AdventAI

Denominational Names.

By William H. Littlejohn

From Review and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 38., September 19, 1882

BY ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN.

Judging from the past, we may safely predict that the contest over the question of denominational names is far from being at an end. At the present time there are certain churches that seem to claim it as their especial mission to make war upon all sects that do not adopt Bible names exclusively. Prominent among these are the Disciples, so called. Their ministers never seem to grow weary of denouncing those who have adopted appellations not found in the Scriptures. Indeed, they employ language which would seem to indicate that such a course rendered it certain that those denominations that pursue it belong to the Babylon of the Apocalypse.

But let us reason a moment in regard to these criticisms. In the first place we suggest that the necessity for names originates in the existence of denominations. If there were no such divisions, there would be no need of distinctive titles. This being true, it is manifest that the surest method of disposing of church names will be found in the abolition of denominationalism. Are our Disciple friends ready for this? We reply, They are in the same sense in which every other denomination is ready for it; i. e., they are ready to have all other churches abandon their own denominations, and come and unite with them. In other words, they are just as zealous, in reality, for their own denominational existence as Baptists, Congregationalists, Methodists, Adventists, and others are for theirs. Were this not the case, they would not have increased the perplexity on this subject by creating an establishment of their own, and calling upon others to come and unite with them. Should it be replied that they do this in order to rescue their brethren of other churches from the errors into which they have fallen, and to lay a foundation for a union of all which will be both safe and Scriptural, we respond that such is the theory, at least, of all sectarians. They agree in desiring the union of all professing Christians, but hold that such a union must be based upon sound doctrine. In other words, that its foundation must be that of their own creed; for this, say they, is a creed which furnishes the best basis of union of any extant. Having adopted this conclusion, they, in common with the Disciples, try to draw all to themselves, hoping that ultimately that which appears to be disruption may prove to be union.

Let our Disciple friends reply (as certainly they will) that they have no creed, and, therefore, that our strictures are unjust; we answer, This is a mere play upon words. The term “creed” is from the Latin credo, meaning “I believe.” In its technical sense, it no doubt applies to a written document setting forth the tenets of any given denomination. Nice distinctions apart, however, our Disciple friends, practically speaking, have a creed as certainly as do others. For example, let a man apply for admission to their church who has never been immersed. The result will be that he will either submit to the administration of that ordinance, or else be rejected; i. e., his practice must, in this particular, conform to what the Disciples “believe,” or else he cannot become one of them. Should this fact be admitted, as surely it must, and should it be replied in extenuation that they only insist upon those points of faith which can be plainly read out of the Scriptures, we answer that this, again, is a play upon words. Pedobaptists do not see it in that light. They constitute, perhaps, the majority of the Christian believers, and they protest that they can find nothing in the Bible which makes immersion a prerequisite, either of salvation or of church-membership.

Thus it is made to appear that the whole matter turns upon the construction placed upon the Scriptures, and that the Disciples, as well as others, insist upon the right of defining what construction shall be put upon them, in the particular in question, by those who join their communion. What we have said about baptism would apply with equal force to the divinity of Christ and other cardinal doctrines of the Disciple faith. Hence it appears, after all, that the fundamental difference between our Disciple friends and others does not consist in the fact that one class has a creed and the other has not, but rather in the fact that the creed of the one is written, and that of the other unwritten. Practically, therefore, as remarked before, they are in agreement in regard to the necessity of some sort of creed. This being true, they are necessarily the advocates of denominational existence. But, as we have seen before, it is the existence of denominations which creates the necessity for church titles. I say necessity for church titles, for this seems to express the facts in the case.

To illustrate: There are, it is supposed, over six hundred different sects in the world. Now we submit that it would be not a little troublesome to find Bible appellations for all these. We submit, also, that it is really desirable, so long as these sects have a separate existence, that we should be able to distinguish them one from another. How, for example, in a great city, could a visitor, desiring to listen to the ministration of the word, on the Sunday, by those holding a faith in common with his own, do so, should all employ names which would apply equally well to every other denomination? In fact, how could any denominational work be accomplished at all, except through great perplexity, without denominational names? To the course pursued by our Disciple friends there are, it seems to us, serious objections. Their appropriation of so general a name as that of Disciple not only smacks a little of egotism, but actually does injustice to the rest of the Christian world, unless they can demonstrate either that they are the only disciples of our Lord, or else that in assuming the name “Disciple,” or “Christian,” they do not really arrogate to themselves, for denominational purposes and uses, an appellation which the Scriptures designedly apply to all who are the true followers of Christ.

