AdventAI

“RECENT MOVEMENTS REGARDING SUNDAY OBSERVANCE.”

By Editor

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 2., January 13, 1885

Under this heading the New York Independent of Jan. 8, 1885, in its Religious Intelligence department, gives a candid and comprehensive view of the present condition of the Sunday question throughout all Christendom. In a condensed presentation of its facts, our readers will be interested.

The contest over the “Sunday question,” it says, still continues both in this country and in Europe. In Great Britain the old Puritan ideas are in the ascendant, and in Scotland Sunday is strictly observed. Opposition under Prof. Blackie, heading a small party in Scotland, is making no apparent progress; neither in England, though the movement there is stronger. All motions in Parliament for Sunday opening of museums and galleries, have been defeated. Petitions for the opening do not come from the workingmen, but from their friends in their behalf. The workingmen fear that if Sunday loses its old character, Sunday toil will soon take its place; and they prefer to forego the privilege of visiting museums and entertainments, for the sake of retaining their period of rest. In the last vote on the question in Parliament, taken last March, the proposal was defeated by a vote of 46 to 38. While on the other hand the Irish Sunday Closing Act strengthens the defenses of the day.

Turning to the continent of Europe, the current seems to be in the direction of stricter Sunday rest. A movement among the Roman Catholics of France, for better Sunday observance, started some years ago by Count de Cissy, received the cordial support of Pius IX., and has the earnest sanction of Leo XIII. It has secured the closing of many shops, stores, and factories on Sunday, and is still making progress. The social democrats of Germany and France make the demand for Sunday rest a part of their platform. In Switzerland and Italy there are popular movements and efforts in legislative bodies in behalf of Sunday as a day of rest. Atheists, even, favor cessation from labor, while the churches plead for its religious character.

Coming to our own country, we find that the secularization of Sunday has made more progress, though we may add that there has also arisen within a few years, a more wide-spread and determined effort in behalf of a religious observance of the day. Railroads and steamboats do more Sunday business than they did a few years ago; Sunday newspapers have increased, and Sunday exhibitions have been opened; while it may be regarded as a significant fact that the opening of the exhibition for the Bartholdi Fund on Sunday was considered a losing affair, as it alienated the sympathy of many wealthy and liberal persons. But Sunday afternoon concerts by Theodore Thomas have been commenced in New York for the benefit of the working people. There was music in the park at the expense of the city for the first time on Sunday last summer, which gives an advantage to those who will propose its renewal when warm weather returns; and in stricter religious circles many Sunday usages are tolerated and even participated in which would not have been countenanced a moment a generation ago. But the New York Sabbath Committee, organized twenty-five years ago have greatly held in check the influences which were tending to destroy the day; and it is claimed to be owing chiefly to their labors that New York is now one of the quietest cities on Sunday in this country. The late Catholic Council at Baltimore has put forth in a Pastoral letter, it is said, some of the strongest utterances issued for a long while in behalf of the religious observance of Sunday. The Independent says: “The day still commands the regard of the people of our land, and they are ready to rise in its defense,” and “those who would make the American Sunday a day of secular business and amusement are not by any means going to have everything their own way.”

The same number of the Independent contains an editorial on “Roman Catholics and Sunday Observance.” The circumstances on which it comments in this article are these: A Catholic writing from New Orleans condemned as a breach of Sunday sanctity the opening of the great Exposition in that city on that day; whereupon the Freeman’s Journal (Catholic) says that that writer “ought to know better,” and in a long article headed “Shall we Please the Puritans,” denounces those Catholics who contend for a strictly religious Sunday—laments that “Christian ladies well instructed in the faith will refuse to knit and sew on Sunday”—calls it a mask of hypocrisy put on to please Puritanical persons around them—declares it silly for Catholics to accept it—and says that there is no danger of a so-called “Continental Sabbath” here, and that there is no such thing anywhere.

The Independent reminds the Journal that the dignitaries of the whole “Roman American Church” recently assembled in Plenary Council at Baltimore thought differently, and published a Pastoral, than which there has not for a long time “been issued a stronger utterance in favor of the ‘Puritan’ Sunday,” and adds that “the New York Sabbath Committee could hardly do a better thing than to reprint for general circulation that eloquent and able section of the Pastoral which treats of Sunday observance.” The Independent closes its article with these words:—

“Can it be that while the Independent has been speaking in the highest commendation of the Pastoral as a document which will command the respect of Protestants as well as Romanists, the Journal has been preparing to open a fusillade of indirect criticism on the highest officials of its own communion? For our own part we rejoice to know that there is a ‘Puritan’ element in the Roman Catholic Church of the United States, an element that favors total abstinence and Sunday quiet and other matters of Christian sobriety. To the New Orleans writer and the ‘Christian ladies’ and the fathers of the Pastoral we extend our Christian salutations; and, pending the settlement of the questions which have separated Protestants from Catholics for centuries, let us stand together in condemnation of Sunday dissipation and other such evils, whether those who practice them disgrace the Catholic or the Protestant name.”

These words are wonderfully significant as showing the attitude which Protestants are assuming toward Romanism and its work. So it seems that the questions which have separated Protestants and Catholics for centuries are to be “settled”? How?—Not by any concessions on the part of the Catholics, we may be sure, but, if settled at all, only by a dastardly surrender on the part of Protestants of the principles of their once glorious Reformation.

But, strange to say, the Independent in enumerating the forces which are marshaling in favor of stricter Sunday observance, makes no mention of the “National Reform Association” as a factor in this work, though it has attained such proportions and is exerting so wide-spread an influence in favor of Sunday, though not making that ostensibly its leading object.

This is altogether a remarkable showing; and they who think that this agitation is destined to die away, and prophecy not receive its fulfillment in regard to this matter, should see enough in these facts to undeceive them.