Rapid Changes in Science.
The great leaders in science need to be modest in claiming that their propositions are absolutely true, and should be cautious in announcing that they have made a new discovery. Prof. Huxley gained for a season a brilliant reputation by announcing that he had discovered protoplasm to be the source of all organic life. But soon after, Dr. Lionel Beale, the great English microscopist, denied the truth of Prof. Huxley’s theory, and asserted that bioplasm must be put in the place of protoplasm. The eulogies over Mr. Darwin’s grave are yet fresh. They lifted him to a place among the immortals, for his wonderful discovery of progress in creation by the law of natural selection. But now comes a Mr. Towne, who has for years been studying with the best naturalists and biologists of Europe, and announces that life is not due to protoplasm, but to atomized charges of electricity conducted into the system by the oxygen of respiration. Variations, he says, are caused not by natural selection, but by the action of electricity on reproductive germs. Mr. Towne holds to the theory of evolution, but not to the form which gave a world-wide reputation to Mr. Darwin. The famous Prof. Helmholtz, one of the highest authorities in Europe, is said to agree with Mr. Towne. It may not be to the point to ask who shall decide when scientists disagree. But it is certainly pertinent to say that such disagreements should make philosophers modest and cautious.