AdventAI

Independent Responds to Christian Advocate on Dr. Storr's Woodstock Oration

From Review and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 38., September 19, 1882

In REVIEW of Aug. 8, in the article headed, “Signs of the Times,” we quoted from the Christian Advocate some remarks on Dr. Storr’s oration at Woodstock, Conn., July 4, in which [laughter] is inserted after several serious and startling statements. We think it no more than justice to the Independent that we publish its explanation. It would have appeared more promptly, but for the absence of the editor, who is now on the Pacific coast. The Independent says:—

The Christian Advocate, speaking of Dr. Storr’s oration at Woodstock, says: “The Independent, in its verbatim report of the address, introduces [laughter] when the decline of religion is spoken of; [laughter] when the loss of the sacredness of the marriage relation is referred to; [laughter] when the considerations that lead cool men to be apprehensive that ‘decadence and decline are not to be arrested in the moral life of the nation.’” Is that quite fair, brother editor? Are not these the words of an advocate, rather than of an impartial judge? It was not when “the decline of religion was spoken of” that the “laughter” came, but when it was said that Methodism had “become as sober, respectable, and almost as dull as the old standing order.” There was no laughter over the loss of the sacredness of the marriage relation, but at the intimation that such was the case only “among those living outside of your Connecticut.” There was no laughter over the apprehension that “decadence and decline are not to be arrested in the moral life of the nation,” though a laugh of incredulity might have well come from a serious man. That laugh was at the story of the Western engineer who resigned because there was nothing left of the railroad except a right of way and two streaks of rust. The criticism of the laughter falls not on the audience, but the speaker, and is justified against him only when some one shall arise who can forbid an orator ridentem dicere verum, to spice his speech with wit.