THE RELATION OF SPIRITISM TO THE FALL OF THE CHURCHES DISCUSSED STILL FURTHER; THE GROWING FRIENDSHIP BETWEEN PROTESTANTISM AND CATHOLICISM CONSIDERED.
BY ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
Mr. Biblist.—When we closed our last interview, modern Spiritism in its relation to the fall of the churches was under discussion. I had assumed that ancient necromancy was wrong, because it is nothing more nor less than intercourse with Satan and his host. That point once proved, modern Spiritism is condemned for the same reason; since it is claimed by the spirits themselves, as well as by the friends of Spiritism generally, that the ancient and the modern communications are from the same source. A single pointed testimony will be sufficient to prove that my assumption respecting the true nature of the old time sorcery was justified by the facts. If you please, Maud, you may read 1 Cor. 10: 20.
Maud.—“But I say that the things which the Gentiles sacrifice, they sacrifice to devils, and not to God; and I would not that ye should have fellowship with devils.”
Mr. B.—That you may be assured that I was right also in attributing Saul’s death to the judgment of the Most High, brought upon him for the terrible sin of consulting a witch, or female spirit medium, I will read 1 Chron. 10: 13: “So Saul died for his transgression which he committed against the Lord, even against the word of the Lord, which he kept not, and also for asking counsel of one that had a familiar spirit, to inquire of it.”
One more text, and I must leave this branch of the subject. It will not be disputed that in Bible language a sorcerer is one who pretends to communicate with the dead. In Rev. 22: 15 the fate of that class of individuals is depicted. In the previous chapter the Revelator describes a glorious city with streets of gold, walls of jasper, and gates of pearl. That city, as we learn from Rev. 22: 14, is to be the future eternal abode of the redeemed. Through its sacred portals no sorcerer will ever pass. I read the 15th verse of chap. 22: “For without [without the city] are dogs, and sorcerers, and whoremongers, and murderers, and idolaters, and whosoever loveth and maketh a lie.” A terrible concourse that; and yet it embraces sorcerers, a class now tolerated in very many of the churches of Christendom. I pass with the single reflection that something must be greatly out of joint somewhere, when the gates of heaven are bolted against a whole order of persons who are retained in the church on the earth.
The wise man says in Eccl. 9: 10, “Whatsoever thy hand findeth to do, do it with thy might; for there is no work, nor device, nor knowledge, nor wisdom, in the grave, whither thou goest.” Modern orthodoxy makes nonsense of the text by re-writing it so that it will read in this way: “Whatsoever thy hand findeth to do, do it with thy might; for there is an abundance of work, no end to devices, fullness of knowledge and wisdom in the grave, whither thou goest.” You see the conflict between the ancient and the modern version of this text. If men know more in death than they did in life, then Solomon blundered; for he bases the necessity for energetic action inp. 83 life upon the hypothesis that there is no knowledge, or wisdom, or device, in the grave.
Mr. Thoughtful.—What, then, do I understand your view to be of the condition of men in death?
Mr. B.—Why, sir, I could not express it more exactly than I have already done in quoting the passages which I have read to you. “The dead know not anything.” “His [man’s] breath goeth forth, he returneth to his earth; in that very day his thoughts perish.” “There is no work, nor device, nor knowledge, nor wisdom, in the grave, whither thou goest.” To express it in a word, the dead, between the time of their decease and their resurrection at the coming of the Lord, “sleep.” See how clearly Paul sets forth this fact in 1 Thess. 4: 13–18: “But I would not have you to be ignorant, brethren, concerning them which are asleep, that ye sorrow not, even as others which have no hope. For if we believe that Jesus died and rose again, even so them also which sleep in Jesus will God bring with him [from the dead]. For this we say unto you by the word of the Lord, that we which are alive and remain unto the coming of the Lord shall not prevent them which are asleep. For the Lord himself shall descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel, and with the trump of God; and the dead in Christ shall rise first: then we which are alive and remain shall be caught up together with them in the clouds, to meet the Lord in the air; and so shall we ever be with the Lord. Wherefore comfort one another with these words.” Note it! Paul does not say, as he certainly would have done, had it been true, “Your friends are in heaven; wherefore comfort one another with these words;” but he says in substance, “Comfort yourselves with the thought that your friends who now sleep in the grave, will be resurrected when the Lord comes, and, together with us be caught up to glory.” The point of deliverance for the dead, and that of redemption for the living, are located alike at the advent.
