AdventAI

MR. BEECHER’S LATEST SENSATION.

By C. C. Lewis

From Review and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 44., November 7, 1882

HIS WITHDRAWAL FROM THE CONGREGATIONAL ASSOCIATION.

BY C. C. LEWIS.

Mr. Beecher’s announcement at the opening of a regular meeting of the New York and Brooklyn Association of ministers and churches, held on Tuesday, Oct. 11, that he proposed to meet the representations and misrepresentations in respect to what he believed and taught, and to do so preliminary to withdrawing from the Association, was a matter of no small surprise to the threescore or more of ministers and delegates present. It had been announced that Mr. Beecher would speak upon the subject of “Spiritual Barbarism,” but nothing unusual was expected. Thus it happened that this important statement was made before less than a hundred of his brethren.

After dwelling for a time upon the topic assigned him, during which he expressed himself upon some points which he did not believe, Mr. Beecher spoke of his mode of preaching, his philosophy, personal experience, and early preaching, and then stated positively what he did believe.

He declared his belief in a Personal God, the Trinity, the Divinity of Christ, the Holy Spirit as one of the persons of the Godhead, the General and Special Providence of God, Miracles, the Sinfulness of Man and his Need of Regeneration, the Inspiration of the Bible, the Atonement through the sufferings and death of Christ, and Future Punishment. But he refuses to analyze the tri-personality of God, and leaves “any attempt to divide the functions—the Father to his function, the Son to another department, and the Holy Ghost to yet another function—to those who are better informed” than he is; he believes that Christ was God manifest in the flesh, but that he was limited by his human nature and human surroundings; he can pray to the Father only through Christ; he regards miracles in the light of God working through natural laws in a realm beyond our comprehension, not as suspensions or violations of law, and believes they are possible now; he believes in the universal sinfulness of man, but not in the doctrine of Total Depravity, and says, “There is not a man born that does not need to be born again, and it is a work as impossible to men as for a person to come suddenly to education, to knowledge simply by volition;” his view of Inspiration is that the writers of the book, not the book itself, were inspired, and that “the book is the record of that inspiration that has been taking place from generation to generation.”

It is difficult to see just what is meant by this statement, or to understand how the writers of a book could be inspired and not the book itself. Doubtless the meaning is that he does not believe in verbal inspiration. Concerning future punishment he holds that the Scriptures explicitly teach the consequences of sin in the future life “are so large, so dreadful, that every man ought to be deterred from venturing upon them,” but does not “think we are authorized by the Scriptures to say that it is endless in the sense in which we ordinarily employ that term.”

In taking leave of the Association Mr. Beecher said:—

“I have reason to believe that a great many of the brethren of the Congregational faith would speak more than disapproval, and that many even in the Association to which I belong feel as though they could not bear the burden of responsibility of being supposed to tolerate the views I have held and taught; and it is on this account that I as a man of honor and a Christian gentleman cannot afford to lay on anybody the responsibility of my views. . . . I, therefore, now, here, and in the greatest love and sympathy, lay down my membership of this Association and go forth—not to be separated from you. I will work for you, I will lecture for you, I will personally do everything I can for you. I am not going away from you in any spirit of disgust. I never was in warmer personal sympathy with every one of you than I am now; but I lay down the responsibility you have borne for me—I take it off from you and put it on myself. And now you can say: ‘He is a member of the Congregational Church, but he has relieved his brethren of all responsibility whatever for his teachings.’”

At the close of the address, a resolution was unanimously carried which contained the following sentences:—

“His full and proffered exposition of doctrinal views that he has made at this meeting indicates the propriety of his continued membership in this or any other Congregational Association. We hereby declare our desire that he may see his way clear to reconsider [his action] and withdraw it.”

Although this resolution was unanimously carried, the preceding debate showed considerable difference of opinion, some agreeing with Mr. Beecher throughout, others differing with him on one or more points.

By withdrawing from the New York and Brooklyn Association, Mr. Beecher does not thereby withdraw from the Congregational ministry. “The Congregational Association,” says the Christian Union, “is a purely voluntary society, composed sometimes of churches, sometimes of ministers, for mutual benefit, from which church or minister is always at liberty to withdraw when the benefit is not commensurate with the labor and responsibility.”

