AdventAI

OPTIONAL SABBATH-KEEPING.

By Wm. Penniman

From Review and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 40., October 7, 1884

BY WM. PENNIMAN.

“One man esteemeth one day above another: another esteemeth every day alike. Let every man be fully persuaded in his own mind.” Rom. 14 : 5.

Dr. Adam Clarke comments as follows upon this text:—

“Perhaps the word ἡμέραν, day, is here taken for time, festival, and such like, in which sense it is frequently used. Reference is made here to the Jewish institutions, and especially their festivals, such as the passover, Pentecost, feast of tabernacles, new moon, jubilee, etc. The converted Jew still thought these of moral obligation; the Gentile Christian, not having been brought up in this way, had no such prejudices. And as those who were the instruments in bringing him to the knowledge of God gave him no such injunctions, consequently he paid to these no religious regard.”

“Another] The converted Gentile esteemeth every day—considers that all time is the Lord’s, and that each day should be devoted to the glory of God, and that these festivals are not binding on him. We add here alike, and make the text say what I am sure was never intended; viz., that there is no distinction of days, not even of the Sabbath; and that every Christian is at liberty to consider even this day to be holy or not holy, as he happens to be persuaded in his own mind. . . . The word alike should not be added, nor is it acknowledged by any MS. or ancient versions.”

“Let every man be fully persuaded] With respect to the propriety or non-propriety of keeping the above festivals, let every man act from the plenary conviction of his own mind. There is a sufficient latitude allowed; all may be fully satisfied.”

As the context, or 6th verse, is so closely allied to the 5th in meaning, we will give the comments upon it:—

“He that regardeth the day] A beautiful apology for mistaken sincerity, and injudicious reformation. Do not condemn the man for what is indifferent in itself; if he keep these festivals, his purpose is to honor God by the religious observance of them. On the other hand, he who finds that he cannot observe them in honor of God, not believing that God has enjoined them, does not observe them at all. In like manner, he that eateth any creature of God, which is wholesome and proper food, gives thanks to God as the author of all good. And he who cannot eat of all indiscriminately, but is regulated by the precepts in the Mosaic law relative to the clean and unclean meats, also gives God thanks. Both are sincere; both upright; both act according to their light; God accepts both; and they should bear with each other.”

We have quoted nearly all of Dr. Clarke’s comments on this text, as they are so much to the point. We infer from the following that he thought that the text has no allusion to the Sabbath: The word “alike [not in the original] makes the text say what was never intended; viz., that there is no distinction of days, not even of the Sabbath.” If the reader will read carefully the whole chapter, he will see that Paul has reference to festival days enjoined in the ceremonial law, and also to the customs of both Jews and Gentiles in using different kinds of food, which are of minor importance, and not to the moral precepts enjoined by the law.

We also quote briefly from Mr. Barnes’ notes on this text:—

“The discussion had reference only to the peculiar customs of the Jews, and the rites and practices which they would attempt to impose on the Gentiles, and not to any questions which might arise among Christians as Christians. The inquiry pertained to meats and festival observances among the Jews, and to their scruples about partaking of food offered to idols, etc., and there is no more propriety in supposing that the subject of the Lord’s day is introduced here than that he advanced principles respecting baptism or the Lord’s supper.”

According to the preceding, Mr. Barnes did not seem to think that the Lord’s day, or Sunday, was alluded to in this text; then certainly the Sabbath is not. This admission of Mr. Barnes is also good evidence that the Gentile Christians did not then keep any other day for the Sabbath but the one the Jews kept; for if they did, how natural would be this discussion in regard to the two days; the controversy then would have been between the seventh day and first day, and they would no doubt have been definitely mentioned. This, then, is a good argument in favor of the Sabbath. Again, this same commentator very truthfully says: “If any man is disposed to plead this passage as an excuse for violating the Sabbath, and devoting it to pleasure or gain, let him quote it just as it is; i.e., let him neglect the Sabbath from a conscientious desire to honor Jesus Christ.” Again, “Let every man, etc., . . . This direction does not refer to subjects that were morally wrong, but to ceremonial observances.”

How often do we hear the text quoted, “One man esteemeth one day above another,” etc., just as though it made no difference which day a man keeps, only so that he is fully persuaded, or thinks it all right. There is no question about man’s free moral agency; but this text, according to some men’s theology, gives his agency a very wide latitude, as this wonderfully liberal text gives a man liberty to do just as he pleases in regard to keeping days, etc. Admitting that this text relates to the Sabbath, and that different days are kept by different people, and that every one of the days of week are observed by different nations as the Sabbath,—in this way, therefore, all are right. Again, an every-day-Sabbath man says, “The text makes me right also, for it says, ‘another esteemeth every day’ [as sacred].” This very liberal text, then, makes all right, including any-day, every-day, and no-day Sabbath men. Carry out this position in regard to the ordinances, and see where it will lead. One man esteemeth feet-washing and the Lord’s supper necessary, another does not. One esteemeth sprinkling as baptism, another pouring, another immersion. “Let every man be fully persuaded,” etc. The truth is, this liberal text has reference only to non-essentials, and not to fixed moral principles. Away, then, with quibbling, and let the truth stand as it is.