Mr. T.—Then what will you do with the parable of the rich man and Lazarus?
Mr. B.—What will I do with it? Why, I will do nothing with it. As you say, it is a parable; and by common consent, parables can never be quoted to refute doctrines which are based upon plain Scripture statements. They are very loose in their structure, frequently representing things which are not, and never can be, as though they were actual facts. Jotham, for example (Judges 9: 7–15), declares that on a certain occasion, the trees determined to choose a king from among their number to rule over them, and he gives the language which each employed in turn. Now we know that this never took place. Yet it was admissible to represent it as actually transpiring; since the law of parables allows a resort to absurdities in their formation. Parables usually seek to impress but one great truth, and everything is made to contribute to that one desire. In the parable of the rich man and Lazarus, the prominent idea in the mind of the Saviour, was that a man might be very wealthy and yet be damned; or very poor, and be saved. That, therefore, as we say, was the “one foot on which the parable walked;” in other words, that was the peculiar doctrine which he sought to impress by the parable; the remaining parts being simply auxiliary to that end. They were not based upon actual facts of history; but like Jotham’s talking trees they serve to illustrate the central conception that the possession of wealth does not furnish evidence of divine favor. To deny this, and to insist that the parable as a whole was necessarily or even possibly true, in all of its parts, would be to go against the positive declarations of the word of God and to reverse the law of parables. But I must pass. Before doing so, let me repeat the statement that unsound doctrine is an exceedingly dangerous commodity in which to deal.
The churches having adopted the false notion that dead men still live, the Devil has taken advantage of this fact to entangle them in the skillfully woven net of modern Spiritism. Having repudiated those scriptures which teach that God only hath immortality (1 Tim. 6: 14–16), and denied that eternal life is the gift of God through Christ, while the wages of sin is death (Rom. 6: 23), they have altered the record to make it read that all men are immortal as well as God, and that the wages of sin is eternal conscious misery in the lake of fire. Satan, with an art peculiar to himself, having first induced men to adopt the illogical and unscriptural dogma of eternal torment, now turns around, and leads them to adopt “restorationism” as the only escape from the absurdities of an unending hell with its infinitude of horrors.
Mr. T.—What did you tell us a few nights since respecting the destiny of the wicked? If I recollect aright, it is your view that they will be punished according to their deserts in the lake of fire, and then destroyed.
Mr. B.—Yes, sir. Your recollection is correct. If you would like to look up the matter somewhat at your leisure, I will give you some texts bearing upon the point.
Mr. T.—Do so, if you please.
Mr. B.—Very well; here are some that occur to me which you can take down: Matt. 16: 27; Luke 12: 47, 48; Ps. 37: 10, 38; Prov. 10: 25; 12: 7; Isa. 41: 11, 12; Jer. 10: 24; Obad. 16; Mal. 4: 1; Ps. 21: 9; 97: 3; Matt. 3: 12; 7: 19; 13: 24–30, 36–43; John 15: 6; Heb. 6: 8; Rev. 18: 8; Rev. 20: 7–9. If you look up these texts, you will find that they teach two things very clearly: 1. That the punishment of every man, so far as pain is concerned, will be graduated according to his deserts; 2. That the wicked will finally be blotted out of existence. To such a retribution no reasonable man can object. The infliction of suffering, when regulated to meet the demands in each individual case, is just; and it must be admitted that God has a right to deny a place in his universe to all who will not obey the laws made by the Ruler of that universe. Such a theory of punishment will drive no man into “restorationism” in order to escape its conflict with the plainest principles of equity.
