At a dinner given just before he sailed for England, Herbert Spencer criticised in no sparing terms the American tendency to overwork. Among his utterances were these words: “I should have liked to contend that life is not for learning, nor is life for working; but working and learning are for life.” His criticisms call out the following excellent remarks from the Independent:—
What is the ideal of life is quite as much a question of Christianity as of philosophy, and we are interested to see how Mr. Spencer’s answer corresponds with that of Jesus Christ. Mr. Spencer’s answer seems to be that the chief end of man is complete life; that working is for living, labor for relaxation; that “living completely,” with an “adjustment of labor and enjoyment,” and with “an increasing surplus of energies that are not absorbed in fulfilling material needs,” and that may be devoted to a man’s “living completely,”—that this is the true ideal of life. In short, if we understand his not very clear statement, man’s chief end is to make himself as complete, as beautiful, and as happy as he can.
Christ’s ideal, Paul’s ideal, the universal Christian ideal, absolutely contradicts this definition. What Jesus gives as the chief commandment has passed into the conscience of Christendom. It is supreme love and service to God, and love and service to fellow-men as hearty as we give to ourselves. That is not Spencerism. Paul says: “None of us liveth to himself and no man dieth to himself;” but Spencer says the contrary. For our part, give us the old Christian philosophy, which recognizes selfishness, no matter how refined, as the condition of our sinful nature, which needs to be renewed by conversion. And that conversion is the rejection by the will of this principle that we are our own chief end, that labor is for relaxation, that working is for living, and the hearty acceptance of the great and holy principle of consecration, that we are not our own, and, therefore, we will glorify God, in work or patience, with our bodies and our spirits, which are his. Living is for work; not selfish work, but helpful work, in imitation of Him who “pleased not himself,” but “went about doing good,” and who has taught the world the unwilling lesson, which philosophers also may well learn of the Peasant who walked among the lilies of Galilee, that the sweetest bliss comes not to him who seeks it for himself, but to him who forgets himself in seeking the good of others. He that would save his life shall lose it; he that is willing to lose it shall save it.