AdventAI

WHICH DAY IS THE SABBATH?

By F. Peabody

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 14., April 7, 1885

BY ELD. F. PEABODY.

It is strange to see how the opponents of the seventh-day Sabbath disagree among themselves; and certainly it is astonishing to see a person set up several contradictory positions and then demolish them by an assumption that is contrary both to reason and the Scriptures.

The editor of the New York Weekly Witness, in his issue of Feb. 26, has undertaken to tell which day is the Sabbath. It does not require many words, but he has used a great many and said some strange things. We first quote from his article this statement: “The starting point of the week which was to end on the seventh day, or Sabbath, can never be exactly known, or what day it corresponds with in our week.” If things are in such a doubtful condition as this, why should he even attempt to decide which day is the Sabbath? When he is through, it would only be guess work anyway. But I think the Lord did tell his people the very day on which his Sabbath came. In Ex. 16 we read that he gave manna six days, but withheld it on the Sabbath. After the people had had such an experience as this for forty years, they certainly ought to have known just where the seventh-day Sabbath came in. Luke must have thought so, for he says, even after Christ was crucified, “They rested the Sabbath-day according to the commandment.” Chap. 23:56.

The second point I notice, is a statement that no man can disannul or dispute: “The ceremonial law of the Israelites, has been regarded as obsolete by Christians from the time of Paul downward. It is superseded by Christ’s teachings; but nothing can supersede or render obsolete the moral law expressed in the ten commandments.” So we say. The ceremonial law was taken out of the way by Christ. It was fulfilled by him. He “nailed it to the cross.” Just as our friend has said, in substance, this did not touch the moral law expressed in the ten commandments. He says, “Nothing can supersede it;” and certainly all agree with him. Now, admitting this to be true, and all must admit it, what would necessarily follow?—We should all have to keep the seventh day as the Sabbath of the Lord our God. Why? Because one of the unchangeable ten commandments so teaches. How plain he made this; but he was not satisfied to leave it so. Everybody would understand this.

Now the editor undertakes to do what he says nothing can do; viz., supersede or make obsolete the expressed moral law. He says: “The essence of the fourth commandment is, Six days’ labor, and then keep a Sabbath.” This is not the expressed command, but the essence after being distilled by man. This, of course, is the no-particular-day theory. But let us see if he is willing to leave it so. He further says: “It is evident that in the apostles’ day it was the first day of the week, not the seventh; the day on which Christ rose from the dead; not the day he lay in the tomb, that the Christians observed.”

He is now bidding for a change of days, which is superseding the moral law as expressed in the fourth commandment. That says, the seventh day, not the first, is the “Sabbath of the Lord.” On this change he says:— “This change the Lord himself seems to have sanctioned.” What! Christ sanction a change in the moral law as expressed in the ten commandments! We had agreed that Christ only set aside the ceremonial law, and that nothing could touch the moral law as expressed in the ten commandments. But how does he say Christ sanctioned the change? “By appearing miraculously among them on two occasions on the first day of the week; viz., his resurrection day, and the next first day while they were met for worship.” If all he has assumed in the above statement be correct, there is nothing in it to prove a change of the Sabbath. There is nothing said about a Sabbath or a change, but we understand that the proof he wishes to draw from this is that Christ met with them “miraculously.”

As he did not give the authority for the above statement, we shall have to suppose he referred to John 20:19, 26. As regards the 19th verse we can only say, the disciples were not met there to worship, as far, at least, as we can learn from this scripture; but we are not left in the dark as regards the frame of mind the disciples were in on that occasion. Mark, in recording this meeting, says that Christ “upbraided them with their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they believed not them which had seen him after he was risen,” etc. Mark 16:9–14. Our friend says they had met for worship. This is assumed in the face of evidence to the contrary. John 20:26 is, we suppose, the other case referred to, but we cannot be certain, because the meeting spoken of here could not be upon the next first day, as the record says, “And after eight days,” etc. The meeting was sometime after eight days, just what day our friend cannot tell.

The approval must be then in Christ’s miraculously appearing to them. Our friend has only mentioned two such instances, while there are three in this series of meetings. John 21:14 speaks of this third meeting as being the third. Now if the first two meetings changed the day, one will have a like result by the same method of reasoning. In fact, we have shown that only one of them could have been on the first day of the week, as the second was after eight days. Now, if that one meeting changed the Sabbath, what about the other two? They must have done as much. But let us look at the third meeting. Christ appeared to them while they were fishing. There was something miraculous about this meeting, too. They had toiled all night, and had caught nothing; but Christ said to them: “Cast the net on the right side of the ship, and ye shall find.” Did this sanction the change of the Sabbath? After all, this proves too much, and therefore proves nothing.

But now our friend tells us who did appoint the first day as the Sabbath. He says: “The day was appointed as well as observed by the apostles.” But this not appearing really to satisfy him, he makes the following bold assertion: “It therefore follows that the change of the seventh to the first day of the week was appointed by Him who was Lord of the Sabbath. . . . And the fourth commandment, with this change, is as binding on the first day of the week as it was on the seventh, and not only is the command to keep the first day holy, but inferentially it forbids the observance of any other weekly day of rest.”

Now let us sum up his positions. (1) He says the count of the exact day cannot be known. (2) A Sabbath is to be kept after six days of labor, but on no particular day. (3) A change was made from the seventh to the first day of the week by the apostles, which was appointed by Christ. (4) The fourth commandment makes it binding on us to observe the first day of the week. And (5) the fourth commandment inferentially forbids us to keep any other day as a weekly Sabbath.

Now if his first position is correct, the second might be. But if these two were correct, what about the third? Lo! all at once, the seventh day in the count is found, and the obligation to observe it transferred to the first day. And the fourth position brings the fourth commandment forward, and enforces the observance of the first day.

Here we have the editor arrayed against himself. Here is a particular day, but not the one expressly commanded. Now what shall be done with the fourth commandment? If the editor will inform us how he can read in the first day of the week and not render it obsolete, we will listen. If he is still at a loss to know where to find a seventh day, we would suggest that he will always find it just before the first.

Such a process of reasoning as the above, reminds us of the precocious son, who, returning from school, proposed to prove to his father that there were three chickens on the table when there were but two. Pointing to one, he said, “That is one,” and then to the other, “That is two.” The father said that was true. “Then,” triumphantly exclaimed the young man, “one and two make three.” The father took one chicken, and put it on the mother’s plate, and taking the other himself, said, “Mother, you eat that, and I will eat this; Dick may have the third!”

Now, why did not our editor tell us at first that the fourth commandment had been so changed as to enforce the first day of the week? and not try to explain that the day was lost, and then before he got through find it all right, but behold! it was changed? Why does he first say the moral law as expressed in the ten commandments is unchangeable, and then, in the absence of the least evidence, say it was changed so as to enforce the observance of a day as the Sabbath that God never rested upon, or blessed, or sanctified? Let him tell us; for we do not now see.