Again, the course pursued works confusion. Observation will prove this to any one. In ordinary conversation, for example, if one should refer to the Christian Church, it is many times difficult to determine whether he means the church at large, or the Christian denomination in particular. To avoid the difficulty, individuals not infrequently resort to a device of elongating the first “i” in the word, or pronouncing it as though it were spelled Christ-ian, when it applies to the denomination in question. But no; this will not answer the case. Our friends, with a pertinacity which far excels their modesty, not infrequently protest, That is not our name; we are not Christ-ians, but Christians. The result will be that in process of time, from the indelicate appropriation to a denomination of that which applies properly to a whole class of religionists, the word will have to be surrendered in its general application to the particular use in question, or else its employment in both senses will prove a source of endless perplexity and misunderstanding.

That which has been remarked respecting the term “Christians” will apply equally well to that of Disciples, or, in fact, to any other Bible name of general application which is used without limiting words to designate any particular sect. Furthermore, there is another serious objection to the practice in question. There mayp. 594 be a decided choice in the Bible terms to be selected. There are but a very few which would be in a high degree appropriate or desirable. By arrogating these to themselves, those who do so debar others from the privilege who are equally entitled to it with them. In fine, it seems to us, to repeat what has already been said in substance, that it is a practice which is both immodest and unjust. To us it seems far more preferable to pursue the course which has been followed by the majority of denominations for ages; i. e., that of adopting some distinguishing title by which each one can immediately be recognized as the one to whom reference is made. Take, for example, the name Seventh-day Adventist. It expresses two prominent characteristics of the denomination that have adopted it as their appellation. First, it indicates, in the use of the word “seventh day,” that they are observers of the seventh day of the week as the Sabbath. Secondly, that they are Christians who believe in the near coming of the Lord; since, in common parlance, an Adventist is one who holds such a doctrine. If there be any objection to the title, it will be found in the fact that it is not more fully distinguishing than it is at present. Practically, however, so long as other denominations wear their distinctive appellations, it works well, as no one is left in doubt as to whom reference is made, whenever the people in question are referred to by the use of their proper denominational title.

In conclusion, we remark that in religion it is just as proper to use a little common sense as it is in matters of a worldly nature. As families multiplied in the past, it was found that great confusion was produced in the use simply of family names. To avoid this, Christian names were adopted. The result is that by adding to the family name of each individual an appropriate given name, we are able to distinguish them one from another, no matter how numerous their family connections may be. No sensible man objects to such a course. All recognize its necessity in law and equity, and its convenience even in ordinary conversation. Why not reason in the same manner in regard to denominational titles. Surely there can be no principle involved, so long as we retain, in common, the appellation of Christians, disciples of Christ, etc. This becomes manifest when we reflect that there is no specific provision on the subject in the Bible itself. Indeed, it is in the highest degree probable that the title of Christian, which we all at the present time love so much, was originally given in derision to the followers of Christ at Antioch; or at least that it was applied to them without divine authority.

The existence of sects is a misfortune, beyond doubt. It is a fact, however, and we must receive it as such. Nor is there any probability that these distinctions will ever cease to be while the world shall stand. In fine, with all the evils which they present, there is a condition of things which would be much worse. It is better by far that men should honestly differ in regard to important Bible doctrines, and advocate their own views zealously through their own peculiar organizations, than that, in order to bring about nominal union, they should do violence to their own convictions of duty or demoralize the community by publicly inculcating the view that it is unimportant what a man believes in other particulars, or what disposition he makes of the ordinances of the Lord’s house, provided only that he admits the divinity of the Lord Jesus Christ. We would rather a thousand times have matters remain as they are than to have such a condition of things created. We can respect men who honestly differ with us, and stoutly oppose us on points which to them are of cardinal importance, but we despise a man who places so low an estimate on truth and its intrinsic value that he is willing to sacrifice it to expediency. While we would have the denominations come as near to each other as they can by refusing to place stress on matters of minor importance, we would have them stand stiffly for everything which is essential in its character. Should it be suggested that our Disciple friends are acting upon that principle, we answer that such may be their intention on the whole, but that in the matter of names they, like those whom they condemn, are placing altogether too much stress on a matter which is inferior in importance, even to the smallest differences between those whom they denounce so unsparingly. The simple fact is, that the vast amount of talk which they expend upon this subject demands an outlay of strength and energy in no wise commensurate with the importance of the subject. Practically, men will follow in this matter the dictates of sound reason. While refusing to discriminate between written and unwritten creeds, they will also insist that it is both reasonable and in good taste to adopt names expressive of their peculiar faith.