Drakeville, Nov. 8.—Closed meetings in the tent Nov. 5. The weather was favorable, so that with our large heater we were able to keep the tent comfortable to the close of our meeting.
Bro. McCoy was with me from Oct. 29 to Nov. 1. There was no public opposition to our views till one week before the meeting closed. A Disciple minister from an adjoining town preached two discourses on the Sabbath question, which were reviewed before a good audience in the tent. In the midst of this opposition, we were challenged to discuss the question. Bro. McCoy stated why we are opposed to set discussions, but also stated that we are always ready to defend the truth.
Two propositions were then presented from Eld. Hedrix of Fairfield, one of their champion debaters. These we could not accept, because they were so indefinite. The next day we were urged by a few of the citizens to write out such propositions as we would discuss. This we did, requiring Eld. H. to affirm what they as a people teach and practice; viz., that “the first day of the week is the Lord’s day since the resurrection of Christ, and is enjoined by Christ and his apostles to be observed as a day of religious worship, in breaking of bread, and in commemoration of the resurrection of Christ.” We would affirm the seventh day to be binding on Christians since the resurrection of Christ.
When these propositions were submitted to his people, they were very sure that Eld. H. would accept them, and accordingly sent him a dispatch to come at once. The next morning we received a line from Eld. H., requesting an interview at the hotel. We met the gentleman, but found him as unwilling to accept our propositions as we had been to accept his. The best he would do was to affirm his practice of keeping Sunday on the authority of apostolic example, and also the example of early Christians. He would not affirm that they had any precept, or that they had even the example of Christ for their practice, and claimed that they did not teach it. Here he contradicted his brother, who had just been laboring so hard to prove that Christ and his apostles taught, both by precept and example, the observance of the first day in honor of the resurrection.
Neither party was willing to modify their propositions, and so we parted, inviting Eld. H. to attend meeting at the tent in the evening. After the discourse in the evening, Bro. McCoy stated the reasons why we would have no debate; viz., that Eld. H. was unwilling to affirm what they as a people taught. Eld. H. replied to this statement in a half-hour’s speech, accusing us of dishonesty, and talking in a spirit to disgust even many of his own members. We then submitted the question of discussion to the audience, when only about a dozen, excluding the Disciples, manifested a willingness to accept Eld. H. as their representative man. This brought the Elder to his feet again. He said such an action was without precedent; that it was a work of demagoguery, and done to avoid discussion, etc. At this point the people manifested their lack of sympathy with the speaker by beginning to leave, and the meeting would soon have broken up in confusion had we not called to order and dismissed the audience.
So anxious was Eld. H. to debate, that he came over the next morning to see whether Bro. McCoy would not in some way modify his propositions; but Bro. M. told him it was no use to talk; that he would not now discuss with him under any considerations, because of the spirit he had manifested, and because the people would not indorse him. Here the Elder called Bro. M. a “soundrel;” and yet he claims to be a disciple of Christ, and to have the spirit of Christ.
The Elder, seeing a debate was out of the question, announced to speak in the Disciple church, meetings to continue over Sunday. He spent two evenings in discussing to his people (for but few others would go to hear him) the propositions he had sent us, and especially in denouncing Bro. McCoy. Our meetings continued each evening with a good attendance; and on Saturday evening, when Eld. H. took the train for home, because of the inclemency of the weather, we held meeting in the tent as usual. We have the sympathy of the best people in the community, and they commend the course we pursued to avoid discussion, though they were at first very anxious for the discussion.
We think this has been a perfect defeat to the Disciples, even more so than if we had gained a victory in discussion; for the Elder’s unwillingness to affirm their teaching and practices betrays a weakness in their position which some of the honest ones may now be able to discover.
We know not what will be the result of this eight weeks’ labor. Three or four are now keeping the Sabbath, and many good people are investigating. People seem desirous to know the truth, but they are slow to move.
We have rented rooms, and will remain for a time to carry forward the work here and in Bloomfield. Pray for the work here, that wisdom may be given to move aright.
IRA J. HANKINS.