In this connection it will be interesting to note a few opinions of the New York press.

“To understand the exact meaning of his action, a chapter of history is necessary. The New York and Brooklyn Association is the regular Association duly represented in the State Association. Down to a few years ago it included all the Congregational churches and ministers of any importance in this part of the country. But for the express purpose of avoiding the necessity of being responsible for Mr. Beecher, and of meeting with him in the New York and Brooklyn Association, the Manhattan Association was formed, some of its members being governed mainly by the former object, but others avowedly by both. The Manhattan Association took nearly every person of weight and consequence of the Congregational body in New York and Brooklyn. The New York and Brooklyn Association was left a mere skeleton. Since their withdrawal, however, Mr. Beecher has been the principal figure in what was left. But when he published his article in the North American Review, it was too much for the few evangelical ministers remaining. One or two of them said that ‘there ought to be an investigation,’ and others threatened to take themselves and their churches out of the Association. These facts precipitated the action taken by Mr. Beecher. This is all it means. . . . Under all the circumstances, the withdrawal of Mr. Beecher, so far as his position and influence are concerned, is an event of no significance. . . . Where he will gravitate will depend probably upon the length of his life and the peculiar operations of his mind. It is useless to speculate upon these. . . . Meantime it behooves all Christians ‘to beware of his leaven.’”—Christian Advocate.

“Mr. Beecher’s statements of what he does believe will surprise some who have never credited him with holding to any orthodox doctrine at all—and there are such we know. . . . As to Christ, Mr. Beecher’s statement will certainly surprise many, and among these not a few of our Unitarian friends. ‘So literally do I believe Christ to be divine,’ says Mr. Beecher, ‘that I cannot really pray to any other being. I have sometimes tried to pray to the Father, but have always ended by addressing my prayer to Christ;’ and he added, ‘My faith is stronger in the divinity of Christ than words can express.’ . . . We only renew the expression of our opinion that Mr. Beecher’s action in withdrawing from an Association with many of whose theological tenets he is out of sympathy, does him great credit, and will both undoubtedly enhance him in the esteem of many while the effect upon the church will be beneficial.”—Christian at Work.

“It is to be feared that Mr. Beecher’s latest departure will swell the volume of that skepticism and negation and scoffing against religion of which we hear so much, rather than lead the way to better beliefs; that his eloquent denunciations of the old theology will be caught up and re-echoed everywhere in support of infidelity, while his modified orthodoxy will fall still-born; that his kicking against established religion will be imitated by the disciples of Ingersoll, while his eulogies of Christ fall on listless ears. Should such be the result of Mr. Beecher’s latest departure, it will be a cause for regret that he did not withdraw from the pulpit altogether.”—N. Y. Star.

“Non-theological readers certainly will be puzzled to see in this frank declaration of views any striking departure from the faith of the great body of Christians, except, perhaps, as respects the doctrine of future punishment; the resolutions of the Association passed after its delivery fairly express the sentiments of a much larger constituency. Future ages will be as puzzled to comprehend the reason for the obloquy with which the son is now assailed for defending evangelical truth by new lines of argument as this age is puzzled to account for the similar obloquy hurled at the father by the conservatives of his day for the same offense.”—Christian Union.

“Mr. Beecher’s withdrawal will not spread so much consternation among many Orthodox believers as the condition of things which his action has disclosed.”—N. Y. Tribune.

This is written with reference to the fact that many members of the Association fully sympathize with Mr. Beecher’s views.

It has been my purpose to give an impartial summary of Mr. Beecher’s views, drawn from the full report of his remarks, together with the opinions of leading papers, leaving each reader to make his own comments and draw his own conclusions. I close with a short extract from the Signs of the Times:—

“He says that the Old Testament writers constructed their conception of God from the example of their animal inclinations and appetites, and not from the example of their reason and moral sense. In short, he rejects the greater part of the Old Testament, as gross and barbarous. As a natural consequence, then, he must reject those New Testament writers who quote from the Old Testament. But Beecher’s infidelity is no new thing. It has been for a long time very thinly disguised. The worst of the matter is that the Association passed a resolution the next day asking him to reconsider his action inp. 693 withdrawing from their body, and expressing concurrence in his belief. To put the matter plainly, they expressly assured him that they believe as little of the Bible as he does.”