Under the above caption the Christian at Work answers a correspondent, who asks “very earnestly” for an explanation of 1 Sam. 28:7-20, where the witch of Endor holds a séance with Saul, and gives him a communication purporting to come from the prophet Samuel. Its repudiation of the mediumistic view, that the spirit of Samuel actually appeared, is so pronounced, and so far confirmatory of the position held by Seventh-day Adventists, that we cannot forbear quoting it:—
“The modern spiritualist claims it as affording Scriptural proof of a genuine séance. The witch was a first-class medium; the spirit of Samuel actually and truly appeared, revealing himself clothed in his former earthly form and mantle, and foretelling by supernatural voice the fate about to fall upon the unhappy king. The reality of Samuel’s appearance is also held by Vilmer, by Erdmann, and many English expositors. This view we utterly reject. It is anti-scriptural. God, by the mouth of Job, expressly assures us: ‘He that goeth down to the grave shall come up no more,’ and accordingly David, upon the death of his child, cried out: ‘I shall go to him, but he shall not return to me.’ It is also against common sense. The idea that the pure and blessed spirit of Samuel in the other world should be obedient to the beck and call of a witch—an old hag—in this world, is simply preposterous. Besides, the whole transaction was one of sin and guilt, which could never have been countenanced by Samuel’s sinless presence and participation. The witch was a sorceress, condemned as such by divine law; Saul, acting under this law, had slain all such false prophets save this one, who had escaped his vigilance; and now with glaring inconsistency and superstition, but driven by his crimes, he seeks in guilty disguise to consult the forbidden ‘familiar spirit.’ The real Samuel would never have come back to encourage such iniquity.”
The editor also cites what he is pleased to call “the more common interpretation,” viz., that Satan personified Samuel, giving in support of this view the testimony of Luther, Calvin, Grotius, and Henry, but objecting to it on the ground that the message was too truthful to come from Satan, containing, as it did, “a withering rebuke for his sin, and a prediction of disasters and woes about to fall as a punishment for his sin.”
While it is true that this is not Satan’s usual course in dealing with his subjects, is it not reasonable to believe that he would depart from his custom in this case, in order to make a complete personation? Had it been possible for Samuel to appear, that was just the nature of the message he might have been expected to give; and as Satan doubtless knew of the fate which awaited Saul, he risked nothing in predicting his downfall, althoughp. 762 he did make a mistake in the time of the event, as shown by the subsequent history.
If Satan succeeds in transforming himself into an angel of light, he must not only look like one but must talk like one as well; and if he would successfully personate Samuel, the resemblance must not only be in the fact of an old man with a mantle, but in the words he might be supposed to utter.
Satan’s success in personating dead men was not confined to that case, but has been repeated again and again, until the monstrous delusion of modern spiritualism has fastened itself upon the minds of the people in every land, with a grasp like that of death itself, and which can be loosened only by the power of divine truth. W. C. G.