There is another tendency in the churches at the present time which is so marked and so dangerous that I cannot leave this subject without alluding to it. I refer to the rapidly increasing favor with which Protestantism now regards Catholicism. Were not the facts in the case so patent that their existence is placed beyond question, the present situation would be almost incredible. Three hundred years ago, the Reformation grappled with the Papacy in a struggle which must have resulted in the extermination of those connected with the former, had it not seriously weakened the latter. Luther and his co-laborers denounced the church of Rome as the mother of harlots, whose character, history, and destiny are so fearfully pictured in the book of Revelation. The result was a complete and, as it was supposed, a final separation between the Reformers and the corrupt body from which they came out. Now if Luther was right, and if his movement was justifiable, then it must be true that the church of Rome was indeed the mother of harlots as alleged. If this be not the case, then the Reformers were guilty of misrepresentation and abuse of the mother church, which should forever consign them to infamy, and fully justifies the charges which Rome brings against them. On the other hand, if the Reformers were right in their charges against the papacy, then it represents the mother of harlots still; for according to the book of God, she was never to be reformed; but was to be the recipient of the seven last plagues, and utterly destroyed in her sins at the coming of Christ, as you will learn by reading 2 Thess. 2: 8 and Rev. Chaps. 16, 17, 18.
Mr. T.—Do you think that the Catholic church is really as corrupt as it was formerly? You know they used to put the saints to death.
Mr. B.—That is true, and if they do not do the same things to-day, it is simply because the circumstances have changed. For six thousand years the Devil has ravaged this world, tempting and destroying men to as great an extent as possible. We read, however, in Rev. 20: 1–3, that the time will come when he will tempt no one for a thousand years. Why? because his character will be changed? No; simply because he will be bound during that time. Just so with the papacy. If Romanists do not resort to the fagot and the stake in our day, it is simply because they are prevented from so doing by the loss of the power which they once possessed. The spirit of intolerance is just as rife among them to-day as it was in the past. They have never abated one jot or tittle from their arrogant claims to supremacy. Never has there fallen from their lips one word of acknowledgment that their course of conduct in the past was not reconcilable with the principles of right. Pope Leo XIII. is as stout in claiming that he is the vicegerent of God on the earth as was Hildebrand. Within your recollection and mine the infamous doctrine of papal infallibility has been flaunted afresh in the face of modern civilization, having received the sanction of an Ecumenical Council of the Catholic church. But I need not multiply words upon this point, as already we have the Scriptures for it, that the mother of harlots will remain such until she receives her just doom in the seven last plagues at the coming of the Lord.
Mr. T.—Well, I do not know but you are right there. I have never looked at it in just that light before, however.
Mr. B.—There can be no question about it. Catholicism is either the great mystery of iniquity, or else Protestantism is a fraud and a cheat.
Maud.—Well, what about it anyhow, father? I don’t see what all this talk has to do with the fall of the churches.
Mr. B.—Let me explain, Maud. We are all agreed that Protestantism in the outset was heaven-born, and that its antagonism to the church of Rome originated in a just conception of the moral or rather of the immoral character of that church. Three hundred years have passed since Luther proclaimed that Catholicism, when judged by the facts of history and the word of God, was found to be hopelessly apostate. Now, as he was right in this, and as he called out from the Roman connection the very best element that it contained, it follows that Romanism, to say the least, is as far from God to-day as it was then. This being true, if Protestantism is what it was in the days of Luther, its clergy should be just as hostile to the papacy now as Luther was in his day. But what are the facts? Manifestly, a mighty change has come over the spirit of the Protestant ministry within the last forty years. Down to that time red-hot thunderbolts were constantly hurled from orthodox pulpits at the Vatican. Not so to-day. If the battle may be said to be going on at all, there are so few engaged in it on the orthodox side, the firing is so desultory, and the shots so far between, that one is reminded of the resistance offered by those who are just ready to strike the flag and surrender a fort, rather than the impetuous assault and fierce cannonade of an attacking army. Pius IX., the formulator of the theory of the Immaculate Conception of the Virgin, and the manipulator of the council which promulgated the infallibility dogma, dies, and a prominent orthodox clergyman of America sends him straight to heaven. Mr. T.—Who was that? Mr. B.—It was Henry Ward Beecher.p. 84 Other ministers also were not far behind him in their utterances, and yet no special commotion was created by such talk as this. A hundred years ago, such sentiments coming from such a source, would have shaken orthodoxy from center to circumference. In our time it is looked upon as commendable charity rather than censurable and dangerous doctrine. But more anon; I see that it is late.