The Great Catholic Debt

25%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Dec 12, 1882

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 59, No. 49.

Read the full edition

The Great Catholic Debt.

The great Catholic debt of the Archbishop of Cincinnati has become the great Catholic scandal. The $4,000,000 which confiding depositors placed in the hands of the Archbishop and his brother, the Vicar-General, for safe keeping, was expended for the benefit of the church. With it school-houses, churches, orphan asylums, a library, a theological seminary, were provided, and candidates for the priesthood were fed, clothed, and educated. If the money was the Archbishop’s, it was wisely administered. But as it was not the Archbishop’s, as he was only a banker for poor Catholics, who trusted him because they believed their money was safer with him than in savings banks, such appropriation was misappropriation, differing from embezzlement only, if at all, in the lack of criminal intent and purpose of personal profit. Most of this enormous sum of money was invested in property in the Archdiocese of Cincinnati, the title of which the Archbishop held. Both he and his brother turned all their real and personal property over to an assignee, for the benefit of their creditors. The sale of this property would have involved the loss of many churches and other buildings into which the money had been put; but the depositors would have received their own again. Bishop Elder, the administrator of the archdiocese, came forward, however, to oppose this step, and raised $40,000 to contest the matter in the courts. No decision has yet been rendered, and perhaps years may elapse before the final decision is secured from the court of last resort. Meantime, the creditors have not even promises to sustain their patience. The money which was raised by the general appeal to the Catholics of the United States is in the hands of Vicar-General Quinn, of New York, and Archbishop Williams, of Boston, and those who are waiting for some portion of their deposits have not even the poor satisfaction of knowing how large the sum is. Furthermore, there seems to be some doubt as to whether any of the 25,000 sufferers will receive a dollar of it.
It is not strange, under all these circumstances, that some of the creditors should become impatient and even indignant. A protest of terrible severity has been published in Cleveland, and another letter sent to the pope. The protest accuses Bishop Elder and his advisers of an intention to repudiate the entire debt, and applies to them the epithet “repudiating priests.” This epithet they do not reject; instead, they adopt it and declare in their answer, signed “Repudiating Priests,” that the debt is not a Catholic debt, and Vicar-General Purcell was alone responsible for it. It is refreshing, in the face of such a lack of moral sense, such indifference to the rights of the robbed and to the good name of the church, to find such frank, manly words of deprecation and indignation as the Catholic Telegraph pours out in its last issue. The Telegraph has lately passed into new editorial hands; but still bears the declaration of Archbishop Purcell that it is “our official organ.” In righteous anger it spurns all proposals of repudiation, of prevarication.
If such words as these do not stir a response in the Archdiocese of Cincinnati and in every other diocese of the United States; if priests and people who worship in the Cathedral and other churches built by the hard earnings wrenched from the depositors, do not feel the tinglings of shame when they bow in prayer; if those charged with the administration of the archdiocese do not show any sensitiveness to such goadings; if no further efforts are made to do justice to the wronged depositors—then the world must conclude that the Catholic sense of honor and moral obligation has become benumbed to the point of utter insensibility and death.—The Independent.