HERBERT SPENCER ON AMERICA

9%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 7, 1882

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 44.

Read the full edition

HERBERT SPENCER ON AMERICA.

In an interview with a reporter, Mr. Spencer, the English philosopher, who is now traveling in this country, has given some very interesting criticisms on the problem of American social and political life. Coming from an observer so thoughtful and candid, his views are worthy of consideration. We quote from the report of this interview as published in the Christian Union, first giving a few sentences from the Christian Union’s editorial notice of the article:—
“The emphasis which Mr. Spencer lays on the danger from political indifference and easy good nature among citizens, and machine manipulation by professional politicians, is all the more worthy of public attention that it cannot be suspected of being uttered in the interest of any party or faction. The most significant of his remarks, however, in our judgment, are those upon education. He cannot be suspected of speaking in the interest of any form of ecclesiasticism; and he points out very clearly, as many Americans have done before him, that the education which contents itself with merely developing the intellectual faculties, will not save the nation from demoralization; it changes the nature of the crimes against the community, but does not decrease them, perhaps even adds to their magnitude.”
“Beyond a question, in respect of all mechanical appliances, the Americans are ahead of all other nations. If, along with your material progress, there went equal progress of a higher kind, there would remain nothing to be wished.” But the present condition of America recalls to his mind the Italian republics of the Middle Ages, in which, “while there grew up a great commercial activity and a development of the arts which made them the envy of Europe, and a building of princely mansions which continue to be the admiration of travelers, their people were gradually losing their freedom.”
“Do you mean this as a suggestion that we are doing the like?”
“It seems to me that you are. You retain the forms of freedom, but, so far as I can gather, there has been a considerable loss of the substance. It is true that those who rule you do not do it by means of retainers armed with swords; but they do it through regiments of men armed with voting-papers, who obey the word of command as loyally as did the dependents of the old feudal nobles, and who thus enable their leaders to override the general will, and make the community submit to their exactions as effectually as did their prototypes of old. It is doubtless true that each of your citizens votes for the candidate he chooses for this or that office, from president downward, but his hand is guided by a power behind, which leaves him scarcely any choice. ‘Use your political power as we tell you, or else throw it away,’ is the alternative offered to the citizen. The political machinery, as it is now worked, has little resemblance to that contemplated at the outset of your political life. Manifestly, those who framed your Constitution never dreamed that twenty thousand citizens would go to the poll led by a ‘boss.’ America exemplifies, at the other end of the social scale, a change analogous to that which has taken place under sundry despotisms. You know that in Japan, before the recent revolution, the divine ruler, the Mikado, nominally supreme, was practically a puppet in the hands of his chief minister, the Shogun. Here it seems to me that the ‘sovereign people’ is fast becoming a puppet which moves and speaks as wire-pullers determine.”
“Thirty years ago, when often discussing politics with an English friend, and defending republican institutions, as I always have done, and do still; and when he urged against me the ill-working of such institutions over here, I habitually replied that the Americans got their form of government by a happy accident, not by normal progress, and that they would have to go back before they could go forward. What has since happened seems to me to have justified that view; and what I see now confirms me in it. America is showing on a larger scale now than ever before that ‘paper constitutions’ will not work as they are intended to work; the truth, first recognized by Macintosh, that ‘constitutions are not made, but grow.’”
“But will not education and the diffusion of political knowledge fit men for free institutions?”
“No; it is essentially a question of character, and only in a secondary degree a question of knowledge. But for the universal delusion about education as a panacea for political evils, this would have been made sufficiently clear by the evidence daily disclosed in your papers. Are not the men who officer and control your Federal, State, and municipal organizations,—who manipulate your caucuses and conventions, and run your partisan campaigns—all educated men? And has their education prevented them from engaging in, or permitting, or condoning, the briberies, lobbying, and other corrupt methods which vitiate the actions of your administrations? Perhaps party newspapers exaggerate these things; but what am I to make of the testimony of your civil-service reformers—men of all parties? If I understand the matter aright, they are attacking, as vicious and dangerous, a system which has grown up under the natural spontaneous working of your free institutions—are exposing vices which education has proved powerless to prevent. . . . Not lack of information, but lack of certain moral sentiments, is the root of the evil.”
* * * *
“No one can form anything more than vague and general conclusions respecting your future. The factors are too numerous, too vast, too far beyond measure in their quantities and intensities. The world has never before seen social phenomena at all comparable with those presented in the United States. A society spreading over enormous tracts, while still preserving its political continuity, is a new thing. This progressive incorporation of vast bodies of immigrants of various bloods has never occurred on such a scale before. Large empires, composed of different peoples, have, in previous cases, been formed by conquest and annexation. Then your immense plexus of railways and telegraphs tends to consolidate this vast aggregate of States in a way that no such aggregate has ever before been consolidated. And there are many minor co-operating causes unlike those hitherto known. No one can say how it is all going to work out. That there will come hereafter troubles of various kinds, and very grave ones, seems highly probable; but all nations have had, and will have, their troubles.”