitants of Palestine did not see in that destruction a sign that the Son of man was in heaven, but, on the other hand, remain unbelievers to this day. Christ did not gather his people into one church at that destruction; on the contrary, they were scattered to the four winds of heaven by the persecutions which followed. For myself, I am willing to leave unfulfilled prophecy without interpretation, and to say, frankly, I know notp. 597 what it means, but I am not willing to conceal my ignorance from my own consciousness by endeavoring to find the fulfillment in events which have already taken place, and which do not fulfill it, and for this purpose transform the sublime prophetic words of the Master into mere extravagances of language, calling them Orientalisms. Christ continually spoke in trope and metaphor, and the literalist always misapprehends him; but he spoke by trope and metaphor not that he might exaggerate the reality, but because the reality transcends all defining, and can only be suggested in poetic and pictorial forms.
I shall follow in this interpretation Matthew’s report of this discourse, which is fuller, and more orderly and systematic in its arrangement, than that of Mark.1
Christ has ended his public ministry as a teacher by his denunciations of the Pharisees; he has irreparably and forever broken with Judaism, and now only awaits the hour appointed for his sacrifice. We can never realize that death has marked our own beloved for its prey, even when the prophecy is written on the pale brow, the hectic cheek, the labored breath. The disciples could not believe that the death of their Messiah King was at hand. His prophecies passed with them for nothing. With pardonable Jewish pride, they pointed out to him the goodly proportions and the architectural glory of the marble temple which adorned the hill of Zion in Jerusalem. This should be, they thought, the center and heart of his kingdom. Christ sadly replied, endeavoring to prepare their hearts for the disappointment which was preparing for them, that all this glory should pass away, and not one stone be left upon another of this pride of Jerusalem. They were in too exalted a mood to catch the meaning or to accept the prophecy of gloom. To their thought, when the temple was destroyed nothing would remain worth living for, and time and the earth would come to their end. So thoroughly were the interests of mankind and the permanence of Judaism identified in their thought, that the end of one seemed to them of necessity contemporaneous with the end of the other. When they had gone out of the city, and were sitting on the Mount of Olives looking upon the setting sun and the burnished roofs and glittering spires of the Holy City, they asked him when this dread event should take place; when he would come into his kingdom, destroy Jerusalem, and bring the world to its end in the great consummation of the Judgment day. That he might make clear to them that these events were not contemporaneous, that the world should outlast Jerusalem, that a long period of sorrow and discipline must precede the era when the kingdoms of this world shall have become the kingdoms of our Lord and his Christ, this was the object of his prophetic discourse.
Do not think, he says in substance, that the end of Jerusalem is the end of the world. Before that end of the world, before I come to take possession of my kingdom, there must be a long period of deceit, false messiahs arising, wars and rumors of wars, famines and pestilences and earthquakes. These are but the beginning of that travail out of which the kingdom of God is to be born. This world-anguish is itself a prophecy of a birth of a kingdom of righteousness, of joy, and of peace. Verses 4–8. The church itself shall share in this labor pain. Four successive eras of trouble must it pass through. The Gentiles shall hate it and persecute it; the Romans shall burn its Bibles, imprison its disciples, or send them to the mines, or cast them to the wild beasts, or impale them upon lofty poles and pour oil or tar upon them, and light them, to be torches for the malignant on-lookers.2 Following this, Christians shall fall into enmities one with another. They shall hate one another and betray one another to death. The persecutions by the Roman Catholic Christian of his Protestant Christian brethren shall transcend the persecutions of Christians by the Gentiles; the fire and sword of Alva, the massacre of St. Bartholomew, the inquisition of Spain, shall exceed the cruelties of a Nero, a Caligula, a Diocletian. The age of persecution and internal conflict shall be followed by an age of skepticism and false doctrine. False teachers shall rise in the church itself, who, bearing the name of Christ, shall deny the truth of Christianity. The enemies of Christian truth shall be born within the Christian church, a Strauss, a Baur, a Kuenen. Every tenet of the Christian faith,—the inspiration of the Scriptures, the incarnation of the Son of God, the forgiveness of sins, the life everlasting, the living communion of God with his saints,—shall be questioned or denied by teachers of religion wearing Christian vestments and preaching from Christian pulpits. Last, and worst of all, iniquities shall abound, faith shall grow dim, love shall grow cold, the lines of demarkation between the church and the world shall seemingly be obliterated, and luxury shall enervate and selfishness and greed shall corrupt the church of God itself. Yet throughout all this long succession of persecutions and apostasies many shall endure faithful unto the end, and heralds shall be found who will go forth to proclaim the glad tidings of the kingdom for a witness in all pagan nations. Then, and not till then, shall the end draw near. Verses 9–14.
When, therefore, Christ continues, you see the Roman standards standing where they ought not, environing the Holy City, do not imagine that the time of my appearing is at hand, and a deliverance is near. Think not to remain housed and safe in the Holy City. Flee, and make haste in your flight. Come not down into the house to save your property, turn not back from the field to seek your garments; pray that winter may not impede and Sabbath days may not delay your escape. Think not that your Christ is coming then for your salvation; for there shall arise false Christs, and false prophets, who will lull you into security for your destruction. If they tell you he is in the desert, go not forth for him; if they say he is hidden in the city, believe it not; for the Son of man, when he does come again, will not come as now, unrecognized and unknown. His coming will be instant, and it will be known of all men. As the lightning flash runs from east to west, and every eye beholds it, so will be the second coming of the Son of man.3 Verses 15–27. This destruction of Jerusalem will not be the only calamity which will precede the final manifestation of the Son of God. For wherever corruption is, there God’s avenging ministers will make their appearance; wherever the carcass is, there will the eagles be gathered together.4 No period of peace or prosperity shall intervene between this long age of tribulation and the coming of the Son of man. No doubts shall be left in any minds whether he has come or not. Such signs and portents shall accompany his coming that not only his disciples shall welcome him, but his enemies shall behold him and shall mourn.5
No man shall know, no one therefore can foretell, the hour when the world’s history shall be consummated in the advent of its King. He shall come to an unexpected world as the flood came; he shall come a Judge and a King; and so close and searching shall be his judgment that those whose lives are most interwoven, the two laborers in the field, the two grinding at the mill, shall find themselves separated, the one taken and the other left. “Watch, therefore, for you know not what hour your Lord doth come.”—Lyman Abbott, in Christian Union.