WE CANNOT TELL

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 28, 1882

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 47.

Read the full edition

“WE CANNOT TELL.”

THESE are not the words of Christ nor of his apostles, but the words of those who rejected him, and could give no good reason for their unbelief. Therefore when a plain promise of Scripture and its fulfillment was propounded for their decision, for or against, they took the most uncomfortable, miserable position possible,—We cannot tell; in other words, the truth being too plain to be denied, and they too proud and stubborn to confess it, they chose to take no position for or against it.
The people of those times must have known that the sixty-nine weeks of Daniel’s prophecy, which were to reach to the Messiah, had expired, and consequently they were “in expectation” of his appearing. (See Luke 3:15.) They knew also that the Scriptures promised a harbinger of the Messiah, a “messenger” sent before his face,—“the voice of one crying in the wilderness, Prepare ye the way of the Lord;” for the scribes objected “that Elias must first come.” (See Matt. 17:10.) But the chief priests and elders of the people did not choose to admit that Jesus was the Christ, which they must admit, if they credited John’s mission. John had testified of Jesus as the Lamb of God; and admitting that this testimony was a Heaven-sent message, they could themselves easily read the answer to the question which they had asked,—“By what authority doest thou these things?”
The can’t-tell position is a most miserable one to occupy, and yet many hold it year in and year out. My present design is to say something that will help some unfortunate ones out of it. It is not necessary to remain in this position. Matters of truth and duty can be decided. The reason why people get into such an uncomfortable position is because conviction and inclination do not harmonize. There are plainly revealed truth and duty on the one hand, and custom, inclination, and convenience on the other. If men would exercise their reason, they would discern that convictions which call for a change involving self-denial, sacrifice, and cross-bearing, do not come when there is no good cause for them. The safe way is to follow the convictions awakened by the word of God.
To make my meaning clear let me illustrate it. I have been acquainted from my youthful days to the present with two classes of people, one keeping the first, the other the seventh day of the week as the Sabbath; and I have known of many changes of individuals both ways. But I have never known a case where one who kept the seventh day labored under the conviction for days and weeks and months that he ought to keep the first day in order to be approved of God. Their reason for the change was custom and convenience invariably; and their inclination for popularity, position, and worldly gain was so strong that they persuaded themselves that perhaps God would not condemn them under such trying circumstances. On the other hand, I have known first-day keepers convicted of duty to keep the seventh day, and have seen them go halting between two opinions for years and years, before they could decide the question; and sometimes they came out on one side, and sometimes on the other. Now all this doubt and perplexity was entirely unnecessary. Convictions that we are wrong and ought to change do not come without the best of reasons.
It is a question of surpassing interest and importance whether the movement now in progress as the fulfillment of the predicted proclamation of the third angel (Rev. 14:9-12) is from Heaven or of men. Many are convicted that the time is come, and that the Lord is redeeming his promise by causing the present movement throughout the world. The evidences which prove this work to be Heaven-sent are precisely similar to those which sustained the mission of John the Baptist,—a promise of God in prophecy, and its plain and obvious fulfillment.
The commandments of this message are none other than the commandments of God, and its faith is that of Jesus Christ. Its object is to develop the remnant of the church and prepare them for translation at the coming of the Lord. The dragon wages his last war against this last remnant of the church, because they “keep the commandments of God, and have the testimony of Jesus Christ.” “The testimony of Jesus is the spirit of prophecy.” This “testimony” appears in the fulfillment of the last message. Whether it is from Heaven or of men is what some “cannot tell.” The evidences in its favor are too strong to be decidedly rejected, and yet some hidden motive prevents a cordial reception, and a decided position in its favor. Perhaps it is because it strikes against some favorite sinful indulgence.
An unhappy indecision is not necessary on this point. The conviction that we ought to yield to these reproofs, counsels, and entreaties, which are in harmony with all the messages of the ancient prophets, should be accepted as coming from Heaven and pointing out the path of duty. There is freedom and joy in venturing to take a decided position in the way of faith and duty. Try it, my friends. The convictions that stand opposed to self-love and worldly inclination, are right in this case, and safe to follow. R. F. COTTRELL.